4th Gen Did you give back Shuckie and Kenya?

[cxd]

I gave Shuckie back, without really meaning to. I went back to Cianwood to show the guy that I still had Shuckie, expecting that he would say I could keep it like he did in Gold. Instead, he took it back, which was a little disappointing.

They didn't change anything, you can keep him in all five games, but it needs to have high friendship.
___
I just wanted to give Shuckie back in HG, but then I realised I didn't even have it (I've got it in gen II, but not in IV) xD I know you're supposed to return it when you beat your rival at Mt. Moon, but he still gave it to me after that. So I think I can't give it back :(

 

[Inferna]

I had no idea you could give Shuckie back xD
I always give Kenya back though, the guilt is too much!

 

[Hikamaru]

I remember holding on to Shuckie for a while, but returned him since I don't like using nicknames on my team.

Haven't used Kenya though, so no comment there.

 

[Yiazmat]

I bred Shuckie then gave back, felt bad keeping it I guess.

 

[Sweets Witch]

I kept Shuckie because I boxed it and forgot about it, but I gave Kenya back because I had my own Spearow. Shuckie might be on its way out too since I don't like having Pokemon that other people have nicknamed.

 

[Venitardus]

i gave Kenya back, i kept shuckie. i totally forgot about it

 

[Lusus]

i usually just leave them in my PC boxes,they help increasing the chance you win a lottery in Goldenrod,especially if you have nobody to trade with(not me tough). I wish Shuckle would keep the Berry Juice and Rare Candy generating mechanic from Gen 2 because that would have made at least one of them actually useful lol

 

[Isseubnida]

No, I still use them, like the stingy person I am.