[Hack of the Month] Voting - June 2009

[insectduel]

You shouldn't have voted for Moonshine just because you can understand its language.

Exactly, even Touhoumon has Japanese language when the new game comes out. Hacks should be only based on scripts, graphics, gameplay, bugfindings, etc.

The reason why I vote DarkBlue because of good scripting and uses Diamond and Pearl Pokemon.

 

[dragonarche]

I voted for Pokémon DarkBlue Version
the tiles look cool and nice palletes

 

[Mana1]

Exactly, even Touhoumon has Japanese language when the new game comes out. Hacks should be only based on scripts, graphics, gameplay, bugfindings, etc.

The reason why I vote DarkBlue because of good scripting and uses Diamond and Pearl Pokemon.

Actually its perfectly fair to vote for one that you can understand, its hard to tell if the scripts are good if you don't understand the language I think, and voting just on looks is rather blind too.

Voting for a story isn't perfect either because you don't know how well it has been implemented XD so yeah.

 

[Lady Berlitz]

Actually its perfectly fair to vote for one that you can understand, its hard to tell if the scripts are good if you don't understand the language I think, and voting just on looks is rather blind too.

Voting for a story isn't perfect either because you don't know how well it has been implemented XD so yeah.

Scripts are whole new languages altogether; they aren't English or Spanish. I don't see a point in voting for "how well a story has been implemented," because a story can easily be changed based on how the game was made.

Though it may affect gameplay and it does help to know a common knowledge of the language to understand the storyline of the game, it shouldn't affect how good or bad the game is.

 

[øbliteration]

Moonshine... looks like i'm in the minority here however.
i think because i like a more professional hack, and tiles don't necessarily do it for me as scripts do

Spoiler:

i can't read spanish >.<

 

[Halcyon]

Pokemon Crono.
The storyline is good, so as the tiles and palette.

 

[Samike360]

I vote for Pokemon DarkBlue because although I haven't got around to playing it, I like the tiles and the looks of it, and I can't get Crono to work on my emulator :(

 

[Alec_]

Perhaps. I should vote for Pokemon DarkBlue. I know it's in a Spanish Language. But the story seems awesome. The Scripts / Events are truly wonderful. Especially the Tiles.
So i vote for Pokemon Dark Blue Version.

~Fairytales.

 

[pikalax]

I played Chrono. After talking to Lance, I challenged the fisherman, only to find that Poochyena had disappeared! Plus it's crudely translated from Italian... So Chrono is out for me. Moonshine is not available on the thread itself. I guess that leaves Dark Blue.

 

[Disturbed]

I voted Moonshine, because of Ninja Caterpie's determination to keep it going, and the commendable amount of effort he has spent on it over the year.

 

[SonicBlazePlatinum]

Pokemon Crono has a glitch where you lose your Pokemon. Pokemon DarkBlue has changed tilesets and a beta release. I'm voting for Moonshine because I like hacks with Fire Red and Emerald tilesets instead of hacks with edited tilesets.(I like hacks with changed tilesets too) I'm also voting for Moonshine because the beta hasn't been released yet.

 

[Vrai]

Moonshine takes my vote, as I think NC has definitely worked hard on it. :D
It's awesome, in any case.

 

[Logan]

Jake3 pretty much sums it up. We need to look past flashy graphics, and we need to take a look at the bigger picture. In this view, Moonshine wins by a distance.

 

[Chibi Robo]

I voted pokemon moonshine because NC deffinetly put in an outstanding ammount of effort
Great scripts
And I just love the unedited FR tileset

 

[derozio]

Pokemon Crono for me as the tiles and sprites are simply beautiful!(I wish I could understand any language in the world so that I can play a wide variety of games!)

 

[dragonarche]

I vote for pokemon crono
its got nice tiles and
scripts and a verry exciting storyline








~dragonarche

 

[Master Terrador]

Crono gets my vote...
Why?:

-The Tiles and Sprites are beautiful...
-The Storyline is amazing and exciting...
-And the Scripts are really amazing...

>Dante< Really outdid himself with this hack...^^

~Shadow~

 

[pokemon trainer blaze]

Pokemon Moonshine is the one i choose

 

[Xenosaga]

I vote Crono bcuz its cool o_O!!! Also The Tiles Kinda Awesome ;D

 

[Fleur]

I vote for Pokemon Crono
Crono
Tiles ++
Story +
Scripts +++
Moonshine
Tiles -
Story /(Nothing)
Scripts /(Nothing)
DarkBlue
Tiles - (I don`t like this style)
Story +
Scripts +
~LaFleur