Day 2:
Ouch, I missed a vote
Last time I played with town!desi, he tried to lead the town with a hypoclaim strat. Can't say this upfront playstyle isn't out of the norm for him, so I trust him for now. I'm in favor of having him investigated, but he'd be an easy NK pick if he's town. Too late to check since I'm already typing this, but I don't think this game has any protection now that doof got iced.
Declares his trust in Desi. Easy to do that as scum though. Slightly surprised he didn't try to pressure him but I guess he thought easy town points, especially since he knew Lulu was scum. Also would look good later if Desi was cop checked. I'm surprised that he didn't follow it up with a kill on Desi given his "hunch" on Lulu, but perhaps they didn't want to risk Lulu getting lynched without a lover to drag down.
Doesn't seem like there's much to go by. I'm not feeling Desi's vote on jd, being inquisitive isn't necessarily scummy. I'd be more worried if no one at all questioned someone attempting to direct night actions.
Forgot to ask but you let the cat in, right? Thought you'd get N1'd, or did you have some other reason?
This is more of a pet-peeve than anything, but the whole presentation of this felt off. It's like "I, a fellow townie, am also glad that this pro-town action happened to us, the town, rather than something that benefits the scum team that I am not a part of." If you're just a new townie, I'd avoid doing that. Regardless, it'd be worth keeping an eye on you.
Other than that, I've got good vibes from Ash. Call it a tonal read
Focusing on the second part here, which is in response to Lulu, his scummate. Throwing shade here to prepare for a Lulu lynch in the future, I guess?
Day 3:
I'm a bit worried that no one's claimed the suspicious partner yet. Assuming that no one who already talked this phase has the role, then the only person besides Kitty who could have it is Ash. But if that isn't the case, then they should go ahead and claim. If Kitty's mafia, then she's the roleblocker and she'll die. In other words, there's no point in laying low right now.
Just occured to me that the teacher's useless at this point. I said this under the assumption that L'Belle would get turboed tonight. But still, I'd rather have a guaranteed scum lynch and another conf town than a late-game tracker. Weigh your options and claim if you see fit.
The gist of what I'm saying is that
- I'm having doubts about Kitty being scum, since no one's claimed the watch/track role
- The only way to know for sure is if that happens
- But on the downside, our last info role gets weeded out and killed the next night
Going for LuLu instead might be a good option, but I'm not sure how much of an impact losing Desi would have
These 3 posts go together here, with the last being in response to my request to him to clarify his thoughts. Anyway, the gist here is that he wants to lynch Lulu in order to keep Kitty alive for one more night so they can use their action again, and also not let Desi use a potential action that night.
Day 4:
Vote
Yeah, I'm confused too. At first I suspected that she might be the crusher, but that's impossible now.
My guess is that they thought she didn't have any hope after the watch/track got revealed, and sacrificed her to take out a confirmed townie.
@L'Belle Did your action get blocked?
He's revealing the thoughts of the mafia here, which I also deduced.
Now's a good time to claim, as well. I'm the promise ring. There isn't any way to support it with night actions, so you should go through my post history and determine if I'm trustworthy.
That leaves Ash, Jolt, and Jd. Among you, there's the Jock, Charmer, and Crusher. One of each alignment. I want claims from you three.
And finally the claim that reveals his alignment. Here he is baiting the promise ring to reveal so he knows who to avoid on N4. There was no reason to ask for claims on D4 when we already had a lynch lined up.
