The Courtroom

Why defensive? I'm always irritated when anyone tries to push lynch on innocent me for no good logical reason.
 
Melody said:
I see Pie softing me. It's silly. Looks like he's prosecution. Possibly a Witness.
Click to expand...

gimmepie said:
I like how I'm immediately scum because I'm scum-leaning you. Truly you're the master of the OMGUS play.

Why so defensive, Melody?
Click to expand...

Woah woah, easy you two. Don't go cut throat on each other please. Maybe instead of going at each other, maybe you should work together to find the prosecutors??? Honestly, both of you don't scream scum to me so :P

EDIT: Besides, if you're village, we're more concerned with killing the prosecutors than witnesses
 
Last edited:
The way you say "innocent" makes me think you're trying to push in our faces that you are when you may not be. imo it's kind of difficult to read you Kind of like "I'll gain their trust and stab them in the back" sort of thing.
 
As much as I'd like to agree with GP here, I'm going to wait before I decide whether or not to vote Mel or go for someone else entirely.
 
Whoa whoa whoa, let's not be rash about anything here. Questioning is good and all, but isn't it a bit too early to be cutting up each others throats? As for my vote, I'd hold that off for now, unless someone is highly suspicious.
 
The time to be cutthroat is when someone is cutthroat.

Definitely town reading GP, he's showing initiative, though I don't share his scum read on melody.


Actually no, I don't see how he's softing...

Sorry I'm trying to process this, and I keep wanting to say they're scum bussing, so I'd like to see a flip from one of them, and since she already has a vote

[VOTE]Melody
 
Witnesses aren't anything evil-like that can harm town.

Abby, Abby, Abby
If you don't share the scumread, why you're still voting them?
 
Well, this is a strange interaction.

To be honest I think both arguments are really weak. They've both accused each other of being scum, so I wouldn't be surprised if Melody came back with a vote on GP. Imo this is town v town or town v witness and they're both clutching at straws looking for reasons to lynch someone on D1, or one of them is a Witness Lyncher role (if it's either of them, it's probably GP) and the other is their target (again, idk if Lyncher really works in an AitP setup, but it's a possibility?) I don't think either of them are prosecutors yet.

I'm going to put down a [Vote] Abby (and yes I know I'm stacking)
because I think his reasoning for trying to start a Melody wagon is flawed and not very well thought out, like scum keen to start up a mislynch.
> The whole "softing" thing is probably just a poor use of words. Substitute "softing me" for "suggesting that I'm scum" and she's conveying the same idea, just in a clearer way.
> I think scum bussing is the least likely scenario here, since a) why would two scum bus each other on D1 when there was literally no suspicion on either of them beforehand? and b) how would bussing another scum at this point benefit the prosecutors when we have no idea what people's alignments are after they've died?
 
I don't know what to do but
[Lynch] Sparkin for now.
 
That was quite an about face you pulled there, Abby!

[Vote] Abby
 
Eh, whatever. I'll random vote instead.
[Vote] TheUncreativeSawsbuckGuy
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top