• Our friends from the Johto Times are hosting a favorite Pokémon poll - and we'd love for you to participate! Click here for information on how to vote for your favorites!
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.
    Register

Chemical castration

Pachy said:
The effect isn't permanent. They have to go in every so often and get another shot to keep them chemically castrated. Fortunately the flight risk can be averted by forcing all chemically castrated offenders to wear a waterproof tracking device on their ankle.
Click to expand...

That's good then. Fully in favour of this. Can administer the dose to match the severity of the crime then if not permanent.
 
Actually, over time the effect does become permanent ~ just is in many transgirl, the testes atrophy and begin to lose functionality. Tho coming off anti-androgens does restore a mostly baseline testosterone level; there's a very very high chance of permanent sterility.

Of course, it's outrageous that there are thousands of transgirls in the US that desperately need these medications as part of their treatment ~ but can't get them; yet they're going to give them to sex offenders for free?
 
I don't know about this :| This sounds a bit inhuman... granted, rapists are pretty messed up in the head, but I still don't feel quite right about this.

If I were to do something to earn this, I would rather rot in jail for a long time.
 
I'd want it to be passed. Those who abuse it should lose it.

And trannys don't DESPERATELY need anything. It's not like food and shelter. I'm not going to pay (through tax dollars) for them to change their body, because I couldn't give a crap whether or not someone wants to be a girl or guy. They can deal, or pay for it themselves.

It's just as outrageous as me demanding everyone else to pay for any plastic surgery or even personal gym trainers, nutritionists, psychologists, etc if I wanted something extra out of my life.

HEY YOU CAN PAY FOR A CHIROPRACTOR FOR ME! I NEED TO GET INSOLES FOR MY SHOES!!
 
Last edited:
i think they should use a guillotine for pedafilez and chemical castration for people who go around spreading AIDz on purpose...i'm sure no one disagreez with me on that last one......
 
Kura said:
I'd want it to be passed. Those who abuse it should lose it.

And trannys don't DESPERATELY need anything. It's not like food and shelter. I'm not going to pay (through tax dollars) for them to change their body, because I couldn't give a crap whether or not someone wants to be a girl or guy. They can deal, or pay for it themselves.

It's just as outrageous as me demanding everyone else to pay for any plastic surgery or even personal gym trainers, nutritionists, psychologists, etc if I wanted something extra out of my life.

HEY YOU CAN PAY FOR A CHIROPRACTOR FOR ME! I NEED TO GET INSOLES FOR MY SHOES!!
Click to expand...
It's not a *want*. It's a *need*. It's a medically accepted mental illness that can generally only be treated by transition. You're being an idiot. It's like saying "diabetics don't need insulin shots" or people who have an infection don't need antibiotics. Do not come here and talk about stuff you have no idea about; just makes you look like a moron.
 
Bianca Paragon said:
It's not a *want*. It's a *need*. It's a medically accepted mental illness that can generally only be treated by transition. You're being an idiot. It's like saying "diabetics don't need insulin shots" or people who have an infection don't need antibiotics. Do not come here and talk about stuff you have no idea about; just makes you look like a moron.
Click to expand...
By transexual are you talking about homosexual people who seeks for sex change or hermafroditism?
 
Throat said:
By transexual are you talking about homosexual people who seeks for sex change or hermafroditism?
Click to expand...
Uhh..actually a good amount of transgendered folk don't identify as homosexuals, at all. But yes, I refer to transgendered folk, not to hermaphrodites who are, generally speaking, "corrected" physically at birth by removal of the male genitals.
 
Bianca Paragon said:
Uhh..actually a good amount of transgendered folk don't identify as homosexuals, at all. But yes, I refer to transgendered folk, not to hermaphrodites who are, generally speaking, "corrected" physically at birth by removal of the male genitals.
Click to expand...
Aw... it seems quite more complicated than hermafroditism then. Doesn't government support people who are born with such problems?
 
In modern, first-world countries; if you have gone thru all the official channels? Sure. But in the US? You're on your own.
 
Bianca Paragon said:
It's not a *want*. It's a *need*. It's a medically accepted mental illness that can generally only be treated by transition. You're being an idiot. It's like saying "diabetics don't need insulin shots" or people who have an infection don't need antibiotics. Do not come here and talk about stuff you have no idea about; just makes you look like a moron.
Click to expand...

You really shouldn't be saying that, just because she doesn't know about this doesn't mean you can talk to her like that.

ON-TOPIC: I think this is a great way to kill the Pedo Bear.
 
インフェルノの津波 said:


You really shouldn't be saying that, just because she doesn't know about this doesn't mean you can talk to her like that.

ON-TOPIC: I think this is a great way to kill the Pedo Bear.
Click to expand...
It's the only way she'll learn~
Don't think of me as an aggressor; instead consider me an educator.
 
Bianca Paragon said:
It's the only way she'll learn~
Don't think of me as an aggressor; instead consider me an educator.
Click to expand...

All we need is an "educator" that wants to preach for the opposite side, and we've got a locked topic :\

I guess castration wouldn't be so bad as an option, on second thought. As a replacement? I don't think so: I think that this process is unnatural enough to where a person should get to choose a very long time in jail over the treatment. It's as if we were to alter the brain to where it could not comprehend theft as a punishment for thieves: we lose a major part of our personalities in the process and become less human. I think that's a punishment too cruel to force on people, but I welcome the option.

It's always tough to decide if rapists deserve to be treated as humans or vermin... arguably, they could be viewed as either one.
 
Bianca Paragon said:
It's the only way she'll learn~
Don't think of me as an aggressor; instead consider me an educator.
Click to expand...

Oh, you just come across as a perpetually angry young man.

And I suppose this kind of treatment is fine if the offender decides he wants to reform. I dunno, I don't really have an opinion on the matter - I thought this topic was going to be about dogs.
 
Jolene said:
Oh, you just come across as a perpetually angry young man.
Click to expand...
Call me a man again and I'll be shure to report your post~
 
Chemical castration feels like someone's hope that drugs will fix a problem they can't think of a better way to fix. Kind of like how lots of kids with behavioral problems are on medication.

I think it's irresponsible and potentially dangerous to give rapists drugs and then release them to the public. Aside from the fact I think they should be punished, if they're let out too soon there's no way of knowing how likely they are to find other ways of hurting people or even how well the castration worked on them.

And BP has a point. If she's expected to work for her medicines then these rapists should have to earn their castration somehow.
 
The idea seems good, in theory. But does this drug have adverse effects or does it become ineffective in people who take certain medication?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top