Haha, even after playing my priest I still love my warrior the most. Even though the rotation is very simplistic, it's just a ton of fun swinging a heroic cryptmaker and a shadow's edge around with 100% ArP in BGs. Oh god, I remember the day before 4.0 hit, I went into a BG with 100% ArP and DBW and just Whirlwinded EVERYTHING in sight. Then Blizz killed us.
The hit thing really hit us hard, literally. that 17% hit thing was a JOKE. Like what the hell were they thinking? This is when my guild decided to take all the OP classes and not let anyone else try. Its funny, I was the most versatile player. I could make every raid, stay as long as necessary, I can easily say I was the #1 dps in wrath (lolOP fury, proness) and top 5 when cata hit. I was just missing gear, but I couldn't get crafted epics because the guild gave everything to the baddies pulling less than me ;.;
But whatever, I'm done for now. Maybe if Blizzard stops making everything a joke I'll go back. As for PvP, I've actually never tried to PvP competitively. I usually just did my weekly arena for points and never went higher than 1500 ahaha. :P Although I will admit, fury PvP pre 4.1 was OP as hell. I went in with heroic blues and was critting people for 58k executes the second week of cata o.O no joke! I have a screenshot to back it up :3
http://i.imgur.com/QYVg4.jpg