• Our software update is now concluded. You will need to reset your password to log in. In order to do this, you will have to click "Log in" in the top right corner and then "Forgot your password?".
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.
    Register

Map Rating/Review Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Ninja Caterpie

Ninja Caterpie

AAAAAAAAAAAAA
5,979
Posts
16
Years
    • Well, it's sorta hard to make the bottom mountains less empty...I dunno, I just find it hard :\

    Well, to keep this ontopic, I gve your map an 8/10.
    As Disturbed said, the tree's aren't meant to be on top of the rock like -that-.
    Other than that, I like the shape of the mountains and...yeah. The paths look nice, although the irregularity of the stairs will be annoying.
    Oh, there shouldn't be grass in towns, but that's just me.
     
    Luck

    Luck

    ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
    6,779
    Posts
    16
    Years
    • Seen May 20, 2023
    Alright, these were the maps i made in my spare time. F.Y.I, everyone knows how capable i am of inserting tiles, i just used this tileset to test it out.

    Map name: silon village(pending)
    game: firered
    comments: a small simple area.
    Spoiler:


    Map name: Silon meadows(pending
    Game: firered
    comments: a nice simple map. The dead end is just there.
    Spoiler:


    map name: almair city
    Game: firered
    comments: the first city i made with this tileset.It has a day care that will not open up until the fourth badge is acquired.
    Spoiler:


    map name: almair ridges
    Game:firered
    comments: the route after almair city. It is a very rocky place, even though a lot of fauna grows there. The trees are mainly a stretch from almair city.
    Spoiler:


    Credits to christos/semele, PHO, and peyi for the rombase.if there is any more, someone tell me so i can change it.
     

    p.hant0m

    Studier of ancient legends.
    53
    Posts
    15
    Years
    • ~Fire said:
    Alright, these were the maps i made in my spare time. F.Y.I, everyone knows how capable i am of inserting tiles, i just used this tileset to test it out.

    Map name: silon village(pending)
    game: firered
    comments: a small simple area.
    Spoiler:


    Map name: Silon meadows(pending
    Game: firered
    comments: a nice simple map. The dead end is just there.
    Spoiler:


    map name: almair city
    Game: firered
    comments: the first city i made with this tileset.It has a day care that will not open up until the fourth badge is acquired.
    Spoiler:


    map name: almair ridges
    Game:firered
    comments: the route after almair city. It is a very rocky place, even though a lot of fauna grows there. The trees are mainly a stretch from almair city.
    Spoiler:


    Credits to christos/semele, PHO, and peyi for the rombase.if there is any more, someone tell me so i can change it.
    Click to expand...
    Ok. The trees are really killing my eyes. It's just the yellow in them. They need to be darker.
    Almair City:Actually it looks more of a town to me. The waterfall is wrong. You used the currents/rapids tile for it. It actually has it's own tile and a waterfall ending point tile that appears as water crashing up in the air.
    The mart could be seperate from the day care and the day care's fencing is not complete. There needs to be some more fencing behind the mart so the mart should be moved more to the left. Overall a 4/10 due to the colors and the little things used improperly and the simplicity of it. Could use more things for a filler.
     
    Luck

    Luck

    ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
    6,779
    Posts
    16
    Years
    • Seen May 20, 2023
    p.hant0m said:
    Ok. The trees are really killing my eyes. It's just the yellow in them. They need to be darker.
    Almair City:Actually it looks more of a town to me. The waterfall is wrong. You used the currents/rapids tile for it. It actually has it's own tile and a waterfall ending point tile that appears as water crashing up in the air.
    The mart could be seperate from the day care and the day care's fencing is not complete. There needs to be some more fencing behind the mart so the mart should be moved more to the left. Overall a 4/10 due to the colors and the little things used improperly and the simplicity of it. Could use more things for a filler.
    Click to expand...

    It was supposed to be simple. And the tiles shouldn't count for the rating. It does look more town like, so i'll fix that. And i don't think you rated the routes.By the way, its supposed to be like that to prevent the player from screwing up the border. I didn't like the idea of rocks covering the exit when a boat is supposed to cross through that.
    I also planned on moving the mart, but i was lazy.
     

    Ryousha

    Waiting for Gen 4 Remakes
    954
    Posts
    16
    Years
    • Map Rating/Review Thread

    Basically just a minor edit, off a zeikkus rom base.


    Map Rating/Review Thread


    Pure Scratch :D

    These arent my best, they're alphas, and Im just making maps to get better.
     

    p.hant0m

    Studier of ancient legends.
    53
    Posts
    15
    Years
    • Ryousha said:
    Map Rating/Review Thread

    Basically just a minor edit, off a zeikkus rom base.


    Map Rating/Review Thread


    Pure Scratch :D

    These arent my best, they're alphas, and Im just making maps to get better.
    Click to expand...

    Too heavy on the green in al of the plants, trees, and what not. I like the positioning of it all though. The blue in the water looks more like a painting rather than water/a pond. Both get 6/10's :D

    *EDIT* @Inferno- Don't the tiles make the map? Really, I would change the waterfall.
     

    エロカメ

    38
    Posts
    15
    Years
    • Seen Nov 11, 2008
    Name: Pallet Town (revamped)

    Base: Fire Red

    Credits: Xiderwong and Kyledove for the rombase.

    Map Shot:

    Map Rating/Review Thread
     

    Dratii

    Working on something new...
    195
    Posts
    15
    Years
    • Seen Oct 24, 2023
    Name: Untitled
    Game: Fire Red
    Comments: My first map. No new tiles just a practice map.
    Map Rating/Review Thread
     

    iBlade

    ~Spriter~
    68
    Posts
    15
    Years
    • I'll give you 6/10 ..

