• Just a reminder that providing specifics on, sharing links to, or naming websites where ROMs can be accessed is against the rules. If your post has any of this information it will be removed.
  • Ever thought it'd be cool to have your art, writing, or challenge runs featured on PokéCommunity? Click here for info - we'd love to spotlight your work!
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.
    Register

Map of the Week

Another thing to take note of; you shouldn't be able to use other people's hack bases (i.e. no maps using ShinyGold's tiles ;D). Also, I've now come to enforce this thread's rules (all bow before me >:D) so any off-topic posts in this thread will be deleted. If you've got a problem or something, bring it up with the topic owner, okay? ;D
 
Vrαi said:
Another thing to take note of; you shouldn't be able to use other people's hack bases (i.e. no maps using ShinyGold's tiles ;D). Also, I've now come to enforce this thread's rules (all bow before me >:D) so any off-topic posts in this thread will be deleted. If you've got a problem or something, bring it up with the topic owner, okay? ;D
Click to expand...
I'll go add that in. (And disapprove maps that violate the new rule. >:D)

sasquatchd00d said:
Map Name: Wildwood Pass
Tiles used: kyledove, cope, Wesley_FG, newtiteuf
Credits: kyledove, cope, Wesley_FG, newtiteuf
Comments: Meh, I don't expect to win with this map. I'm just too lazy to open up advance map to make a new one. Maybe next week.
Mapshot:
Spoiler:
Click to expand...
Looks nice. I remember this from the MRT.

Approved
 
I was just wondering, does it have to be upon your vote only? Can't there be a senate of some sort voting of whether it should be in or not? I think the vetoing by PM is *meh*
I wish I had a map, but I don't as of yet, but I'll probably have one next time I post here.
 
Luck said:
I was just wondering, does it have to be upon your vote only? Can't there be a senate of some sort voting of whether it should be in or not? I think the vetoing by PM is *meh*
I wish I had a map, but I don't as of yet, but I'll probably have one next time I post here.
Click to expand...
Look, the "senate" as you called it is made up of me, the thread owner, and the mods.
I think the mods and I can handle it pretty well. Plus, if you don't like my choice on a map, you're free to PM me about why you think it should've been x instead of y.

Well, PMing me is better than spamming the thread, arguing with me publicly over a map, don't you agree?
 
Is there going to be a limit to the number of maps that can be approved per week. (Not for each person, but for everyone.) If we get too many maps, the votes will be spread pretty thin... so I think it would be best to limit it. The 7 that we have now is probably a good number actually.
 
QuilavaKing said:
Is there going to be a limit to the number of maps that can be approved per week. (Not for each person, but for everyone.) If we get too many maps, the votes will be spread pretty thin... so I think it would be best to limit it. The 7 that we have now is probably a good number actually.
Click to expand...
I second this (though there are actually 8 approved maps, counting Ninja Caterpie's recently approved map).
It's up to Seth but I think somewhere in the 5-7 range would be a good limit.
 
Eh...Well if the rule goes through you can just ignore this xD
Oh and I also think that that rule would be great to have!

Map Name: Route 207
Tiles used: Ruby stock + FireRed Stock
Credits: No one
Comments: Nothing really special, I'm using it for my hack though.
Mapshot:
Spoiler:
 
Btw, there is an error with the link to colcolstyles' map. I think it would be better for that link to be a link to their posts.
 
Wind~ said:
Btw, there is an error with the link to colcolstyles' map. I think it would be better for that link to be a link to their posts.
Click to expand...
>x<
I should probably link to the posts as you said. /me fixes.

Ven said:
Eh...Well if the rule goes through you can just ignore this xD
Oh and I also think that that rule would be great to have!

Map Name: Route 207
Tiles used: Ruby stock + FireRed Stock
Credits: No one
Comments: Nothing really special, I'm using it for my hack though.
Mapshot:
Spoiler:
Click to expand...
It's rather simple, but alright. Grass placement isn't very good as you only have to go through 3 grass tiles to get to the other side, making the jumps a bit pointless.
It's alright, but nothing special.

Although this was a bit hard to decide...
Disapproved.

colcolstyles said:
I second this (though there are actually 8 approved maps, counting Ninja Caterpie's recently approved map).
It's up to Seth but I think somewhere in the 5-7 range would be a good limit.
Click to expand...
I think 6 would be best. Enough, but still limited.
 
Not sure if you've imposed the max rule yet if so theres always next week.

Map Name: Cradle of Birth
Tiles used: A Few from Mew Ryn's Rom Base most my own
Credits: Who's tiles where in the Rom base
Comments: One of my first attempts at a map so will be happy to just get accepted
Mapshot:
Spoiler:
 
Dot dot dot dot dot. Fine, I missed the estuary theme... T_T

But why approve or disapprove? If the map sucks, let it get voted out?
 
Bodhii said:
Not sure if you've imposed the max rule yet if so theres always next week.

Map Name: Cradle of Birth
Tiles used: A Few from Mew Ryn's Rom Base most my own
Credits: Who's tiles where in the Rom base
Comments: One of my first attempts at a map so will be happy to just get accepted
Mapshot:
Spoiler:
Click to expand...
It looks...alright. But the tree placement isn't very good, and it's too spaced out.
Disapproved

Ninja Caterpie said:
Dot dot dot dot dot. Fine, I missed the estuary theme... T_T

But why approve or disapprove? If the map sucks, let it get voted out?
Click to expand...
It's best to list the ones that are actually going to get more than one vote.

Also, to note: the Entry period has drawn to a close. No maps will be approved until next Wednesday night. You may now start voting for your favorites. You have until Wednesday night at 12:00 AM GMT -6 to do so.
 
Last edited:
I think that all credits should be stated, not just something like "Ray's rom base"
Which he half stole -_-
 
Woops. Sorry. I forgot it was time to vote^^
Anyways, I'm gonna go ahead and vote for Thrace's map. I really wanted to vote for sasquatchd00d but I just don't like the way he tried to make everything look natural. The concept behind Thrace's map is superb and it looks like it came straight out of an official game. His ability to emulate Nintendo's style of mapping down to the smallest detail and the nostalgic charm that those types of maps always bring are what secured my vote. Kudos to you, Thrace!
 
narutoactor said:
I looked at all of them any it was close between nija caterapie and sasquatchd00d and I vote for sasquatchd00d's map because nijas caterpies was a lil empty There both amazing maps
Click to expand...
1. I could barely understand that.

A "reason" for voting for a particular map means "I like this map because of (feature, pretty, etc)", not that it's "better" than another.
I'm not counting that vote.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top