weedle_mchairybug
Banned
- 2,688
- Posts
- 20
- Years
- Seen Aug 29, 2020
Ash's dream is not to be a specific element's master, what a gym-leader is, that's why he is not turning into one.
You also confuse Ash's and Misty's goal. Ash want to win, while Misty wants to collect, train and research. Misty is simply told to quit being childish, grow up, take notice you already reached your dream. Ash'd need the same slap (unless he is still 10 years old which rises questions).
Also, Ash is a Deformed Clone Twin of Gary, who turned to be a Pokemon Researcher.
An Elite Four shares the title with three other person, that's why Ash can't be one. Not to mention Ash is mentally challenged, what disqualifies him from being an Elite Four. After 4 league he still uses types against pokemons which are immun to that type. Come to think of it as being a Gym-leader is about loosing/letting the newbie win if (s)he has the necessary skills, that's not for Ash who'd never let anyone win a badge.
Ash could be a G-men though. Probably. But there is no such thing as a "champion trainer". If you think on "pokemon champion" we are all waiting for that. But no champion is restricted to using only one type.
Now "Top Coordinators" are matching the definition with "Pokemon Champion", thus not at all mean there should be "Pokemon Master" title:
"The title is bestowed upon Coordinators who have won a Grand Festival" - translated into trainer-version "...who have won a Pokemon League". But that's what "Pokemon Champion" is.
As DBZ fan pointed out, being Gym Leader =/= Water-type master, something both the games and even the anime made very clear. In fact, common sense, if being a Gym Leader actually did mean being a Water Pokémon Master, that means Misty wouldn't even NEED to go travel by herself, because even before GCYL, Misty was already a gym leader (in fact, it was stated as early as Episode 7, Waterflowers of Cerulean City, and her sisters don't even deny it). And BTW, Lorelei/Prima of the Elite 4 was specifically referred to as being a Pokémon Master in some sources including, yes, the Anime. In fact, Misty even idolized her. Use common sense, if she wanted to reach Prima's level, don't you think she would, I don't know, go for Elite 4 at the very least if not champion? And BTW, Masters don't lose against rookies easily, which is unfortunately what happens a lot with Gym Leaders (I believe that's even one of Blaine's complaints in Riddle Me This). And then there's the Whirl Cup, which explicitly stated that winning that would, if not make Misty a Water Pokémon Master, certainly would get her far closer to the goal.
So no, Misty definitely got the short end of the stick. And let me remind you that Iris has a similar goal to Misty yet she didn't even bother getting the Gym Leading position, instead electing to actually continue her journey, and this is DESPITE her being due to leave the cast anyways. That should prove to you that becoming a Gym Leader obviously cannot get you to become a Pokémon Master, whether it be of a specific type or in general (otherwise, Iris would have jumped at the opportunity to become a Gym Leader).
And do I really need to remind you that in Kanto, Ash also wanted to collect Pokémon (he ended up dismayed whenever he learned that Gary outranked him in amount of Pokémon caught)? Or that most times, he observes Pokémon through the Pokedex, even AFTER Gary was effectively retired as a rival.