Yeah, I skipped one like an idiot. But two really did give me a good scare. Feeling your heart beat so loud is an adrenaline rush. :3
And holy crap, look up Amnesia right now. I'll admit, I've only read reviews and never actually played it, but if the hype it gets is legitimate, then it's probably scarier than any of the horror games already mentioned. Seriously. It's a PC game, so as soon as I get my own laptop, I'm downloading it.
Spoiler:
by the goddess! that screenshot scared me xD
So getting caught by one of those dudes would be like getting caught by a goomba in Mario - oh well, you die and start over or whatever.
Aye, Resident Evil is a hunky bit of fright.
I like turtles.