So, I'm thinking of trying shiny hunting again (only done it once before). Which of the following, in your opinion, do you guys think would be the easiest to get in Pokemon Moon or Pokemon Y (preferably Moon since that's the game I have a shiny charm in)?
Eevee Ralts Shinx Staryu Amaura Vulpix Roselia Nidoran (male)
I would appreciate any help!
You can SOS for Eevee and Staryu, or in Y you can Friend Safari for Eevee. You can only fish chain for Staryu in X. You can horde hunt for Nidoran in Y. Even without shiny charm I recently got a shiny nidoran male in 26 hordes. I've found 4 shiny males actually in hordes to date, trying to get the female.
If you want Alolan Vulpix I think you can sos for it in Sun, otherwise you have to breed for it in Moon.
You can dexnav for Ralts, original Vulpix and Roselia in oras, but you have to breedthem in Moon. You have to masuda for Shinx in both. Amaura can be fossil reset in Y but it would be full odds so masuda in Moon would be better.
Personally I think friend safari, horde hunting, fish chaining and Dexnaving are all easy with or without shiny charm.
I haven't sos'd before but it seems to be easy with or without shiny charm, the same odds anyways. Of course the mechanics of getting ready for a sos hunt don't make any sense to me, I think you need Smeargle or something and leftovers and an Exeggcutor from gen 6 with Harvest.
_________________________________________________________
I'm not sure when I last posted so I'll start with Sept 1st.
I started out the month trying to get Dragonite, Tyranitar and Salamence. During the hunt in FS I got 2 Gabite's, a Dwebble and 3 Druddigon's, failed one of the Druddigon's my first fail. The encounter #'s below don't include the previous shiny encounter #'s in that safari.
I got shiny Pupitar on the 5th after 525 encounters. After 1 Dwebble at 1565.
Shiny Shelgon on the 7th at 80, after 3 Druddigon's, first 685, then 67 (failed) and finally 649. And 2 Gabite's at 26 then 688.
And finally shiny Dragonair at 414 on the 9th. Fortunately no more Gabite's or Druddigon in this safari.
I also horde hunted for Aron (719 hordes), Swablu (98 hordes), Mareep (1636 hordes), Nidoran male (1187 hordes). I dexnaved Torkoal and got it fast at 18.
While horde hunting for Aron I got a Zubat, while horde hunting for Makuhita I got 1 Zubat and 2 Geodude's. The first Geodude at 908 and the second at 441.
I also got a 4th male Nidoran at 26 hordes yesterday, I'm currently horde hunting and masuda methoding for shiny female Nidoran.