Graphic Rating Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
please rate my scratch made, exclusive use, Lucario. It' is MY Lucario, who has the same style as it's owner :):

[PokeCommunity.com] Graphic Rating Thread



EDIT:
taken the pic to the Photoshop 9.0 CS2 for a filter and some recoloring:

[PokeCommunity.com] Graphic Rating Thread
 
Last edited:
Young Wallflower: Nice sigs. Those are have great lighting and depth to them. The first should probably have more color to it and the second one needs a more established flow. I'm thinking it's / this way but I'm not sure.
 
Been some time since I've played with photoshop lately.
The first one here I had a hard time with since it deals with C4D's


[PokeCommunity.com] Graphic Rating Thread

[PokeCommunity.com] Graphic Rating Thread


@Young Wallflower:I like the way your sigs turned out.
But the x-men one looks like I've seen it before.
 
Last edited:
Angle-san: They look really great, especially the first one. I like the colors in it and it has a great flow. The second one looks good also, but I think the first one is really great. The text looks good on both of them, too.

Could someone rate my current for me please? Thanks~ =D
 
Thank you ChocoFlamingo.

I like it I enjoy that style even thought I can't do it yet but I love it.
Just what's with the ASA font?
 
ChocoFlamingo: I think he means, either: What's it doing there, or What does it mean?

I'm asking, what is it doing there? xD; I think it would've looked a lot better with just that teal as the solid color without the stroke, and by placing it in a place less obscured, the banner would look a little more balanced, and less busy all in one place.

However, the only thing I don't like about it is the text itself, the rest is wonderful, and I love that style!

8/10. I think a more curly, less imposing font would've been a nicer choice. Maybe much lowered opacity to match the rest of the style.

Angle-san: DDD: Why do all you peoples work with the styles I can't?? (Why am I always stuck with vector?? Dx)

Anyway, I do love both of them, and disregarded my hatred for Ash, I do like the Ash banner better. The reason? I like the colors, the text placement, and almost everything about it, especially the green. It's just... ASH. *twitch*

Right-o, but I won't dock you points for that, 10/10. I didn't really get a good look at the first one, so I don't think I'll rate that one, sorry. ^^; (Besides, Renamon bugs me more then Ash... which is saying something. >.<)

Sawyer: It was an old post, but I dunno if you should tell people to rate your's if you're not rating anyone else's. :/ You certainly didn't say anything about mine after I rated your's.
--

Believe it or not, this is one of my first banners I've made without a border. *shot for being stupid* I've been so paranoid about having them, so I'd like some thoughts on it. I'm really happy with the way it turned out, considering I searched in vain for a good Hinamori picture and ended up with an IchigoxRukia picture. xD;

[PokeCommunity.com] Graphic Rating Thread

Any comments and criticism would be much appreciated!!
 
Last edited:
I don't know what I can say about it as I'm more of a banner and avatar rater and don't know much about doing things with real humans, but the eye in the middle is awesome. I don't know why, but I've always liked close-ups of eyes.

And I can't tell if it was three images slapped together, or one render put onto a homemade background.

Three images slapped together: 7.5/10
Render && Homemade background: 9.5/10, I can't say I really like the bottom-most image.
 
ChocoFlamingo said:
Thanks a lot!
Whadda you mean what's with it?
The fact that the inside is transparent?
Click to expand...

Jyukai said:
I think he means, either: What's it doing there, or What does it mean?
Click to expand...

I'm asking what is it doing there?

Jyukai said:
Angle-san: DDD: Why do all you peoples work with the styles I can't?? (Why am I always stuck with vector?? Dx)

Anyway, I do love both of them, and disregarded my hatred for Ash, I do like the Ash banner better. The reason? I like the colors, the text placement, and almost everything about it, especially the green. It's just... ASH. *twitch*

Right-o, but I won't dock you points for that, 10/10. I didn't really get a good look at the first one, so I don't think I'll rate that one, sorry. ^^; (Besides, Renamon bugs me more then Ash... which is saying something. >.<)
Click to expand...
Thank you for your rate.
It's taken me forever to get to this state and yet I'm still not good with it.

Now it's time I rate your banner: I'm a fan of vectors indeed I like the use of the brush set your using.
9.5/10
 
Angle-san: I like both of your banners. The first one has nice flow, and good colours. The effects are nice too. Not a big fan of the text, though... And maybe add more lighting? 9.5/10

For the second one, I like the colours =D The text is nice, too, but I really don't like the text with 'Angle' on the top left hand corner. The font looks a bit too distracting. But still, good lighting and good effects, again. 9/10

ChocoFlamingo: I don't know why, but I really, really, really like it. But I also think that the text could be moved where it would balance out the banner. It's a bit too busy around the center of the banner. 9/10

Jyukai: I know I already said it in the "Rate the THEME Above You" thread, but I think that banner is awesome =D *can't be bothered to say more about it* 9.5/10

Thomas-san: I'm not too good with rating things like this, so I might not know what I'm talking about O_o Erm... The images don't really look like they flow together nicely. I think it looks like three images put on top of each other, but I doubt that's true... I like the eye xP 7/10

-----

It's my first sprite tag. Be nice D:
[PokeCommunity.com] Graphic Rating Thread
 
@Shiranui: I am a fan of the sprite tags.
For this being your first I really like it.
Just to much black ya'know unless if your like me and see it as the sprite is jumping toward the light.
9.5/10
 
I like coloring manga thingies too! :D Except mine kind of suck.

I love. Absolutely love. The Rukia 'LOL' one. I really like the icons that are really clear-cut screenshots and super high quality. :D Nice jobu! 10.10

The Shinji one is also amazing. xDD Although it looks like, "Eat Bob" to me. ^^;; 9.5/10 for the "Eat Bob" thing. But I like the text, and the positioning is great.

Hinamori one, the colors are a bit too contrasting and darker for my tastes, but it's definetely a well shaded coloring job. 10.10 because you're beastage at coloring. :D
 
@Mikuru-chan

I really like the second one. keep it up

Alright I made a logo for my sig at a few other forums I just want to know what you guys think.


[PokeCommunity.com] Graphic Rating Thread
 
8/10 on those collectively. I could pretty much tell what you did.

I'd like to present my sig and avvie. More emphasis on the avvie.
 
Last edited:
Alright I made two new ones they kinda look the same the color one has a few things added on to it.

[PokeCommunity.com] Graphic Rating Thread


[PokeCommunity.com] Graphic Rating Thread
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top