Back to the Basics [Game Over]

[Lycanthropy]

Back to the Basics

D8

​

Random Mafia fact #382: "blacksmith" and "bullshit" are abbreviated the same way. Very useful for doubting roleclaims.

CatmanDaTrainer is dead! He was innocent!​

Players

Bardothren
Ullion
jdthebud
GreyBidoof
Elektra Heart
Collector Elwood
JohnnyMustang
Mana
Nagi
Hibikaze [N0]
Nina [N0]
Kaneki!!! [D1]
Nimsy [N2]
Superjolt [N2]
Lisia [D3]
Candy [N3]
Golgari [N3]
Davepetasprite^2 [D4]
Lost [D4]
TheCapsFan [D4]
alexkaz61 [D5]
[g="daily"]Charlie Brown[/g] [N5]
NightKrow [D6]
Desinishon [D6]
honey [N6]
KetsuekiR [N6]
Klippy [D7]
CatmanDaTrainer [N7]

omg this is the best thing ever. And here I was wondering if it would be chill for someone with dozens of games under their belt to pop by and say 'hey, can I play with the beginners?' and then this happened. HOORAY! Count me in.

Yes, for sure. 100%

Me please.

In it to win it.

WHAT MORE DO I HAVE TO SAY LYCAN SIGN ME UP BABY

excellent

Hi

Okay yeah, I think I can handle one more. Especially since it's simple. In.

f yes let's get jiggy with some 'nilla

I'm in.

I've never really understood the term "vanilla". Are all of the other mafias and stuff we do here chocolate? Or strawberry?

And I'm in 'cuz why not.

No, they're all salt flavoured. c:

o/ meeee?

can i still join?

Wakey, wakey.

 

[Ullion]

:|
Nagi, have you any info on anyone?

If not, shall we go to lynch Mana or GB?

 

[jdthebud]

Johnny, why do you think I am scum? You have not said anything about it before now.

And what's you reasoning behind Ullion being cult, Bard being inno, and Mana being mafia? These are the three remaining villager claims.

 

[Mana1]

I'm pretty sure, Nagi, GB and Ullion are the cult. That makes a 3-3-3, insteresting. Of course, the remaining townies being Bact, Bard and me. Leaving Mana, jdthebud and Kiyo as scum.

Interesting that you think the cult wouldn't recruit you, the confirmed inno, over some people who are still question marks :c. And quite why a cult would let the Vigilante stay as an enemy - that night kill could wipe out the cult it one go. Meanwhile, Kiyo has been 99% confirmed inno, by Catman and Nagi. I doubt that would have happened if Nagi was inno-turned-cult and Kiyo was mafia. Whilst Kiyo could maybe be culted, he can't be mafia due to the vests.

I'm scum reading Ullion the most. I've found him phrasing things oddly and throwing out accusations then going quiet for a day or two. GB is hard to read since he's not posting much, so he's looking like potential scum too.

Bard has been a bit all over the place, but with the amount of people pointing fingers at him he hasn't changed his tune. Idk if he's finally learnt to keep the act up or he's genuinely innocent, he does tend to crack under pressure.

 

[Ullion]

I'm pretty sure, Nagi, GB and Ullion are the cult. That makes a 3-3-3, insteresting. Of course, the remaining townies being Bact, Bard and me. Leaving Mana, jdthebud and Kiyo as scum.

Kiyo and Bard's reads are debatable and are the only ones in which I could change my mind. Inb4 Bact is the witch and Bard is also scum.

We don't wanna lynch the cultist yet, so I'll [KiLL]jdthebud

Tbh I don't know why the cult would recruit me while there are still inno PRs out there and (presumably) mafia left as well. Cult'ing a nilla inno doesn't remove any threats, unlike removing mafia, or vig, etc. (as someone mentioned earlier).

I'm scum reading Ullion the most. I've found him phrasing things oddly and throwing out accusations then going quiet for a day or two.

Phrasing what oddly, may I ask? The only "going quiet for a day or two" was after day one - and that was because I was feeling sick + was avoiding PC because I didn't want to deal with DotA mafia (go ahead, check the timestamps for days 2 and 3 of this game and when DotA mafia didn't update as frequently as it could have been). And it's funny hearing you try to scumread someone based on them "throwing out accusations then going quiet" when all you have done is been quiet the entire game and when you do speak is an attempt to make me look like scum or make a lynch post before the day ends. :P

 

[jdthebud]

Bact, did you ever post your NA list? I'm interested in seeing it if not.

