A Simple Game of Mafia

[gimmepie]

Time's up. Phase change shortly.

 

[gimmepie]

A Simple Game of Mafia
No fancy custom roles. No flavour or thematics. Nothing but pure mafia.

Day Two

Nakuzami is dead. He was the Doctor.

Players

gimmepie as the GM​

Chumley as ???
Mystical Isa as ???
Seththeking as ???

Omicron as a Villager
jdthebud as the Scout
Nakuzami as the Doctor​

Charlie Brown as ???​

 

[Chumley]

Do u guys think Naku died because of a PR read or do u think they where a threat or their death id for wifom maybe?

 

[Nakuzami]

And I---oop

Ur welcome

 

[Chumley]

Vote Charlie Brown u need to show up or sub out

 

[Ys]

Thanks Naku ^^

Late, but I'm not a noob when it comes to mafia. I'm just not familiar with PC's mafia specifically.

@Chumley well, for one, they were the one who voted for JD, so they are a threat. Maybe scout saw them at night, but that's not super likely, so I think they were just killed for being a threat.

@Seth what are your reads on the remaining players?

 

[Ys]

Hm. OK, things to notice:

Chumley's vote on Seth and wanting doc/nurse to protect him. Then, JD (now a known mafia) kind of defended him by saying he thought Chumley was talking about a hypothetical doc/nurse (post #45) . Would he have done the same if Chumley wasn't a mad buddy? Maybe he would have tried to throw more dirt on Chumley?

And then there was one post (#38) where JD asked Chumley something but Chumley didn't answer and JD didn't press. And JD said he saw Chumley as possibly scum and that's why he voted him (referring to Chumley?) but there never was a vote.

Finally, now, instead of voting Seth (his previous vote) or questioning him, he goes for Charlie, an inactive.

Nope. Sorry but I'm not buying it. Plus, why did no one mention the possibility of Charlie Brown as being silenced?

@gimmepie if Charlie doesn't post this phase nor vote would he get mod killed?

And

Vote Chumley

 

[Chumley]

Hm. OK, things to notice:

Chumley's vote on Seth and wanting doc/nurse to protect him. Then, JD (now a known mafia) kind of defended him by saying he thought Chumley was talking about a hypothetical doc/nurse (post #45) . Would he have done the same if Chumley wasn't a mad buddy? Maybe he would have tried to throw more dirt on Chumley?

And then there was one post (#38) where JD asked Chumley something but Chumley didn't answer and JD didn't press. And JD said he saw Chumley as possibly scum and that's why he voted him (referring to Chumley?) but there never was a vote.

Finally, now, instead of voting Seth (his previous vote) or questioning him, he goes for Charlie, an inactive.

Nope. Sorry but I'm not buying it. Plus, why did no one mention the possibility of Charlie Brown as being silenced?

@gimmepie if Charlie doesn't post this phase nor vote would he get mod killed?

And

Vote Chumley

We are in setup c. A doc and scout have died. I am the Tracker. Omnicron visited noone n0. Naku visited Seth

 

[Ys]

Why did you visit those two specifically?

 

[Chumley]

Why did you visit those two specifically?

I rng'd n0 and I picked Naku because they'd been getting heat and they'd be cleared by me because only one scum is alive and if they don't track to the kill they'd be clean. I was looking forward to outing myself with an alive Doc but didn't count on Naku being Doc or getting killed.

 

[Chumley]

Also, typically u unvote an uncc'd pr.

 

[Seththeking]

Vote Charlie Brown u need to show up or sub out

Don't vote!

/Vote No One

This is MYLO.
It's best we go onto LYLO.
So we have less possibilities and lowers the chance of us misslynching.
TBH I think your town and I think it's Isa but we'll see at LYLO.
It's best we don't vote anyone today.

 

[Seththeking]

AND you Tracker claimed.
Proves my point further.

 

[Seththeking]

Wait no. actually your confirmed town.
You'd be the Night Kill anyway.

/Vote Mystical Isa

If you didn't claim I would say we go into LYLO but you claimed so there is really no point now.
TBH I don't think Claiming in MYLO was the best and you should have waited till LYLO to see if you can catch a scum slip but eh. What's done is done.

 

[Ys]

I'm not mafia lol.

Guess there's no way to prove myself, though, as I'm a villager.

unvote Chumley

What about my play do you see as scummy, Seth?

 

[Ys]

Wait. What? OK, let me get this straight. You RNG'd and it just so happened to be mafia's target. And then you wanted to follow Naku to clear them instead of someone you were more sus about? What the h. Didn't you think the only person who voted for the one mafia would be mafia's target?

Seriously Seth, you're just buying that without question? Sigh.

 

[gimmepie]

Yes, if Charlie Brown fails to vote this phase he'll be killed for violating the rules of the game. Although, I may consider a replacement player if any of the non-mafia dead are interested.

 

[Chumley]

Wait. What? OK, let me get this straight. You RNG'd and it just so happened to be mafia's target. And then you wanted to follow Naku to clear them instead of someone you were more sus about? What the h. Didn't you think the only person who voted for the one mafia would be mafia's target?

Seriously Seth, you're just buying that without question? Sigh.

I'm mechanically confirmed town. My bad luck with tracks is irrelevant, Vote Mystical Isa

 

[Seththeking]

I'm not mafia lol.

Guess there's no way to prove myself, though, as I'm a villager.

unvote Chumley

What about my play do you see as scummy, Seth?

If Charlie is AFK I don't see how he can do the Night Kill.

 

[Seththeking]

Wait. What? OK, let me get this straight. You RNG'd and it just so happened to be mafia's target. And then you wanted to follow Naku to clear them instead of someone you were more sus about? What the h. Didn't you think the only person who voted for the one mafia would be mafia's target?

Seriously Seth, you're just buying that without question? Sigh.

There's no CC