Emerald Island Gang Wars

Seems like the right thing to do.

[Lynch] Salzorrah
 
jdthebud said:
Not sending in a NA as a bodyguard is a bad claim. You're lying.
Click to expand...

Ok then answer me this

Why would I claim Norman, out of all the roles I could claim? If I was scum, I could have just claimed Pokemon Ranger.

Also, why would I tell everyone that I never sent in my NA? If I was scum, I would have lied about it, and told claims about it.

also before anyone forgets seth tried to claim Norman from me

EDIT: OK I CHECKED THE DAY 2 PHASE AGAIN.

JD, YOU'RE LIZA RIGHT? WHO THE HELL DID YOU TARGET ON N1?

Shelly tried to kill Nero
Brawly blocks Shelly
Juan tries to save Nero
Liza switches Shelly and Brawly.

Would explain why Nero was roleblocked that night, AND why there was no night kill, because why the hell would Shelly kill herself?

Case in point. Jd and Zap know who is Shelly, based on who they targeted on N1/D2.

If for some reason I still fucked it up, it's still clear that Brawly tried to block Shelly, so Zap should def know who they targeted.

Zapmolticuno said:
tell us god fucking damn it
Click to expand...


You're fucking welcome sir.
 
Last edited:
Read through some previous posts and I didn't see Nero's reports from yesterday, despite reading he had them. Zap and jd you should say who've you been targeting to verify. EC, you should also out your role now so we know what role is left. Gunner did bring up a valid point and we should try and piece it together. Something could be up, lloebot may have messed something up, or Gunner's still trying to convince us that she's norman even though we have so many confirmed innos.
 
Salzorrah said:
Ok then answer me this

Why would I claim Norman, out of all the roles I could claim? If I was scum, I could have just claimed Pokemon Ranger.

Also, why would I tell everyone that I never sent in my NA? If I was scum, I would have lied about it, and told claims about it.
Click to expand...

So what you're saying is that you did exactly what you think doesn't look like something scum would do, when the point is to not look like mafia.

Salzorrah said:
EDIT: OK I CHECKED THE DAY 2 PHASE AGAIN.

JD, YOU'RE LIZA RIGHT? WHO THE HELL DID YOU TARGET ON N1?

Shelly tried to kill Nero
Brawly blocks Shelly
Juan tries to save Nero
Liza switches Shelly and Brawly.

Would explain why Nero was roleblocked that night, AND why there was no night kill, because why the hell would Shelly kill herself?
Click to expand...

That looks to me like Shelly would target me, Juan successfully healing afterwards, and Brawly RBing himself. We know this isn't what happened. Liza switches around the players positions at night, not the person they target, as far as I'm aware.
 
I switched Nero and Seth Rollins on Night 1, when all the crazy stuff happened.
Salzorrah said:
Ok then answer me this

Why would I claim Norman, out of all the roles I could claim? If I was scum, I could have just claimed Pokemon Ranger.

Also, why would I tell everyone that I never sent in my NA? If I was scum, I would have lied about it, and told claims about it.

also before anyone forgets seth tried to claim Norman from me

EDIT: OK I CHECKED THE DAY 2 PHASE AGAIN.

JD, YOU'RE LIZA RIGHT? WHO THE HELL DID YOU TARGET ON N1?

Shelly tried to kill Nero
Brawly blocks Shelly
Juan tries to save Nero
Liza switches Shelly and Brawly.
Click to expand...
Nero said:
So what you're saying is that you did exactly what you think doesn't look like something scum would do, when the point is to not look like mafia.



That looks to me like Shelly would target me, Juan successfully healing afterwards, and Brawly RBing himself. We know this isn't what happened. Liza switches around the players positions at night, not the person they target, as far as I'm aware.
Click to expand...

So what happens is that Whoever targeted Nero that night, targeted Seth instead, and whoever targeted Seth, targeted Nero instead.

My interpretation:

Shelly shoots Nero
Shelly (probably) blocks Nero as well
Juan saves Nero
Brawly roleblocks Seth

Zap, can you confirm you targeted Seth on Night 1?
 
Last edited:
jdthebud said:
I switched Nero and Seth Rollins on Night 1, when all the crazy stuff happened.



So what happens is that Whoever targeted Nero that night, targeted Seth instead, and whoever targeted Seth, targeted Nero instead.

My interpretation:

Shelly shoots Nero
Shelly (probably) blocks Nero as well
Juan saves Nero
Brawly roleblocks Seth

Zap, can you confirm you targeted Seth on Night 1?
Click to expand...

I blocked Gunner on that night.
 
Correction: On night 1, I blocked jdthebud. PM got caught up in a mess so sorry.
 
No, that can't be right. The N1 phase post clearly says that Liza used their action, and as far as we can tell they swapped Brawly and Shelly's target around with someone else, the someone being me. If Liza was Brawly's target and Liza never swapped Seth and I, then you would have been told you were roleblocked and the night post would be different, Jd. I'm wondering if Banette could've messed everything up that night.
 
Honestly I'm a bit confuzzled about this too so Baenette probs messed with us, but we don't have much of a description other then that. I'm just going to keep it on Gunner. Let's hope that it ends this flawlessly.
 
So what happens if the GM can't get back into the forums because of the forced password change?
 
I'm pretty sure he's working it out with the admins. Someone else could probably fill in as GM if it takes too long.

EC, you really need to claim a role.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top