Still waiting to hear from Johnny as well. >_>

 

[Mana1]

The only "going quiet for a day or two" was after day one - and that was because I was feeling sick + was avoiding PC because I didn't want to deal with DotA mafia (go ahead, check the timestamps for days 2 and 3 of this game and when DotA mafia didn't update as frequently as it could have been). And it's funny hearing you try to scumread someone based on them "throwing out accusations then going quiet" when all you have done is been quiet the entire game and when you do speak is an attempt to make me look like scum or make a lynch post before the day ends. :P

That was D1? ;-; My bad. My timeline isn't great at the moment. I disagree that I've done that though, I haven't dropped any accusations and then left it even if my posting has been limited, I've replied to the few people who have acknowledged my posts asap :c. I've been trying to post at least twice a day now as well to keep in the loop.

 

[Mana1]

However, Bact hasn't been killing, he claimed vigilante but he could as well be the witch and the vig's been dead for days now. Which is very likely because I don't think he would make such a mistake of killing n0 as the vig, plus, he claimed to have tried to kill me, but as you can see I'm pretty alive. According to honey she never protected me and Catman's vest only came on the night before this.

Didn't Bact target you and that's why Nimsy died? I thought that was the whole proof of you being the ghoul :c. I'm pretty sure Bact is town, or at least was town.

 

[Ullion]

Didn't Bact target you and that's why Nimsy died? I thought that was the whole proof of you being the ghoul :c. I'm pretty sure Bact is town, or at least was town.

My thoughts exactly. o.O

I'm at a loss as to where to proceed, I have no idea who left is maf or cult. :| Also still waiting for Nagi to report in, where is she? :'(

edi: Going by the info we have, I'm going to [kill] Grey Bidoof. I was thinking cult lead or maf are most likely between Mana GB or Bard, but Bard can not be cult lead (thanks to Nagi's info) and Mana has started talking today, which is more than GB can say. So I'll go for GB today unless new info comes to light.

 

[Lycanthropy]

Uhm... votes? Only twelve hours left.
Still need votes from: Bardothren, Collector Elwood, Elektra Heart, GreyBidoof, jdthebud, Mana, Nagi. (aka: basically everyone)

 

[Ullion]

In GB's defense, he hasn't been that active in Joker Game due to internet issues. Activity does not equal innocence, nor is the inverse true. What we really need is Nagi's report before proceeding on any assumptions, assuming there's time for such. I'm going with [Kill] Ullion on a gut call here - Klippy backed up the rationale you're using, more than enough to question why he'd point the finger at the two people we've been thinking were guilty.

Looking beyond just post count as activity - look at all 10 posts he's made (9, ignoring his signup post) - and he has offered absolutely nothing this entire game. No help to town, just posting gifs are the occasional vote to not be removed from the game - the bare minimum needed. And while yes, this may have been the logic Klippy uses - you should know of anyone that using a dead mafia's logic doesn't make someone suss. Letting your own decisions being influenced by the words of a dying mafia player is questionable. Whenever they know they're on their deathbed, they'll always try to leave some manner of misdirection for the townies. Trying to read into it can cause confusion - personally I think it's best to rely on what you know , and not making assumptions based on a publicly announced misdirection. Nevertheless, what I'm saying hardly matters to you Bard, since I'm confident you're a recruit. :P

 

[jdthebud]

Assuming the cultists aren't idiots, they know that I'm consistently checked by the Hooker. I haven't been able to kill in days.

Hey there, did you see my post here?

Bact, did you ever post your NA list? I'm interested in seeing it if not.

Still waiting to hear from Johnny as well. >_>

Johnny's action as a ghoul was used on Nimsy, since he says his action was used up. Though why he chose Nimsy is beyond me...

o/

Do you have any info from last night?

For now, here's my vote. I'll be online for the EoD if new information comes to light though.

[Vote] Grey Bidoof

 

[Ullion]

If I'm a recruit, it would've had to have been very recent - perhaps you think my behavior now is somehow changed from its previous course?

...yeah, maybe it has, but that's mainly because I'm concerned about this:

To be quite honest with you, I have a hunch you and Johnny have been the cult's 2 most recent targets. It helps that you two are the most active in the thread and guiding lots of discussion and with how unorganized the town is. Plus you and Johnny have been confirmed as not being the cult leader - so another good reason to be recruited at this point, imo. :d

If I continue with honesty - I'm not even sure I can even win as an inno. With how long the cult has been alive and how few people remain, if the cult leader does die then the mafia probably wins instantly. :/ If I choose to target and lynch mafia, then the mafia could be finished and then the cult will have majority for day lynches. XD I feel quite powerless in this situation, so I'll leave my vote on Grey Doof.

