Graphic Rating Thread

[Loki]

Thank you! ^^ [they all look the same though haaaa~] the shinshi doumei cross ones anyway.

Omigosh Shira-chan, the text on that banner is AMAZING.

+ The text. I love every last thing about the text. Placement. Font. Placement. Size. Placement. Arrangement. I love everything! >D
+ The textures! <333 I love the textures!!
+ The C4D in the background is great! It's the red glowy stuff, yazzumz? :O Do you make your own C4D's, or do you mooch them like me? Because that C4D matches really well! You incorporated it into the banner with such awesome-ness! <3
+ I love what you did with the texture on the render itself, the cutting out here and there.
+ Lighting! I love that red thing-y! Is that a camera flash filter? :O
+ POP-UP EFFECT, FTW.

- The only minus, I think it would've been triple as awesome if you'd slightly slightly textured the text, and made the texture on the stroke-y thing stand out a little more.

Still a solid [10.10] though!

Is it just me, or is the version in your sig sharper then the one in the img tags? o O; Or do I need new contacts? *shot'd*

edit-ching!: AHAHAHA. Smaller icon dump. It's my first try doing any actual graphical alteration to a picture that's not of anime! :O WHUT NAO? That's right. Before, I never even touched the images of real people used in my sets, if it weren't obvious.

I used orange -> purple gradient map... a lot. < <;; IT JUST LOOKED SO GOOD THOUGH. X_X; Actually they look pretty good in B&W too, but I couldn't part with the colors. :<

 

[Pikabloo]

Thanks for the comment ^^ I still think the C4Ds look off, though :| Maybe I'll try taking some of it off (I have like 6 layers of C4D x_x;; )

The C4Ds are the red-ish thingies in front of the character. I 'borrow' other people's C4Ds xD I don't even know how to make them.

Which red thingy? O_o The red thingy next to the character's head is just a brush stroke with a soft brush.

I was going to add texture to the text... But I was too lazy (plus I made it really late at night).

Har har, I sharpened the banner after I posted it here, so I forgot to change it. So no, you don't need to change your contacts xD

---

Those guys are pretty O_o The avatars are good, too! xD Yeah... They look very awesomes. I don't really have anything bad to say about them. No, really, they look great.

Yeah, the orange > purple gradient map is so awesome... Like, it can completely change the colours of the image, yet make it look very nice at the same time.

 

[DarkGreg]

Well, I only have one avatar made, it was yesterday when I was bored:

It's Victoria Beckham when she had long-ish hair. :3

Tell me what you think of this. Don't be expecting more of these from me.

 

[THIRTY-SIX]

Got kinda inspired by Vavavoom needing help

Basically a few of my other sigs mashed together.
cC

 

[Marauding Master]

I don't like the middle bit of it. It should be a solid color just like the rest. 7/10.

Please rate this:

https://fc01.deviantart.com/fs19/f/2007/227/a/5/CODE_RED_by_MaraudingMaster.jpg

 

[Loki]

Got kinda inspired by Vavavoom needing help

Basically a few of my other sigs mashed together.
cC

That's kinda hard to read.. xD;

undgrscore? underscore? undqrscore?? x_x

I'll edit with more rates sometime later today or tomorrow, for now I must gooo~ </3

 

[THIRTY-SIX]

Lol, yea its underscore. Notice the forth an last letter have the same 'image'.

 

[Rena]

Helvetica: The siggie's pretty kewl, but it's hard to read xD.
~ Rate my current signature, anyone?

 

[Chikara]

Ok, this is like my first EVER banner that actually impressed me... For MY skill level...
Ok, here goes...

I know... there's no brushes on it. I liked it this way, so I didn't want to mess it up.

 

[Hinamori_Momo]

That's really nice Chikara. 7/10

Here's one I made a few weeks ago but never really felt like using it in my sig until now.

And Here's a few minis I made.

 

[Loki]

Could someone rate this banner please? Tell me a few positives or negatives?

