4th Gen Which starter did you choose?

[neworleans-7]

I started SS with Totodile and I traded with a friend to get Chikorita. I just got HG and I started with Cyndaquil so now I have all 3 starters :).

 

[Babs9642]

I got all 3
but my favorite is definetly Cyndaquil because he becomes Typhlosion and i beat the whole game including frist pokemon league with just him

 

[Haunt]

Ah the starter Pokemon. Always a choice I hate making in each game as I like them all.

For gold, it's quite simple as to my reasoning. Despite being arguably one of the easier starters to choose, Cyndaquil was also my first choice back when I had a japanese copy of Gold a long time ago, as well as the starter I went with when I eventually got the english version. And so now with Heart Gold, the decision was quite simple to pick Cyndaquil once again, mostly for the reminiscent memories :D

Although, sadly I will be replacing him with Entei from the shiny beast event.

 

[SceptileGirl]

my starter Pokemon is cyndaquil but whenever I see all the poke-balls at the beginning of the game I really want to choose totodile!:laugh:

 

[MasterΩMind]

I hate them. It's impossible to choose between them so they always make me start again about 15 times before I think "No, this is the best one." In every game. But the first one I chose was Totodile. He looked somewhat like an evil minion in Crocodile form.

 

[mewditto555]

Cyndaquil, since he has major fighting power, and also easy on the eyes.

 

[olih]

Cyndaquil, and I'm glad I did. I have an all-poning lvl 100 Typhlosion

 

[Lynnth]

I chose a cyndaquil in SoulSilver, who then went on to be my first legitimate level 100 pokemon as a typhlosion. In HeartGold I chose a chikorita, because in the original Gold, Silver and Crystal I always went with cyndaquil and totodile, and I decided that I would like to go hard mode and pick up a chikorita instead.

 

[JustinDestruction]

On Soul Silver I chose Totodile, and on Heart Gold I picked Cyndaquil!

 

[NamelessGuy]

I chose Totodile, for obvious reasons. Good moveset, evolves into Feralipwner.

 

[pokemanoscar]

Cyndaquil. he is amazing and pwns everything. Plus hes cool

 

[k0n0k0]

I always choose Chikorita.

 

[DarkViper]

Totodile because he is just plain awesome

 

[Mig144]

I chose Cyndaquil. in silver versoion traded a random pokemon for chikorita from my gold version for some reason i never chose Totodile.

 

[Cathar]

I owned Gold, Silver and Crystal, and played it with Cindaquil, Chikorita and Totodile, respectively.

For Soulsilver, I'll do a Monotype Challenge Ground, so I won't use any of them ^^

 

[XFakerX]

cyndaquil, as totodile don't seem to have very good moves and chikorita is uhhh worse?
so i picked cyndaquil and i used a lapras for my water type

 

[Mew~]

Totodile for HG and Cyndaquil for SS.

 

[Maj. Cor]

I started with a Totodile. This was before I found out that Meganium is the best final evolution-staged Pokémon out of the three. My Feraligatr was nice, yes, but the max attack and defense Charmander I got for it was quite the better fit for me. I ended up getting all of the Johto starters anyways.​

 

[Eon-Rider]

I'm surprised I haven't posting in this thread.

I started off with Chikorita as I knew it would provide me with the biggest challenge. There was no other reason for choosing it. =\

 

[Maj. Cor]

I'm surprised I haven't posting in this thread.

I started off with Chikorita as I knew it would provide me with the biggest challenge. There was no other reason for choosing it. =\

Lucky you. You chose the best choice.
I personally don't care for the Johto starters, but if I had to pick one, I'd pick Chikorita.​