Mafia Madness: Guns [Game Over]

[Ullion]

Well, I felt that CapsFan was also flying under the radar on purpose. But now I don't really like his posts from the end of D3. Almost seems like he voted Catman just to ensure that Catman stayed in the lead in votes, possibly to keep a GreenLegend lynch from going through.

If this is true - then thats two of the remaining mafia right there.

 

[TheCapsFan]

Well, I felt that CapsFan was also flying under the radar on purpose. But now I don't really like his posts from the end of D3. Almost seems like he voted Catman just to ensure that Catman stayed in the lead in votes, possibly to keep a GreenLegend lynch from going through.

For your information, I was on vacation in New York for basically the first two days of the game. Although I'm not sure I ever announced this to the rest of the thread (my mistake), Lycan knew this, which is probably part of the reason why he let me live instead of modkilling me. I was not "flying under the radar on purpose." I checked in when I could, and made the decision that I felt would reveal the most information when I had the time. Second, I knew that whomever I voted yesterday, you would have found whatever action I made scummy in some way, Superjolt. This is why I was caught up on who to vote for. I ISO'd Catman, Green, and Mana, and I thought that Mana was the scummiest. However, if I had voted for Mana, my vote would have been wasted since there would not be enough support for a lynch. As for Green, well, I thought Catman was scummier.

Now it's a new day. [VOTE]: Mana For starters, you've contributed less to the game than I have. You voted Bact on Day 2 because you "thought Twiggy was inno." Given the fact that both players are now revealed to be town, I can see how extra knowledge could have played into your decision to vote Bact. You also voted Catman yesterday, who was ALSO revealed to be town.

Note that Mana apparently was given a vest as stated D1, so shooting him might not be the BEST option. Though I don't have a gun, I think that we should let them fly this phase. There's plenty of suspects, obviously. I don't think Green is in the clear just yet. Mars and honey could be iffy too. And I need to ISO Superjolt.

 

[Mars]

At least 2 left probably. There could be 3, it's hard to say because 22 players falls into that sort of "imperfect" range. 5/22 is about 23% and 6/22 is about 27%. So it could go either way really.

I've been thinking about it, and I'm almost certain that there are three left:
>Both of us recieved a gun on the same night, confirming the presence of a fab.
>Catman turned out to be innocent, confirming the presence of an illusionist.
>And Bac was Night Killed despite claiming to have a legit vest, probably confirming the presence of an alchemist.

 

[Nakuzami]

I think it's definitely time that the gunsmiths start claiming. They should state who they gunned, and from there we can figure out true from fab and either catch a mafia member or rule out which guns shouldn't be shot.

 

[Ullion]

night 0 - alexkaz61
night 1 - gimmpie
...yeah I messed up bad :|
night 2 - drewbie
night 3 - nakuzami

If you guys don't believe me go back and check the days immediately following the night I gave out a gun. I'd post as soon as I could after whomever I gave a gun usually stating that I trust said person. :)

 

[Nakuzami]

Well, I can verify that gun. As such, it seems likely to be real, and Ullion clear.

Time to test a theory.

 

[TheCapsFan]

I'll buy GP's claim, and Naku's too. That's two off the list.

EDIT: Just a notice, I will be gone for the large majority of tomorrow. My vote will stay where it is.

 

[Superjolt]

Spoiler:

For your information, I was on vacation in New York for basically the first two days of the game. Although I'm not sure I ever announced this to the rest of the thread (my mistake), Lycan knew this, which is probably part of the reason why he let me live instead of modkilling me. I was not "flying under the radar on purpose." I checked in when I could, and made the decision that I felt would reveal the most information when I had the time. Second, I knew that whomever I voted yesterday, you would have found whatever action I made scummy in some way, Superjolt. This is why I was caught up on who to vote for. I ISO'd Catman, Green, and Mana, and I thought that Mana was the scummiest. However, if I had voted for Mana, my vote would have been wasted since there would not be enough support for a lynch. As for Green, well, I thought Catman was scummier.

Now it's a new day. [VOTE]: Mana For starters, you've contributed less to the game than I have. You voted Bact on Day 2 because you "thought Twiggy was inno." Given the fact that both players are now revealed to be town, I can see how extra knowledge could have played into your decision to vote Bact. You also voted Catman yesterday, who was ALSO revealed to be town.

Note that Mana apparently was given a vest as stated D1, so shooting him might not be the BEST option. Though I don't have a gun, I think that we should let them fly this phase. There's plenty of suspects, obviously. I don't think Green is in the clear just yet. Mars and honey could be iffy too. And I need to ISO Superjolt.

Ok, well... if I'd known you were on vacation that might have changed things. Please don't make it sound like I'm not open to different thoughts and shifting reads though, because that's not true.

