• Our software update is now concluded. You will need to reset your password to log in. In order to do this, you will have to click "Log in" in the top right corner and then "Forgot your password?".
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.

Happily Never After [GAME OVER]

jdthebud

Engineering Solutions
4,195
Posts
13
Years
  • Sure, Maleficent can always conceal her identity on Belle's reports, but can she conceal her identity on a wish made by another person? I'm pretty sure she wouldn't...

    Checkmate.
    How is it "Checkmate"? Role abilities are not so flimsy as to be circumvented by wishes, especially since CB clearly knew they were going to be a mechanic in this game.

    Just because you don't want to see the truth doesn't mean it doesn't exist. I know it might be hard for you to accept it, but your wish is not 100% reliable.
    Hello hello hello.

    I'm more inclined to believe that a wish for a true identidy would reveal the true identidy, especially when it's specified what it would be hidden from

    HOWEVER

    Jd raised the point that he could be seen as clear by the phase posts and by his claims.
    Thank you! This is the point I've been trying to get across. The phase posts have numerous indications that I am clear, especially D3. Please continue on this line of thought. I'd like to again point out that the most recent one also says this:
    Maleficent still remained alive and prepared to claim victory.
    I am the only one to put forth a possible way that Maleficent could win - by lynching me, 2 other princesses are going to die, and I think he has a way to kill 2 others or avoid the lynch tomorrow, which will give Bard the win.
    Haven't heard from you lately, what are your thoughts? please don't sheep along.
     
    Last edited:

    Omicron

    the day was mine
    4,430
    Posts
    14
    Years
  • If on previous games here the Godfather hadn't been able to get investigated by other means, I'd be inclined to agree with you on that, jd.

    To be honest with you, I felt Bard was scummy early in the game, but I just expect that from Bard now.

    You really should have defended yourself when the accusation that you were mafia was made or cc'ed Bard on the spot.

    Whichever of you two is mafia threw Gio under the bus. Now, was Gio throwing someone under the bus or not?

    Also, why was Bard poisoned?
     

    Aquacorde

    ⟡ dig down, dig down ⟡
    12,512
    Posts
    19
    Years
  • I don't think gunner fully revealed exactly who was investigated and what results turned up? And I don't know why Abby wouldn't have been able to be targeted last night. It could make sense, considering the phase post noting a disappearance, but the role was still active at that time. idk I'd like to know exactly what went on over there.

    Maleficent's desc specifically says she is able to conceal her identity on Belle's reports. That's fairly specific. It's a little worrisome that both Rapunzel claims have come after Belle's death.

    Bard gets more sus by the post tho. Talking abt Syn who wasn't even in this game- then again, Bard thinks Nina and I are the same person. :P Golgari defending Bard is kind of incriminating, though I did agree that the behaviour in question was typical of him. But the poison claim feels more odd as the game goes on- nobody else has been poisoned? The antidote was an item? The only other item was Phillip's sword, which was far more important. As it stands, the poisoning looks like a sham.
     

    jdthebud

    Engineering Solutions
    4,195
    Posts
    13
    Years
  • I don't think gunner fully revealed exactly who was investigated and what results turned up? And I don't know why Abby wouldn't have been able to be targeted last night. It could make sense, considering the phase post noting a disappearance, but the role was still active at that time. idk I'd like to know exactly what went on over there.

    Maleficent's desc specifically says she is able to conceal her identity on Belle's reports. That's fairly specific. It's a little worrisome that both Rapunzel claims have come after Belle's death.

    Bard gets more sus by the post tho. Talking abt Syn who wasn't even in this game- then again, Bard thinks Nina and I are the same person. :P Golgari defending Bard is kind of incriminating, though I did agree that the behaviour in question was typical of him. But the poison claim feels more odd as the game goes on- nobody else has been poisoned? The antidote was an item? The only other item was Phillip's sword, which was far more important. As it stands, the poisoning looks like a sham.
    it does look like he made it up to appear innocent especially since no one knows where the antidote came from...
    Also, while Gunner didn't reveal who was investigated explicitly, it's obvious that at least Bard was investigated and she got Rapunzel. Gunner and Nimsy and Nina thought they would be able to get around Malificent's ability to dodge role checks but it didn't work out that way. Are you willing to change your vote? We need one more on Bard make sure to lynch him.
     

    Salzorrah

    [font=Montserrat][b][color=#66CC66]g[/color][color
    6,374
    Posts
    13
    Years
  • Okay, jd, I'll have you answer this. Give me a list of everything that had happened to you (curses, silences, everything) starting D1. Bard, I'd also like you to do the same as well.

