ok so this is where I stand on everyone right now:
Town reads: Bard, Melody
Slight town reads: Sparkin, Earth Traveler, Gunner, purplecicada
Null reads (due to lack of content): HyperMorian, Kiyotaka, Johnny, Zenithos
Null reads (due to conflicting thoughts on what they've done so far): Abby (town who forgot about no-reveal, or scum who also forgot about no-reveal?), EvilChameleon (actual cop hoping for doctor? granny/loudmouth claiming cop so that maf visits? actual cop pretending to bait as granny/loudmouth so that maf doesn't visit? Stalker trying to establish themselves as cop? Maf faking cop reports? Another role told him Johnny is inno? So many questions...), gimmepie (either overly aggressive town or Lyncher, if such a thing exists in this setup.)
Very tentative scum reads that might actually be null reads due to lack of content but they're also playing the rookie card: Sawsbuck, Ida13
Slight scum reads: Pecilia, because wtf was that OMGUS vote?
Scum reads: I don't feel this strongly about anyone yet tbh
Was going to go for EC but the more I thought about it the more conflicted I was. Yeah, the Abby vote is iffy and the reasoning for it is weak, but then none of us are confident about Abby's alignment at this point. We could be ripping into Sparkin for his Abby vote too but I don't see anyone doing that (tbf I might have moved him down to null for it, but before that I townread him so I'm sticking with my gut here.) Also Sparkin's right, a cop claim is still a cop claim. There's so many things that could be true here that we risk lynching our actual cop, or another important town role, if we lynch him. I'm with Bard - wait for him to slip up or for a cop CC.
I'm actually going to [Vote] Pecilia because it's one thing to waltz in, give a random vote and completely ignore everything that's been going on like some people have been doing, but it's another thing entirely to waltz in, give an OMGUS vote that stacks on someone else's random vote, and then not comment on anything that's happened so far. Sparkin's not even scummy. (or voting for Pecilia any more, so even the OMGUS reasoning is invalid now)
gonna try and keep an eye on the thread even though I'm going to be out this evening to see if Pecilia says anything else though.