Full Metal Alchemist Fan Club

[Charizard★]

Aha.. my mistake. :P
I've just Pm'd it to you because your vms are disabled.
Plus, it said to PM it.

Its fine XD

Welcome to the club!

New topic added~
Which (In your opinion) is better FMA or FMA:B?

 

[Pokestick good times.]

FMA:B is, in my opinion.

The story makes more sense to me, it's way more satisfactory, its re-watching value is way higher. The graphics and the music is way above the 2003 series' level, and the opening and ending sequences still makes me eye/eargasm :P

 

[Charizard★]

I didn't see FMA yet so I'll say FMA:B for now. I mean the art is great, the plot is great and so are the characters.

 

[Pokestick good times.]

FMA's story is both shorter and... weirder. They go off topic early on, and add things that doesn't make sense, IMO. Just fillers and stuff.

And after a while things start to go really weird,

Spoiler:

Rosé gets raped, then becomes a priest, Edward dies, gets resurrected, IS TELEPORTED INTO THE REAL WORLD, TAKING OVER A BODY, fighting nazis, meeting IRL versions of FMA characters, real people are dragged into the story (Hitler), and finally, a big German warship travels to the FMA world, killing people, and Edward, Al, other Al, other Rosé, Roy and other people fight them and the Japanese dragon Envy, who's actually Edward's brother, created by his father and Dante, who's immortal, resulting in Ed and Al living in the real world for the rest of their lives, trying to stop the Atom bomb!

...*pant*, *pant*

Do you get my point? xD;

 

[Charizard★]

FMA's story is both shorter and... weirder. They go off topic early on, and add things that doesn't make sense, IMO. Just fillers and stuff.

And after a while things start to go really weird,

Spoiler:

Rosé gets raped, then becomes a priest, Edward dies, gets resurrected, IS TELEPORTED INTO THE REAL WORLD, TAKING OVER A BODY, fighting nazis, meeting IRL versions of FMA characters, real people are dragged into the story (

Spoiler:

Hitler), and finally, a big German warship travels to the FMA world, killing people, and Edward, Al, other Al, other Rosé, Roy and other people fight them and the Japanese dragon Envy, who's actually Edward's brother, created by his father and Dante, who's immortal, resulting in Ed and Al living in the real world for the rest of their lives, trying to stop the Atom bomb!

...*pant*, *pant*

Do you get my point? xD;

SPOILER ALERT!

*covers eyes*

Oh, you just edited it and put the spoilers :o

 

[Pokestick good times.]

No, I put it in spoilers first, then the spoilers effed up, then I tried to fix it xD;

It's fixed now.

 

[Charizard★]

No, I put it in spoilers first, then the spoilers effed up, then I tried to fix it xD;

It's fixed now.

Oh, okay then XD

Spoiler:

I only read that Rose gets raped xD But, I think I remember that part :o

Is the FMA manga better than FMA:B?

 

[Pokestick good times.]

I haven't read much of the manga, so I can't really put them against each others.

FMA:B does actually add fillers, like the first episode, and things are removed, like the island scenes where Ed and Al train when they were kids.

But the manga style is actually kind of weird, it's not very pleasing to the eye.
A friend of mine says that because of the quality, the anime is better. But that's his opinion.

 

[Charizard★]

I haven't read much of the manga, so I can't really put them against each others.

FMA:B does actually add fillers, like the first episode, and things are removed, like the island scenes where Ed and Al train when they were kids.

But the manga style is actually kind of weird, it's not very pleasing to the eye.
A friend of mine says that because of the quality, the anime is better. But that's his opinion.

Oh, I have only read the last chapter and it was pretty good :o

And I'd have to say the anime ending is better.

 

[Pokestick good times.]

Yeah. and it's fun hearing voices and music and stuff xD

 

[Charizard★]

Yeah. and it's fun hearing voices and music and stuff xD

lmao.


Its funny how much similar and different some of the Eng. Dub voices are compared to the Jap. Dub :o

 

[Pokestick good times.]

Really?

I think Vic's voice isn't even close to the original, e.g.

 

[Charizard★]

Some of the voices are, like Armstrong's (boy). It sounded kinda similar.


Oh and I made a group:
https://www.pokecommunity.com/group.php?groupid=2485

 

[Pokestick good times.]

I joined. :D

Oh well, I don't listen to the dubs very often.

 

[Charizard★]

I joined. :D

Oh well, I don't listen to the dubs very often.

Good :D

I only listened to dubs because I also watch it on Adult Swim.

 

[Pokestick good times.]

We don't have Adult Swim here :<

But that's just another reason to use the almighty internet :D

 

[Charizard★]

lol XD

Added mervyn797 as a member~
Welcome to the group :D

 

[Pokestick good times.]

Hello Mervyn!

The club is growing, indeed.

Anyway, I saw both the whole series online; the old show was on ZTV back when it existed though.

 

[Charizard★]

Hello Mervyn!

The club is growing, indeed.

Anyway, I saw both the whole series online; the old show was on ZTV back when it existed though.

The old series never finished airing on Adult Swim so I never really got to finish it :/

And yes it is, at the rate of 2 members per day :o

 

[Pokestick good times.]

The positive part is that ZTV aired it subbed and in its unedited state :3

The negative parts are that it was broadcasted 1 AM, and that the channel doesn't exist any more x|