Map Rating/Review Thread

[Red Rain]

Polarwind Island. Rates would be appreciated.

 

[BigSteve]

this is a map i made for the interior of the 2nd cave on Seafoam Island in Pokemon Gold,
Articuno will be on the raised area when it is implemented

rates?

 

[X-Buster]

heres my map..
Neiyu Region:

 

[BigSteve]

new interior map for seafoam island with articuno :)
partially because of issues with warps, but it looks better in my opinion

rates?

 

[X-Buster]

your map looks nice, 6.5/10 maybe you should put something in the water..!^^

 

[BigSteve]

your map looks nice, 6.5/10 maybe you should put something in the water..!^^

i was thinking that :) but what can i put in there?

 

[X-Buster]

maybe some rocks same as the one in a sea route..!^^

 

[Tropical Sunlight]

heres my map..
Neiyu Region:

Wow, it's better than mine, I mixed the colors... Whoops!
I like the way you put it in and I like the lake, but what's that green square thingy? A Village?
Oh, I almost forgot: 9.99/10.00 because of the green square thingy

 

[Neti]

grren villages are always the starter towns... well but you took a not so nice palette for it Xbuster
Anyway here is mine:

As you can easily see, it is way too big xD
I will seperate it into 3 different regions, i think its is eas to figure out where each region starts or ends^^

 

[Tropical Sunlight]

OK
Map Name: Crystole City
Map:

Connections: Light Hills (up), Stone path (down) and Eidolon Forest (the entrance)
Shop: Chris's Crystal Shop
Credits: CheesePeow for unfinished rombase (!) but I will edit it

 

[Neti]

here are 3 new maps of me, credit for the tiles goes to fanking omega, dshayabusa gaves his palettes to me.

Starter Town:

Route 1:

Town 2:

and i just wanted to make you not forget my last post with the region map i recently made:

Spoiler:

grren villages are always the starter towns... well but you took a not so nice palette for it Xbuster
Anyway here is mine:

As you can easily see, it is way too big xD
I will seperate it into 3 different regions, i think its is eas to figure out where each region starts or ends^^

 

[FenderX]

Well, here is a map of Pokemon Sacred Legends, its called Equatos Village.
Please rate so i can decide whether not i should keep it.

 

[destinedjagold]

@ yunghove...
Englewood Town...
COMMENT: It's really looking like a Pallet Town remake... :\
RATINGS: 7/10
REASON: I like the peacefulness of the town, the palletes are a bit bright, but it's nice. :3
SUGGESTION: You could add one more doorless house there though... :\

Heres Dimitri City...
COMMENT: There's some parts of the map which are unoccupied, which means, empty space...
RATINGS: 6/10
REASON: The map is pretty nice, yet, the empty spaces, also, the mountain-edge-tile -->

isn't the same as the ones on the top-left mountain in the map...
SUGGESTION: Fix those empty spaces and the mountain edge tiles...


@ X-Buster...
COMMENT: The remade one is pretty nice. :) However, with that map, it needs to have map connections to all 4 directions... :\
RATINGS: 8/10
REASON: I really love the map. Though I think it needs two or three more trees to satisfy my taste, but it's lovely.
SUGGESTION: That map needs some rocks around the water parts though... :\


@ IceCharizard...
Redone Wish Town...
COMMENT: A twon with two houses only..? Well, okay... :\
RATINGS: 7/10
REASON: I like the peacefulness around that map, and the nature is pretty sweet. :3
SUGGESTION: It looks more like a route than a town, though... :\ Why not add a doorless house to make it three buildings there? Also, you could fix this little error...

Crystole City...
COMMENT: It's a nice little map for a busy atmosphere...
RATINGS: 6/10
REASON: The map's nice, yet, it's a bit overcrowded... :\ A bit squarish, too...
SUGGESTION: Erm.., you could resize the map to make room for air to pass through...


@ Red Rain...
Polarwind Island...
COMMENT: Brrr... What a chilly place to be...
RATINGS: 7/10
REASON: I like the freezing balance of the map... But it looks a bit squarish to me though... :\
SUGGESTION: -none-


@ bigsteve...
interior of the 2nd cave on Seafoam Island...
new interior map for seafoam island with articuno...
COMMENT: A gold map. Yay! My first time rating gold maps. :3
RATING: both 7/10
REASON: It's a bit squarish to me though... But it's a nice, yet, simple-to-go-through map...
SUGGESTION: You could add some mazes to confuse us, though. :)


@ Neti...
Starter Town...
COMMENT: An icy atmosphere... Lovely. :3
RATING: 8/10
REASON: It's really a nice map to start our icy adventure. It's lovely. :3
SUGGESTION: -none-

Route 1...
COMMENT: Still pretty nice. :3
RATING: 7/10
REASON: It's a nice map. I can tell that you really worked hard on this piece of art. :)
SUGGESTION: I do think the sign post should be located in the middle part of the map, though... :\

Town 2...
COMMENT: A complex map. Sweet. :3
RATING: 7/10
REASON: It's complexity is lovely. A frosty town. It's pretty nice. :3
SUGGESTION: Though it's a nice map... That stone on the left corner of the map is kinda disturbing the way,

is it not? :\ Also, this house is kinda, stuck,

right?

@ Arm♠ndo...
COMMENT: Did the town's people planned out the mountain and the trees' pattern? :\
RATING: 6/10
REASON: I should say that it's a lovely map, however, the natural things; trees and mountain, aren't too, naturalistic, though... :\ They follow a pattern...
SUGGESTION: Make it more naturalistic...

 

[Tropical Sunlight]

SUGGESTION: Erm.., you could resize the map to make room for air to pass through...

Sorry, I don't know where to get A-Map 1.82, and LU-HO said not to resize maps in 1.90...

 

[Neti]

why not resize them in 1.9? i always do so and get no problems

 

[Binary]

Well, here is a map of Pokemon Sacred Legends, its called Equatos Village.
Please rate so i can decide whether not i should keep it.

Rating: 7/10
Reason: I like it, although there are some errors easily spot able. I like the paths and the tree placement, but I don't like the mountain thing in the middle of the map. The PC is all messed up and you've got a problem with the border there.
Suggestions: Just fix up the errors...:\

 

[Tropical Sunlight]

Originally Posted by Arm♠ndo
Well, here is a map of Pokemon Sacred Legends, its called Equatos Village.
Please rate so i can decide whether not i should keep it.

I don't like the map because it is made from two almost completely the same halves. Like you'd make half of the map and then put it next to a mirror and then do some Marts instead of PCs,
IT DOES NOT LOOK NATURAL.
3/10

 

[Red Rain]

Thanks for your crit destinedjagold. I now have another map to display, Route 302. I am wondering anyones opinions on it. Thanks a lot.

 

[Veng3anc3]

First half decent map I think, might be the start town for my hack. A few tile errors, Tree's when they cross over onto the mountain area.. (the sides of the tree's) I'll have to make a new tile for that. But eh, I like it. A bit of empty space, might fill it with something.. People, lol.

 

[One Winged Angel]

Yea, i figured out that alot of people don't like that grass. They say its too bright.
5/10
I think its empty
Square
and the rom base.
Make it less square.