Actually, I don't see a real need for a Key Item for cutting trees since both ways work fine.. And anyway since the objective of the game is to steal as many pokemon as you can, there are bound to be lots of extra stolen filler pokemon that the player can lump a HM on.. The only reason why I think a Key Item Replacer would be necessary is for aesthetic reasons, like a nice Magikarp sub for crossing waters or Meowth hot-air balloon to fly.
It's for several reasons. One, you might want to be chopping down trees sooner than you'll be getting a promotion, and I don't want to force players to have to go through with getting a promotion to be able to chop trees down. ( And honestly, HM logic is rather silly in the games. Why would having possession of a badge that a Water-type gym leader hands out suddenly give your Pokémon the ability to use a move to slice down trees, when they could use that move just fine to slice down Pokémon beforehand? What on Earth do the two have to do with each other?)
Two, the Key Item that's handed out--the machete--has more than one purpose. It's used to chop down trees, yes; but it's also used to take hostages (there's no better way to get by a police blockade than grabbing their rookie and holding a nasty-looking knife to their throat), and will probably have other purposes later on.
Three, you'll already have to run around with a five-Pokémon party, because when you try to steal a Pokémon, they won't hand it over if you don't have a space for it--getting a Pokémon sent to the PC is for catching wild Pokémon, not for stealing already-caught Pokémon. If you need an HM slave as well, then you can only have a four-Pokémon party if you want to keep the option to steal Pokémon open. That's a bit too limiting.
So, while a Key Item replacement for Cut
is nice for aesthetics, it's also more practical, and is important to the plot.
Great ideas here :D I'd be checking back for updates. Is you project a group or solo effort?
Most of the work I'm doing myself, but several people are helping out on some sprites, maps, and plot ideas.
EDIT: Hey I just noticed this while browsing your main post a second time..The female Corey sprite looks awfully similar to Miyamoto (hairstyle and all), Jessie's mom. And the male Corey has green hair! *coughButch'sDad?cough* I'm gonna mess around with the sprite examples you've posted and see what I can do about the Rival's sprite, for some reason, the darker sprite colour is bugging me alot. >.<
Hah. The similar colors are coincidence, actually. Jessie and Butch both make cameo appearances in the game (in the first base, actually), and since Corey is much younger than both of them... Might be an extended family, though. You never know.
And yes, Leone is a darker color. This is not an accident, I wanted him to have that skin color. It's the same color his OW sprite has, too, and it's the color for him I saw in my head when I thought of the character. I actually had to use the palette for one of the boats to get that shade for him. Apparently, there isn't a single other sprite--OW or Trainer--in Pokémon FireRed that isn't white. Not even Brock's trainer sprite, despite the fact that he's clearly got darker skin in the animé.
So, I went through quite a bit of trouble to get Leone to be the darker sprite color that's bugging you, even having to change his hair color from the originally planned dark purple to a blue in order to fit with the OW palettes' limitations. I'd appreciate it if you didn't mess with him.
But if you want to mess with female Corey's shoulders, which got messed up when I flattened her to 16 colors and I haven't gotten around to fixing yet, I'd be grateful.
btw I'm so glad and surprised you're a girl..Not many girls past the puberty age still like Pokemon, glad to find a fellow female fan!
Glad to find that you're one, too. :D There certainly aren't enough post-preteen female fans out there.
In other news: Currently having trouble with the last big script in Pokémon Tower. There are two minor issues, to do with items and OW sprite placement, and they won't take long to fix. Then the whole mission will be up and running, woot.
... Though I suggest you don't talk to the Mediums. They won't initiate battles with you, but you can still initiate battles with them, and their Pokémon haven't been levelled down yet. I just haven't gotten around to that yet.
Edit: ... Erm, apologies if I came off as defensive over my sprite. I'm not going to edit the contents of this post because... well, because it would be lame of me to say something and then pretend I didn't say it. But I still apologize if I seemed snappy.