Team Magma's Revenge

Status
Not open for further replies.
Klippy said:
OR he could've been lying and he's Mafia and protecting H.A.N. and Hibikaze...

I'm willing to take a risk and lynch maccrash because he's useless so far and we're all dying because he isn't helping.

I'll wait for some opinions before voting.
Click to expand...
If so, wouldn't the real Birch have mentioned that by now?

Klippy said:
It'd just be nice if people that are involved would stay involved. :/
Click to expand...
^This would make the game easier (and more fun too).
 
H.A.N. said:
If so, wouldn't the real Birch have mentioned that by now?

^This would make the game easier (and more fun too).
Click to expand...

No, because then Mafia would know who it was. But I can't follow that logic because we're sitting here dying and our detective sucks regardless of if its mac or someone else, so someone's not doing their job.
 
Klippy said:
I have to agree with the other guys that we need to pick someone though and I don't mind Sonata's suggestion of doing a less active person, but the only two inactive people last session were maccrash and Sonata and Sonata at least posted. maccrash is the only person that isn't actively contributing and he's apparently our detective.

I'll wait for some opinions before voting.
Click to expand...

I hadn't voted because I knew matt wasn't dumb enough to go for a blatant revenge kill and so I knew he was innocent, and come to find out he was. If you want my honest opinion on who we should be looking at I have to point my finger at Varys again. It was just too convenient.

Over half of us that are still alive are on the chopping block with knives coming from both directions while only three people have a little bit of evidence to keep them safe. If you want to go for maccrash or someone else that's fine, but it's just my two cents and I still don't even know what to do. We still have another day to think about it so let's take our time to think it out and not jump to conclusions.
 
Sonata said:
I hadn't voted because I knew matt wasn't dumb enough to go for a blatant revenge kill and so I knew he was innocent, and come to find out he was. If you want my honest opinion on who we should be looking at I have to point my finger at Varys again. It was just too convenient.

Over half of us that are still alive are on the chopping block with knives coming from both directions while only three people have a little bit of evidence to keep them safe. If you want to go for maccrash or someone else that's fine, but it's just my two cents and I still don't even know what to do. We still have another day to think about it so let's take our time to think it out and not jump to conclusions.
Click to expand...

I definitely agree that we jumped the gun on Matt, but we have stalled for too long and our Detective is not helping, so we have to start deducing something soon.

I'll wait to vote until people weigh in on the info H.A.N. and myself put forth. Then I think we need to decide on two people we suspect and put them forth for tonight and the following night. Our odds aren't great, but they will win if we don't do anything.
 
Klippy said:
I'm sorry, but could we actually get everyone active in here? It's impossible to play the game with elements missing for the majority of it and I even joined late! I just don't see how we can play with nothing to look into. :/
Click to expand...

I'll send out some PMs in a few informing everyone about their activity and asking everyone to stay active. After that there really isn't much I can do, sorry y'all are pretty much in the dark here.

Varys the Galvantula said:
With maccrash still alive, I think if he just speaks up we can deduce from the nights he should be investigating who the mafia are. It's been too long, I guess?

@honey: can we ask if the detective is doing his/her job?

Also, I am with the idea that either H.A.N or Hibikaze is Godfather.
Click to expand...

Sorry, I believe I should leave that information out.
 
I'm really really sorry about totally forgetting about this. there isn't any excuse, really; unfortunately I don't have any new info. I'm gonna read through and make an Informed Decision on who to investigate tonight (unless any of you think I should investigate anyone in particular and have a reason for it -- in which case speak now). gonna make this my home page so I don't forget about it now. sorry again. I am bad.
 
maccrash said:
I'm really really sorry about totally forgetting about this. there isn't any excuse, really; unfortunately I don't have any new info. I'm gonna read through and make an Informed Decision on who to investigate tonight (unless any of you think I should investigate anyone in particular and have a reason for it -- in which case speak now). gonna make this my home page so I don't forget about it now. sorry again. I am bad.
Click to expand...

Well...if you go off my info, you should investigate Varys, Sonata, Thoughts, or Reisen.

Based on your info, I can conclude that you, myself, H.A.N., and Hibikaze are townies (unless one is Godfather). So odds are the next person you investigate is Mafia. Whoever is protecting you should continue to do so because it's the only chance we have to find the truth.

You can also investigate me, but your odds of finding Mafia are 75% by just picking one of the four mentioned above.

I guess we can vote on someone though.

I am just throwing a name out, but I'm going with...

vote// Varys the Galvantula

and for the Detective, investigate// Reisen
 
Klippy said:
Well...if you go off my info, you should investigate Varys, Sonata, Thoughts, or Reisen.

Based on your info, I can conclude that you, myself, H.A.N., and Hibikaze are townies (unless one is Godfather). So odds are the next person you investigate is Mafia. Whoever is protecting you should continue to do so because it's the only chance we have to find the truth.

You can also investigate me, but your odds of finding Mafia are 75% by just picking one of the four mentioned above.

I guess we can vote on someone though.

I am just throwing a name out, but I'm going with...

vote// Varys the Galvantula

and for the Detective, investigate// Reisen
Click to expand...
excellent; gonna withhold who I investigate so, in case they're town, mafia doesn't kill them. it might be Reisen, maybe not, I'm not sure yet. we'll see what happens.
 
vote // Varys the Galvantula

And I'm going to suggest looking in to Thoughts since like Klippy said Thoughts tried to get everyone to PM their roles, but couldn't due to rules. Or you can investigate me or any other player that's still alive. Whatever floats your boat.
 
Haha. Oh well. Since I'm probably going to get lynched out, inspect Klippy. Or whatever. He seemed to be too keen on lynching maccrash (yes, I get you but he still is the detective. he MIGHT be of help during the more crucial times. IDK)

ANyway, VOTE // Klippy

Also, when lynched, will our role be revealed?
 
oops sorry for inactivity

vote// Varys the Galvantula

bandwagony vote is bandwagony, but there are pretty much no other leads soooooo
 
The only way Varys isn't Mafia is if maccrash was blocked from properly using his Detective skill by H.A.N. or Hibikaze OR if we're really terrible and unlucky and pick the only other townie left. :P
 
//vote Varys the Galvantula

we shall see how this works. hopefully he's mafia because that would essentially clear Klippy unless Varys is bluffing.
 
DAY SIX CONCLUSION
Spoiler:


NIGHT SIX START​
Note- The deaths along with the amount of time left is updated after each term incase someone missed it.
 
DAY SEVEN START
If you're reading this, it's already too late. H.A.N., the Townie, was found laying cold in his own blood.
YOU HAVE 48 HOURS TO REACH A VERDICT. ​
 
Wait...something doesn't make sense, honey... If El Heroe was the Jailer and THREE Mafia members are left, then how can there be so many townies alive/now dead? Or are you not revealing roles now? You revealed El was the Jailer, but?

H.A.N., myself, and Varys can't all have been townies in the scenario if three Mafia and three Helpers were left. :/

1) maccrash
2) Klippy
3) H.A.N.
4) Hibikaze
5) Varys
6) Reisen
7) Sonata
8) Thoughts
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top