5th Gen Two different regions for two different games?

[DXrobots]

What would you guys think if they made to brand new regions for both games. You start in one region and then make your way to the other, And then make unlockable side quests and legendaries by connecting with the opposite version of what you have.

 

[JAK3]

It would be interesting but I don't think they will do it, seeing as that is quite alot of work for one game, and it would seem quite cramped, but atleast it would give us something to do.

 

[A Pixy]

That would be huge. Very huge. Too huge for a Pokemon game. >_>

 

[Kieran]

Sounds great but I doubt they would squeeze all their ideas into one game.

 

[BeachBoy]

I'd be... disappointed. =/ Can we please focus solely on one (hopefully large) region, rather than spreading everything all over the place? I mean, it's a nice idea and all (and it'd last long, a plus for me), but I'd rather have one region for both Black & White.

 

[mikey]

I'd be... disappointed. =/ Can we please focus solely on one (hopefully large) region, rather than spreading everything all over the place? I mean, it's a nice idea and all (and it'd last long, a plus for me), but I'd rather have one region for both Black & White.

I agree completely.

Two regions would be kind of cool, but I'd rather have one big new region for both games. Plus, that would be a lot of work for the creators.

 

[Nick]

What would you guys think if they made to brand new regions for both games. You start in one region and then make your way to the other, And then make unlockable side quests and legendaries by connecting with the opposite version of what you have.

I don't know how I would feel about that.

It would be logical, not only would it bring a different experience to both games (which can be considered a bad thing as well), but it'll bring up the logic that Pokémon are exclusive to one version and others are exclusive in another. While I would say it's illogical for a set like Black and White, or Diamond and Pearl, or something like that... it would really be something interesting for reasoning behind limiting some Pokémon to one version, and some to another.

But at the same time, like I said, why would there be two different regions in one generation exclusive to one game? Most of the features limited to one version are limited to simply Pokémon. Limiting a whole region, a whole experience of things that could occur... that seems kind of steep. So while I like your idea for the logic behind exclusive Pokémon, it's excessive for a generation. It's one thing to want two regions included, but two different regions?

 

[GlitchCity]

That would be cool, more exploring to do :D

It would be better than to have Hoenn in the games, just add on an extra region to Black & White. But the only way I see them do that is if the Isshu region is too small to withstand on its own (like how johto was)