 

[Ullion]

Well, since I am most definitely not a cultist, I am whole-heartedly for the destruction of the head cultist... which is why I'm keeping my vote where it is. I don't trust you or your fingerpointing and I feel like you're trying to protect jd - who made a claim that was both hard to counter and while with a means of proving it there (by tying up the vote) that would never be tested, ever. So that's my pick, and I see you as his right-hand man... but it's too late now. Enjoy the win cultists. You've done a valiant job alongside the mafia sidestepping this ****-for-brains town that I am an unfortunate and equally inept member of. I hope you choke on the sweet, sweet steel of the mafia's blades before they find themselves strangled by the town's noose.

The bolded statement makes me quite concerned for whatever it is you're up to, because this makes no sense whatsoever. Nagi has confirmed that the both of us can't be the head cultist. Yet you say you're up for killing the head cultist and hence your reasoning for voting for me over anyone else (where you later point that you believe jd is the head). So if you believe he is the head, why vote me and not him?

 

[Mana1]

[lynch] Grey Bidoof

Gonna go with Ullion's gut ;-;. Maybe he'll roll culthead or mafia at least.

 

[Lycanthropy]

Time's up!

 

[Lycanthropy]

Back to the Basics

N8

​

Bidoof look so innocent and so cute (or something?), but not this one. Two mafia down.

GreyBidoof is dead! He was mafia!​

Players

Bardothren
Ullion
jdthebud
Elektra Heart
Collector Elwood
JohnnyMustang
Mana
Nagi
Hibikaze [N0]
Nina [N0]
Kaneki!!! [D1]
Nimsy [N2]
Superjolt [N2]
Lisia [D3]
Candy [N3]
Golgari [N3]
Davepetasprite^2 [D4]
Lost [D4]
TheCapsFan [D4]
alexkaz61 [D5]
[g="daily"]Charlie Brown[/g] [N5]
NightKrow [D6]
Desinishon [D6]
honey [N6]
KetsuekiR [N6]
Klippy [D7]
CatmanDaTrainer [N7]
GreyBidoof [D8]

omg this is the best thing ever. And here I was wondering if it would be chill for someone with dozens of games under their belt to pop by and say 'hey, can I play with the beginners?' and then this happened. HOORAY! Count me in.

Yes, for sure. 100%

Me please.

In it to win it.

WHAT MORE DO I HAVE TO SAY LYCAN SIGN ME UP BABY

excellent

Hi

Okay yeah, I think I can handle one more. Especially since it's simple. In.

f yes let's get jiggy with some 'nilla

I'm in.

No, they're all salt flavoured. c:

o/ meeee?

can i still join?

Wakey, wakey.

 

[Lycanthropy]

The end of the night is right here. Day post upcoming!

 

[Lycanthropy]

Back to the Basics

D9

​

Double kill! With the mafia crumbling down (as well as the entire town's population), the game was coming close to the end. Prepare for your lynches, town. At this point, you can't really afford any mistakes.

Bardothren is dead! He was mafia!

Nagi is dead! She was innocent!​

Players

Ullion
jdthebud
Elektra Heart
Collector Elwood
JohnnyMustang
Mana
Hibikaze [N0]
Nina [N0]
Kaneki!!! [D1]
Nimsy [N2]
Superjolt [N2]
Lisia [D3]
Candy [N3]
Golgari [N3]
Davepetasprite^2 [D4]
Lost [D4]
TheCapsFan [D4]
alexkaz61 [D5]
[g="daily"]Charlie Brown[/g] [N5]
NightKrow [D6]
Desinishon [D6]
honey [N6]
KetsuekiR [N6]
Klippy [D7]
CatmanDaTrainer [N7]
GreyBidoof [D8]
Bardothren [N8]
Nagi [N8]

omg this is the best thing ever. And here I was wondering if it would be chill for someone with dozens of games under their belt to pop by and say 'hey, can I play with the beginners?' and then this happened. HOORAY! Count me in.

Yes, for sure. 100%

Me please.

In it to win it.

WHAT MORE DO I HAVE TO SAY LYCAN SIGN ME UP BABY

excellent

Okay yeah, I think I can handle one more. Especially since it's simple. In.

f yes let's get jiggy with some 'nilla

I'm in.

o/ meeee?

can i still join?

Hello!

 

[Mana1]

To lose now we'd have to mislynch today, and lose two innos at night. Not totally impossible, but I doubt Bac would go risking any kill that wasn't certain at this point.

The cult has gotta be dead at this point, unless they've been sitting on two players and not recruiting.