    I'm still holding on my wish, though.
     

    jdthebud

    Engineering Solutions
    4,195
    Posts
    13
    Years
  • Okay, jd, I'll have you answer this. Give me a list of everything that had happened to you (curses, silences, everything) starting D1. Bard, I'd also like you to do the same as well.

    I'm still holding on my wish, though.
    Okey doke.

    My targets:
    N0: [Heal] Gimmepie (he still hasn't been N0'd, smh)
    N1: [Heal] Nina
    N2: [Heal] Bardothren (arg that poisoning claim really got me there)
    N3: [Heal] Nina - I was roleblocked this night, so Nina got killed ;-;
    N4: [Heal] Omicron

    Targeted:
    N2: I was hit by the silencer, couldn't talk or vote D3. Hey look, Desishinon can't vote today either!
    N3: I was roleblocked as said above
    N4: I was hit by Maleficent's spell, which put a curse on me. If I die today, 2 other people go down as well.

    As for why Fletch said "wow Bard.", I think it's because he outed as Cinderella D3, before the N3 party ball:
    We're gonna have a ball tonight. ;)
    In what world would you think he was the cop?

    Anyway, Gunner or Anna needs to change their vote to Bard, or we are going to have a coin flip to determine who wins.
    And I don't know why Abby wouldn't have been able to be targeted last night. It could make sense, considering the phase post noting a disappearance, but the role was still active at that time. idk I'd like to know exactly what went on over there..
    I forgot to address this question earlier. Take a look at the Night 4 phase post.You'll notice that Abby is no longer on the player list, and instead has been replaced by ???. This backs up my claim that Abby was not targetable last night as CB was waiting to see Anna would replace her or if Abby would simply be killed off.

    Home stretch guys. Victory is at hand. Just one more vote on Bard and we win.

    [LYNCH] Bardothren
     

    Aquacorde

    ⟡ dig down, dig down ⟡
    12,512
    Posts
    19
    Years
  • Fine. I'll out then, though I am loathe to do so. I'm Rapunzel. I haven't been any help, sadly; I thought they would be after Nimsy and protected her.

    I can't argue with that claim. [Kill] Golgari

    Well that doesn't match a claim up there...

    [Lynch] Bardothren
     

    Omicron

    the day was mine
    4,430
    Posts
    14
    Years
  • Great thing you were so persistent, jd. You could have played it a bit differently, you really, really set up yourself to look like mafia accidentally, but you raised good points that had me doubting since you started posting them, I was just really reluctant to change my vote, since Gunner and Nimsy had more information at their disposal than I had. Most people would've given up at some point, I'm really glad you didn't.

    Sorry, Bard. Better luck in your future roles.

    Who poisoned you, btw? Do you really have no idea? I regret giving you the antidote, but that's another story.
     

    Charlie Brown

    [font=lato]coolcoolcool[/font]
    4,240
    Posts
    12
    Years

  • day five ends.


    → at last we see the light.

    It was a long day. Everyone alive - not that there were many people alive - was torn between jdthebud and Bardothren. One of them was Rapunzel, the other Maleficent, and the salt was real.

    The day was drawing to a close and the Fairies were preparing their Royal Coin to flip to decide who to kill, when the tide suddenly turned and the Princesses saw the truth, deciding to sentence Bardothren to death.

    The Fairies expected a last struggle, but Maleficent, rather uncharacteristically, gave herself up and accepted her faith. Merriweather drew her wand to kill Maleficent once and for all, but Fauna stopped her.

    "I personally think it is quite noble that you would elect to accept your fate, and admit your wrongs. It shows character, Maleficent, and I think that is a big improvement for you. Such a big improvement, in fact, that I think you should remain alive and be given the opportunity to continue to atone for your sins. You have potential, potential to be great again!"

    The Fairies and Princesses alike were touched by this speech, and were willing to forgive Maleficent for her crimes.

    But Merriweather killed her anyway.

    And at last, the world was good again. Good had triumphed. And the Princesses erupted in many many songs of celebration.


    Bardothren is dead. He was Maleficent. The Villains have been defeated!


    → The remaining Princesses have won the game! Congratulations to:
    Omicron as Snow White,
    Davepetasprite^2 as Tiana,
    jdthebud as Rapunzel,
    Anna as Mulan and
    Rowlet as Cinderella!

    All this commotion woke a sniffly Olaf up, who had been resting in bed all day. He joined in the celebration, glad that he had decided to remain alive. It would now be up to him to bring joy to the world once again.


