...
*proceeds to eat all the hats*
Well now I feel like I should be claiming everything. I'm Pinkbeard, originally an Enchantress (the "gift" I gave to Kiyo was a crystal ball, which is why he revealed Bard upon his death.) I abstained N0, gave Kiyo the crystal ball on N1 and received the Old Maid on N2 (the same night Klippy claimed to have given it to Kiyo, which is what made zero sense.) On N3 I swapped the Old Maid for Drew's Snoop, which I used last night to find out that Lost still has two guns, btw.