Ok good, this is what I was hoping for
Her posts gave off an impression that she has played before, like the way #47 was worded (unless she's just an eager newbie player but I'll let her answer that). Why should I wait for someone to respond before voting? I am waiting to see her response.
This seems a tad chainsaw-ish, especially for someone that hasn't had a chance to respond yet
What do you think of Home so far?
I didn't really read any of her posts as coming from someone with experience with the game, otherwise instead of "do not like" there would have been questions or reads or a vote, and instead of "its too quiet" there would have been something like what Aaron did, if anything at all. Nothing she has done so far is indicative of her alignment for a new player - and that's why you should've waited for her response, you don't really have anything on her other than that she doesn't know what she's doing.
(also I was there in the UGDC when she was having OMGUS explained to her so she can't be that experienced)
As for Home, I don't really agree with his "random lynch = scum" reasoning, but I do like how he's being skeptical of what you're saying. That's certainly not something I would have done when I was new to the UG - you're the guy with all the quotes who always seems to know what's what, and a fresh UGer would probably be more inclined to follow that than to question it. Having said that, sticking to the "random lynch = scum" reasoning for the sake of consistency doesn't look too good either - there could be lots of different reasons for voting randomly, and it looks like Aaron used it in a town sided way. I'd say I'm reading null on Home for now, maybe possible town lean for his questioning nature.
Your turn. What's your opinion on Radiating and tokyodrift, given his newest vote?
Also @everyone else, opinions on Superjolt/purplecicada?
edit: also why was my vote not counted? :(