WPC #27 - POLL

[Logiedan]

Weekly Pixel Art Challenge: #27 - POLL
Hosted by: Logiedan
​

Theme: Leprechaunity

Vote for two entries max. Votes are public, so we can see who voted what; if there are more than two votes from one person then the first two in descending order will be counted (unless stated otherwise in thread).
​

Voting Rules:

• One vote per person (unless stated otherwise)
• You may not vote for yourself
• You can post which one you voted for and why
• Critique is really appreciated to help those who struggled in votes!

This Week's Rules:

• Canvas Size: Unrestricted. Include all three sprites in one image.
• Palette Requirements: 24 colours max.
• Transparency: Optional (WILL NOT COUNT AS A COLOUR)
• Animation: None
• Other: N/A

List of contestants: 14
NOTE: This is in no particular order or related to the order of entries below.

Chesu, Retribution, Limanya, ShadowMirror, tajaros, GolurkIsDaBomb, Silversnk, ★Hoenn★, blackmoonflower, kinataki, Discordant, vaporeon7, Fenneking and Aryan143

Entries:

Entry 1

Entry 2

Entry 3

Entry 4

Entry 5

Entry 6

Entry 7

​

 

[Logiedan]

Entry 8

Entry 9

Entry 10

Entry 11

Entry 12

Entry 13

Entry 14

​

 

[ShadowMirror]

I voted for 1 and 7

I think that they were executed great, but congrats to everyone who participated

 

[Magykx]

I chose 7 & 12.
In 7, I love how Carracosta looks green. It almost looks like it should be it's shiny form imo.

In 12, I absolutely love Moltres. Its fire looks amazing green!

 

[Elaitenstile]

6 & 8. Eighth is my personal favourite. Love the shamrock designs, and Kricketune is recoloured really well. Sixth one I chose because of the fluorescent Quilava.

 

[Foxrally]

8 and 13 were my picks. I absolutely love the kriketune's white mustache, and the pot-of-gold Victreebell is epic. Oh, an the steelix. Awesome.

I love 13 for the colouring, mainly. Very serene and calm.

 

[Demon Days]

Oh great, someone else had the same idea as me. :c

 

[vaporeon7]

I thought the way the shamrock was used in 8 was amazing. I also like the colour palette used in 13, however, I thought the shamrock didn't look as nice in it.

 

[kinataki]

@Discordant
i was almost going to do them too :P but i didn't :P

and i voted for 6&9
6 is my favourite because green looks super in those pokemons and the pokemon picks were hard to recolour, but suprisingly the one who did those made them perfect.
9 is really good too. the colours doesn't really look good on that victini but it still looks perfect!!

 

[Ace.]

7 and 13 are obviously the best. I really like the colors in both!

 

[Aryan143]

I voted for entries 3 and 8 because I love the colours in 3 and the Shamrock design in 8.

 

[Limanya]

I voted for 7 and 12 because both have good color choices that aren't hurting my eyes.

 

[Golurks Were Meant to Fly]

I voted for entries 5 and 10. I felt like both entries had really nice pallets, and did a good job not saturating the sprites too much. 5 did a really good job with the acid green, because that green is tricky in my opinion. I love the main green on 10, and the shamrocks floating off of jumpluff like stray seeds was really smart!

 

[Vegetunks937]

Mine is for 3 and 8. I liked them

 

[Brane]

To be blunt, I feel the tone variation in a lot of the sprites wasn't the best it could have been. My vote had to go to number 8, this one was closest to having balanced tones, and I absolutely love what they've done with the clovers. Especially the Steelix!

 

[Silversnk]

I choose 8 because of the tone variation, it stands over the rest and the shamrocks are great. I think that's more yellow than green though, maybe the contrast give my eyes that illusion, but if it qualifies, then that's the one I'm voting for as my favourite.

The other one would be number 10. I like that hue a lot and the Shamrocks around Jumpluff are really nice.

 

[Sirfetch’d]

While all of the entries were great I decided to vote for 7 and 10. I felt that those entries did the best jobs with the pallets and the shading was also very clean and nice. The Hydreigon in entry 7 was my favorite of all of the entries because I feel that it was done perfectly, it is very nice and clean looking, and the shades of green used look nice together. The shamrock was also nicely placed.

 

[Demon Days]

Welp, looks like I need to stop thinking about real-life, saturated clovers while making recolour palettes. :c

 

[Logiedan]

Winners

1st Place - Fenneking

2nd Place - GolurkIsDaBomb

3rd Place - blackmoonflower

3rd Place - kinataki

Honourable Mention(s)

Honourable Mention - Silversnk

---

Thank you for participating. Discussion of results can be in General Pixel Art Discussion thread.
The Medal Ledger is all up to date as of this post.
​