• Ever thought it'd be cool to have your art, writing, or challenge runs featured on PokéCommunity? Click here for info - we'd love to spotlight your work!
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.
    Register

Do you consider video game music to be real music?

I see where the OP was going with this, it's just poor choice in wording. It's like asking if video games are art vs whether or not video games have components of art. Now asking about video games being art? THAT'S a topic of debate.

I'll just put it this way. A majority of the music I listen to comes from video games. And not even the most recent ones at that unless they're part of a franchise I keep up with. Otherwise I'm still listening to music from the 4th generation of video games.
 
Most of the songs I have on my playlist are songs from the games I play, and it's funny because today I was listening to the music from Pokemon Mystery Dungeon time/darkness/sky on youtube, It reminded me how much I loved those games! Brought memories back and made me smile once again! Other than pokemon music, games such as assassins creed and skyrim have fantastic music!
 
I would definitely say video game music is "real" music (not least because well, what's music that isn't real?).

Assassin's Creed 3's music often has hints of Pirates of the Caribbean in it, and pretty much nobody would argue that film scores aren't real music. (Interestingly, the voice of Faulkner is that of the actor who plays Gibbs in Pirates).

And c'mon, would the battles against Lance and Red in HeartGold/SoulSilver be half as dramatic without that brilliant battle theme? (Possibly my favourite out of the entire series). Or its 8-bit remix? In many cases the music makes the scene/game.
 
At least 75% of the music I listen to is from video games. Music from Touhou Project for example could easily be mistaken for non- videogame music. This is the reason why when you look at video game reviews, whether it be Game informer, IGN, or even the reviews on this site, there's a section for music, or sound, etc.

I could list at least a pageful of fantastic music in games. IMO video games themselves are a type of art form.

And to rest my case...

-written while listening to the special orchastera CD that came in the collectors edition pack for the 25th Annevirsery version of Legend of Zelda: The Skyward Sword (seriously.)


 
Last edited:
It depends on the "type" of music. With 8-Bit songs i'd say it can be considered as music, but it doesn't really have to. Of course it has a melody and all that, and i would definitely consider it a tune, but i dont think i would call it music. If we look at videogame soundtracks past the 8-Bit era, i would definitely consider them music, some are even masterpieces! The art of videogame music imo is to stress and underline what is happening in the game and what the protagonists are feeling. Some games have beautiful soundtracks, and it would be a crime not to consider these masterpieces music
 
Music is music some music is good , some bad but videogame music is just the same as normal music, but serves a different purpose
 
Music is music is music. VGM is just music serving its medium, much like film or TV. It sets tone and pace, and it colours a world or event.
 
Yup, it IS music! :) Video game and video game inspired music are my absolute favorite forms of music as well! ^ ^
 
I think what you and I would define as 'real music' and be quite different. As such, I don't think there is no such thing as fake music, or 'not real music', and considering the basic definition for music is organised sound, yes, I think video game music is real music.

EDIT

I just read the OP, probably should have done that originally. Good to see you have the same ideas!
 
I do see it officially as "Music" yes. People have worked hard on creating games with amazing soundtracks (Sonic 06's OST for example was AMAZING)

I listen to nothing but Video Game soundtracks.
 
I agree with video game music being music, and video game music has some of the most beautiful songs out there. For example, Memory of Light and Waves from Final Fantasy is probably one of my favorites, along with the ending theme from Ruby and Sapphire. And of course there's the Skyrim main theme. However, I probably wouldn't listen to video game music on my ipod or something, as I prefer 'regular' music instead. But when I'm playing the game, the music can make the mood so much better.(And I'll admit, I do sing along to the Skyrim theme every time I put the game in :D)
 
Why in the world wouldn't it be real music?

It's made using the mostly the same methods other musical genres are made?
 
I'm really happy, reading through this thread, that so many people agree with each other on how Video Games are just as prominent towards art as anything else. It's a fantastic point of view and one that I hope will become the social norm as time progresses.
 
Why not? I love putting on some VGMs when I'm bored. I mean think about it, they call dubstep music, personally I think it's a load of garbage but I know others like it and so be it. In fact, developers put alot of time into music to help it fit the mood and scene of the game they're trying to create, and in the long run most of the tracks become some really good chill music or some pump kick butt tunes when your button-mashing at those MMOs.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top