Chairman Kaga
living in the past
- 12,044
- Posts
- 21
- Years
- Age 37
- Kitchen Stadium
- Seen Mar 9, 2013
Paul said:Yeah, I completely realize that. In some ways, I really do support the idea of an 'Intelligent Daily Discussion' with post length requirements...and strict grammar/spelling rules.
It'd be a handy refuge, and we could enjoy a very spam-free enviroment. The only downside is trying to get rid of all the n00bs that would try to infiltrate. Jack's got all his military prowress though. He could be our commander. The of course Alan and I have FE experience, we could strategy.
Time for war >O
Why do I always advocate conflict? On some level I find that disturbing.
Ah, while I think that the 25-character minumum requirement shouldn't also be seen as the minimum quality requirement; posts of varying lengths are necessary for conveying different ideas, but people should at least force themselves to find a balance between being unnecessarily wordy and being too brief, linear, and one-dimensional with their posting whenever they find themselves in the middle of a quality conversation. Many conversations can go far longer than we allow them to if only we can generate our own ideas, thoughts, questions, suppositions, et cetera on the subject so people can create longer replies through being forced to address many faces of one issue at the same time. The back-and-forth of monotonic discussion just doesn't do anything for me anymore, especially after looking back at posts from the DCCs of yore. My post count is a scarlet letter that shows how shamefully lax I've been in the past; I have always strived for quality discussion when possible but as I've grown less and less patient with PC my posts have grown shorter. I think many of us no longer feel the need to prove ourselves through intelligence like we did when we were all new; we simply rest on our laurels to talk about the old days.
It's funny, I've found that we have intelligent discussion now only when we're lamenting the loss of intelligent discussion. We could be talking about any subject right now with the same thought that we're putting into this, but yet we linger on our problems instead of solving them.
Simply put, if everyone else wants go to to war against short posts, I'm conscripted >D