The thing around the EOD3 that kind of threw me a little was this:

Just checked votals, but they're pretty confusing, so I may have gotten them wrong. Catman is our lynch so far at 3 votes, we have 2 on NL and 2 on Green. Then 1 on Honey and I each.

Unsure if I want to vote for Catman, or vote for No Lynch. Let me ISO him real quick.

You talked about voting here like these were your only options and you weren't going to consider anything else. There was no mention of Green (besides the vote count) and I just thought it was weird. This most recent post from you really sounds like townie frustration to me though, and it's the kind of post I've really been hoping to see from you anyway. I'm with you on Mana. What are your general thoughts on Green and Mars?

I've been thinking about it, and I'm almost certain that there are three left:
>Both of us recieved a gun on the same night, confirming the presence of a fab.
>Catman turned out to be innocent, confirming the presence of an illusionist.
>And Bac was Night Killed despite claiming to have a legit vest, probably confirming the presence of an alchemist.

Yeah, this makes sense. What do you think about Johnny btw?

I fail to understand how can you not know the answer to this question, I also fail to understand the point of it.

Don't you remember you saying you couldn't shake your head around Mars, that something felt off?

Also, what do you think we should do know? It's great how you're making everyone talk but I think we have all the information we're gonna get until we claim.

I did say that, but it was more of just a paranoid feeling that I could be wrong, I was still ultimately town reading him. (If I'd had a clear scum read on him I would have put him in my scum reads). This post doesn't really answer why you left your vote on Catman though.

As for what we should do now? I trust Ullion's claim, and I think we should lynch Mana or Green and maybe have someone shoot the other.

[Vote] Mana

 

[Lycanthropy]

To confirm his confirmation of Ullion's role, Nakuzami took out is gun and to shoot some scum.
The no-vest streak continues...

​

Mana as ???
honey as ???
TheCapsFan as ???
Ullion as ???
Superjolt as ???
Nakuzami as ???
Mars? as ???
JohnnyMustang II as ???
JohnnyMustang as a Villager [N0]
Davepetasprite^2 as a Villager [D1]
Zehn as a Villager [D1]
alexkaz61 as Mafia [N2]
Desinishon as a Villager [D2]
Klippy as a Villager [D2]
Twiggy as a Villager [D2]
drewbie411 as a Villager [N2]
jdthebud as Mafia [D3]
gimmepie as Mafia [D3]
Bardothren as a Villager [D3]
CatmanDaTrainer as a Villager [D3]
Elektra Heart as a Villager [N4]
GreenLegend56 as Mafia [D4]

Love me some guns :) in!

I am so in.

yes please

Yeah, I guess I could play. <3

Sight was already great, no way I'm missing this one!

I guess I want to shoot people?

/in

I gotta give Alex his rematch so I'm in :P

I mean, I can pull the trigger if you want me to? ;) I'm in!

Vote: Twiggy

We'll see if this will let slide, if not feel free to delete it but I dont want to die considering I'm coming back today.

More death, yay!

 

[Swithdas]

GG guys, was good fun. Catch you all in another game sometime!

 

[Mana1]

I'm not around to defend myself in anyway so do what you must. Please try to vote for me for a reason other than "quiet" though, I'm on LOA because I'm away with family :(.

I suppose my death will help weed out the Mafia, if there's no other choice.

 

[Ullion]

Gunna throw my vote in now:

[kill] TheCapsFan

 

[Nakuzami]

Oh look, I shot another mafia. Rip.

Now we just need to weed out the stragglers. With seven players left, and Ullion and I being confirmed, the last five should all roleclaim at this point, in my opinion.

 

[Superjolt]

Alright, I'm blacksmith

No targets for N0 or N1, I was busy in RL and didn't even log in to the forum for about 4 days so I missed these nights anyway

My targets for the other nights (probably kind of obvious by now):
N2 - Ullion
N3 - Naku

So these two have vests

 

[dad]

bulletproof #2 here, guess my gun is phony :-( not surprised

 

[Lycanthropy]

Nine hours left!
On my phone now, so I can't tell you who's left to vote. Nevertheless, make sure you do if you haven't already. ;)

 

[Mana1]

I'm a vanilla villager with zero guns and a vest from very early on.

Gonna take advantage of Lycan not being on to slide in a vote for [lynch] TheCapsFan before I go out :c.

 

[Mana1]

If Superjolt is telling the truth then Mana's lying, so [KILL]Mana

Or there was another blacksmith, or its fabbed.

Come on now, Johnny. You can even look back and I clearly said I got a vest ASAP.

 

[Superjolt]

2 more left to roleclaim

Where did Mars go?

 

[Lycanthropy]

Hey, sorry. I wasn't able to access my laptop yesterday, but this day has lasted for long enough now. Gonna end it here.