 

[THIRTY-SIX]

Chikara: Simple is always nice and refreshing sometimes. But imo the a's need to be lined up.
Rena: Like the bg, but you blended her in too much making it look like she's a painting on the wall. (of sorts). Animation gets annoying though.
Momo: Type is blurry on banner. Like the first two avatars though :)
Mizuki: Colours are a bit D: Contrast on focal seems different to the bg. The border doesn't help much either.

 

[Brandon-kun]

Not so new at graphics, but I would like some feedback on some icons. (All requests, so please don't take)

 

[Hinamori_Momo]

They're great. I like the first the most.

 

[Hazuki]

Rate these two please.

Yachiru pwns! =O

Mokona + Coffee = Completeness

 

[Loki]

I'm going to give you crits, okay? D: So if you don't want to see them, then don't read ahead. Or at least, don't read the -'s.

- The text is rather large, and positioned in an awkward way.
- The render doesn't take up all that much space in the banner itself.
- The render doesn't stick out, and actually kinda blends with the pink background. :<
- I think in some way, a border of SOME sort should've been incorporated. Maybe like, adding white to the edges to fade it out and make it look less 'boxy'.

+ The text stands out, AND matches the background
+ The background is nice, the brushes are light and not to "up-your-face".
+ The sparkle glitter stuff is fun. :3

8/10 - Because all around, it looks nice, there are just some details that could be smoothed out.

I'm too lazy to rate the Mokona one right now. x_x; Apologies. I will say though, that I feel that you blended the render a little too strongly with the background. </3

May I ask for a rating as well? 8D I made this for Marz. <3 BUT, BEFORE YOU SAY ANYTHING ABOUT HOW PIXELLY THE PICTURE IS... *yes I know. I don't need that pointed out a thousand times. :<*

 

[Hinamori_Momo]

I like it. And Marz really shows it off.

Here's some more made by Hazuki. These ones she made for me.

 

[Pikabloo]

Hazuki -
1. It's very preety, and pink. Erm, text looks off, though. Like, I don't think it looks well covering part of her head. The background is very lovely, and all the colours go together nicely. It could use a border, though.

2. The render is very nicely blended into the background. However, the text stands out a bit too much, and I think it could be moved off to the right a bit, since the right side of the banner looks ever-so-slightly empty. Once again, a border would be nice...

Mizuki -
Is that Lucy from Fairy Tail? O: Very nice... But methinks spatter + sparkle don't look too good together, but that's just my opinion. And I think that a slightly lighter shade of blue would go better with the image. But other than that, I luffles the pop-up ness, and the clipping mask to the left is nicely positioned ^^

Comments pleesh. Tis my first(-ish) manga colouring ^^

 

[Brandon-kun]

They're great. I like the first the most.

Thanks. ^^

Here are a few more:

Aaand, a random banner:

;P

 

[Loki]

@Shiranui: homaigawd joo like the clipping mask too? 8D *hurray~* That was like, my favorite part. xD And yes! It is Lucy from Fairy Tail! I saw this render on planetrenders and I was like, "Must use it! >D" And then I decided I like the style it was drawn in and read the manga and I looove it. x3 *Gray! NO PANTZ LOL*

AAAAND HOMGHOMG NATSUUUUUU~!!!

Natsu + Gray = FUNNEH.

I love the way you colored that. Why is everyone better at coloring stuff then I am? ;A; The textures you added onto the picture make it look SO awesome, and I LOVE the way you colored his skin and his hair and everything and I'm so jealous of ur skillz dood. >.<

@Rasengan: OMFG I LOVE THE FOURTH ICON RIGHT THERE! *amazingly hawt* I love the effect on the text as well, even though it makes the text extremely hard to read. :< The Rag and Bone one is amazing as well; AWESOME text. :3

Can't really say the same about the text on the random banner, and the blue seems like too impact-less a color for Sasuke. It's not my favorite, but it's not terrible. ^^