    Desinishon has won the game! He was Olaf.

    → Trivia


    - Most of my favourite roles died right at the start. The Fairy Godmother was my favourite role - she could choose someone to support and her win condition would be to help that player to win, and she would be able to grant nightly wishes for that player. But gimmepie was slayed by Nimsy/Prince Phillip on D1 before he even pledged allegiance to anyone. I toyed with the idea of protecting the Fairy Godmother from being slayed but decided against it. It was definitely a painful update to write though.

    - Ariel was going to be given the option to change factions on D3 (based on the fact that Ariel the character wants to be part of the 'other world') but alas she also died early on.

    - Thankfully Snow White remained alive lol so at least one of the unique roles could use most of their abilities.

    - Olaf was indeed a fool role, but had to get lynched by D3. After D3 Olaf's wincon changed to surviving the game, as Olaf realised that with all the bad in the world, the world needed someone comical to lift the mood. So Bard if you had managed to get jd lynched, I don't think your plan to lynch Desi would have worked. :P

    - Speaking of Bard, he was poisoned by me as a penalty for not submitting a night kill via PM and making me dig through the mafia group. Omi received the antidote at random, and was all too keen to give it to Bard hahaha.

    - After losing her sword, Nimsy was allowed to 'confront' three players every night and one every day to try and find who had randomly received her sword (it was Lycan/Belle). She was also given the option to confront a selection of other Disney characters, of which she chose Pinocchio. I have no idea why you would ask a notorious liar where the sword is but whatever floats your boat, Nimsy.

    - Gunner/Tiana had the option to send one-way anonymous letters to players which could have been a good opportunity to communicate/send information... but she instead used those letters to send all-caps, slightly-altered Disney lyrics. idk man.

    - Bard/Maleficent was protected from all role investigations (including the wand), and he chose to appear as Belle when investigated by Gunner/Nina's wand.

    - This was fun xoxo thanks guys! That last phase especially was lots of fun to watch.


    → Rules

    - Day Phases will last ~48 hours and Night Phases will last ~24 hours.
    - Posting at night will lead to immediate death.
    - Upon dying, you are allowed one deathpost which may not reveal anything about the game. After that, you are dead. Don't haunt the thread.
    - Do not discuss this game outside of this thread and GM-created chats.
    - Missing two Night Actions or two Lynch Votes will lead to your replacement/death. If you wish to abstain from your Night Action, please let me know.
    - You may not abstain from casting a Lynch Vote, nor can you cast a 'no lynch'. A coinflip will break a tie. Please cast lynch votes in the format [LYNCH] Player Name
    - No PM sharing.
    - Feel free to break into song at any time.
    - If you have any questions, please ask!


    → Player List


    Omicron as Snow White
    Etherion as Ursula
    Youmu as Jasmine
    Desinishon as Olaf
    Nina as Aurora
    Golgari as Cruela de Vil
    aeternum as Elsa
    Nimsy as Prince Phillip
    gimmepie as The Fairy Godmother
    jdthebud as Rapunzel
    Anna as Mulan
    Kaneki!!! as The Evil Queen
    Lycanthropy as Belle
    Arctic Sun as Pocahontas
    Collector Elwood as Anna
    Nakuzami as Ariel
    Moon as Cinderella
    Bardothren as Maleficent
    Davepetasprite^2 as Tiana
    Mana as The Queen of Hearts



    Spoiler:


     

    Salzorrah

    [font=Montserrat][b][color=#66CC66]g[/color][color
    6,374
    Posts
    13
    Years
  • Okay no I'm still salty at the fact that we wished for the TRUE role. Will forever be salty at that decision :(

    But nevertheless, I'm still glad we won... Props to jdthebud for being fuckin persistent. He deserves a fuckin award for that one.
     

    Omicron

    the day was mine
    4,430
    Posts
    14
    Years
  • Nice job, everyone.

    "- Gunner/Tiana had the option to send one-way anonymous letters to players which could have been a good opportunity to communicate/send information... but she instead used those letters to send all-caps, slightly-altered Disney lyrics. idk man. "

    Gunner, wtf.
     
    10,078
    Posts
    15
    Years
    • UK
    • Seen Oct 17, 2023
    Salty about being investigated so soon, sorry Naku but I had to take you down with me :P.
     

    Etherion

    Guest
    0
    Posts
    GRRRRRRRRRRRRRR.
    SO CLOSE.
    YET SO FAR.


    Happily Never After [GAME OVER]
     
    Back
    Top