    Map Rating/Review Thread

    Here is mine .. no new tilesets .. and yeah .. please rate ..
     
    Last edited:

    Hiche..

     
    979
    Posts
    16
    Years
    • Seen Dec 27, 2014
    ~Fire said:
    Alright, these were the maps i made in my spare time. F.Y.I, everyone knows how capable i am of inserting tiles, i just used this tileset to test it out.

    Map name: silon village(pending)
    game: firered
    comments: a small simple area.
    Spoiler:


    Map name: Silon meadows(pending
    Game: firered
    comments: a nice simple map. The dead end is just there.
    Spoiler:


    map name: almair city
    Game: firered
    comments: the first city i made with this tileset.It has a day care that will not open up until the fourth badge is acquired.
    Spoiler:


    map name: almair ridges
    Game:firered
    comments: the route after almair city. It is a very rocky place, even though a lot of fauna grows there. The trees are mainly a stretch from almair city.
    Spoiler:


    Credits to christos/semele, PHO, and peyi for the rombase.if there is any more, someone tell me so i can change it.
    Click to expand...

    I like all the maps.
    First one: Some empty space.
    Rating: 8/10
    Second map: Simply a great map!
    Rating: 9.2/10
    Third map: Also, a very goo map.
    Rating: 9/10
    Fourth map: I only don't like the shape of the mountain at the very bottom.
    Rating: 8.5/10
    :D
     

    p.hant0m

    Studier of ancient legends.
    53
    Posts
    15
    Years
    • I have a few maps i would like to be rated.

    All are on Leaf Green Version and credits go to Lu-ho poke for advance map and credits to me for designing the maps. All made from scratch.

    Name: Shone Province
    This one connects to Viridian city's right side and connects to another one of my maps at the top.
    Spoiler:


    Name: Auroros Cavern Entrance
    Connects to Shone Province's top part.
    Spoiler:


    Name:Auroros Cavern
    The Lugia CAN actually be challenged and fought just like in Navel Rock and like any other legendary, it will run if you kill it. Originally designed as a shrine for Suicune. The lines means connect the entrance with the place it goes to.
    Spoiler:


    Name: Quadrona Village
    Still working on more houses but probably won;t add any more. The lines means connect the entrance with the place it goes to. The three Deoxys forms are only statues. The name of the cavern included is the Shigari Ruins.
    Spoiler:


    Name:Riverveil Stead
    I keep seeing rivers in other maps so I decided to base one on a river. Very quaint village. No connections so far.
    Spoiler:
     
    Last edited:
    Tyrantrum

    Tyrantrum

    5,814
    Posts
    16
    Years
    • Age 30
    • Seen May 19, 2021
    Okay, I really don't want to sound too harsh, but all the maps are empty, square, and have tile errors. They were obviously not spent a lot of time on.
    They all deserve a:
    0/10~
     

    mitchel1

    Rom-hacker/scripter
    237
    Posts
    17
    Years
    • Hey people do you want to rate on this map?
    It's from My hack Pokémon Thunder emblem ^^
    (Btw. please don't remake this map in one other hack (thnx for understanding ^^)

    Map name: Rough Rock Valley

    Game: Pokémon Thunder emblem

    Commants: A great new map with some awesome new tiles ^^ (You people already know from who thise tiles are right?) (with creators) i hope so, that takes less time to say it ^^ (if you don't know who made them just look in me topic of my hack there you can find it ^^) Btw. that unown sign has made by me ^^ if you want to use it, you're free to use it but GIVE CREDITS!!!!

    Spoiler:


    Cya
    ~Mitchel1
     

    p.hant0m

    Studier of ancient legends.
    53
    Posts
    15
    Years
    • Yeah the Auroros ones were made in a hurry so I understand that part. Riverveil isn;t really that bad though. And shone province I actually went back and filler it in before making anything else. Quadrona was one that I made in about 1 hour :D I haven't went back to work on it yet probably because of my time that I haven;t had.
     

    Hiche..

     
    979
    Posts
    16
    Years
    • Seen Dec 27, 2014
    mitchel1 said:
    Hey people do you want to rate on this map?
    It's from My hack Pokémon Thunder emblem ^^
    (Btw. please don't remake this map in one other hack (thnx for understanding ^^)

    Map name: Rough Rock Valley

    Game: Pokémon Thunder emblem

    Commants: A great new map with some awesome new tiles ^^ (You people already know from who thise tiles are right?) (with creators) i hope so, that takes less time to say it ^^ (if you don't know who made them just look in me topic of my hack there you can find it ^^) Btw. that unown sign has made by me ^^ if you want to use it, you're free to use it but GIVE CREDITS!!!!

    Spoiler:


    Cya
    ~Mitchel1
    Click to expand...

    Wow! this a great map. Well done and the trees are placed neatly.
    Rating: 8.5/10
     
    Disturbed

    Disturbed

    1,906
    Posts
    15
    Years
    • Age 30
    • Seen Oct 21, 2019
    Ryousha said:
    Map Rating/Review Thread


    Route 1 Final. Looks nothing like Route 2! or does it.
    Click to expand...
    Rating: 6/10
    Reason: Lots of empty space, and there are tile errors throughout the map, (the rock for instance)

    Now, my starting town.

    Comments: This is not being inserted anywhere, so anyone can have this. I think I perfected this with the shadows, and the accurate block edits (first time for me! ^_^) also, notice the slight palette changes.
    Map Rating/Review Thread
    https://i244.photobucket.com/albums/gg19/Mecharatchet/Somestartertown.png
    Please rate!
     
    Status
    Not open for further replies.
    Back
    Top