4th Gen What Exactly is Manaphy?

Is Manaphy a Legend in your opinion?

  • Yes

    Votes: 17 100.0%

  • No

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Total voters
    17
Status
Not open for further replies.
Empty Pot

Empty Pot

a new beginning...
    • 1,234
    Posts
    15
    Years
    I have two questions about Manaphy. The first one is what is Manaphy? Most Pokemon in the game is an animal in real life. Though I know not all are considering last time I checked, there is no giant, rampaging monsters destroying time and space currently.

    My second question is for everyones opinion. Is Manaphy a Legendary? At first I believed it was, but it evolves from Phione and it can make eggs. Yet it has no gender (if I remember right) and there is only one on Mystery Dungeon 2. So what is your opinion?
     
    Firstly it doesn't evolve from Phione, just if you breed it you get Phione instead of Manaphy for some reason.

    Secondly I'm not really sure what it is, it doesn't have to be based off anything like a Tauros, it can just be an original creature
     
    RickySlaughter said:
    I have two questions about Manaphy. The first one is what is Manaphy? Most Pokemon in the game is an animal in real life. Though I know not all are considering last time I checked, there is no giant, rampaging monsters destroying time and space currently.

    My second question is for everyones opinion. Is Manaphy a Legendary? At first I believed it was, but it evolves from Phione and it can make eggs. Yet it has no gender (if I remember right) and there is only one on Mystery Dungeon 2. So what is your opinion?
    Click to expand...

    It's not opinion Manaphy is offically a legendary. Also, Phione does not evolve into Manaphy, Manaphy just makes Phione eggs.

    Manaphy is also in Pokemon Ranger thats how to get a legit one then transfer it over to D/P/Plat.
     
    Phione doesn't evolve into Manaphy, meaning there is only one per game, unless you transfer more. It fits all the criteria for a legendary, and it has been confirmed by pokemon.com as a legendary. It's definitely a legendary.

    EDIT: Sorta beaten
     
    Yeah! He may be a completely fictional character not taken from any design of any animal. He's officially a legend. Phione too is confirmed to be a legend.

    @ Tinhead Bruce: I too am beaten! lol XD.
     
    RickySlaughter said:
    I have two questions about Manaphy. The first one is what is Manaphy? Most Pokemon in the game is an animal in real life. Though I know not all are considering last time I checked, there is no giant, rampaging monsters destroying time and space currently.

    Manaphy + Phione's based on the Sea Angels (also known as Cliones), which is a type of sea slugs which swims by flapping their wing-like appendages.

    My second question is for everyones opinion. Is Manaphy a Legendary? At first I believed it was, but it evolves from Phione and it can make eggs. Yet it has no gender (if I remember right) and there is only one on Mystery Dungeon 2. So what is your opinion?

    Manaphy's an official Legendary - as it's confirmed by Pokemon.com + it even has its own movie + only one through Pokemon Ranger etc. Phione is ALSO a legendary but rather a failure one >.> By the way - Phione doesn't evolve into Manaphy unfortunately
    Click to expand...

    My answers are in the quote + bold xD
     
    Last edited:
    HirakuNoShadow said:
    My answers are in the quote + bold xD
    Click to expand...

    Wow, I would have never though they could be sea angels. Thanks for the info.


    And thanks to everyone you stated it is a legend and Phione does not evolve into Manaphy. It's been awhile since I had my Manaphy Egg and I though it started as a Phonie. I guess I was wrong. :s
     
    Since Nintendo told me that Manaphy is a legendary Pokemon, then in my opinion its a legendary Pokemon


    :t354:TG
     
    where the hell is the option that says "Garbage"

    j.k, but no i dont count it as a legendary, since it can breed
     
    It doesn't evolve from Phione and it is officially a legendary thus opinions don't matter.
     
    Calvo819 said:
    where the hell is the option that says "Garbage"

    j.k, but no i dont count it as a legendary, since it can breed
    Click to expand...

    It's offically legendary already
    There are a number of other legendaries who break usual legend rules
    For example Latias and Latios have genders
     
    There are plenty of Pokemon that don't have a "real life counterpart."

    Manaphy (and Phione) is an official legendary. An ugly legendary, at that.
     
    Last time I checked I haven't seen any animal that looks remotely like Mr. Mime or Jynx, though now that you mention it, Manaphy does look vaguely like a sea angel.
     
    Status
    Not open for further replies.
    Back
    Top