Map Rating/Review Thread

[MudMast]

Map Name: Jubilife City

Map Game: Pokémon Ruby

Comments: Here is Jubilife City, from Pokémon Diamond and Pearl. I spent a week on this and imported the large building from fire red, i had to recolour it and added other things. This map will appear in my hack Pokemon Alpha.

 

[Tyrantrum]

Map Name: Jubilife City

Map Game: Pokémon Ruby

Comments: Here is Jubilife City, from Pokémon Diamond and Pearl. I spent a week on this and imported the large building from fire red, i had to recolour it and added other things. This map will appear in my hack Pokemon Alpha.

Rating:8.5/10
Re-adjustments:You used a little too much of those eggs and where your ending the mountains, there is a grassy patch for that, I see no tile errors.
Comments:Other than what I said, this looks really good and I can't wait to play.

 

[MudMast]

Rating:8.5/10
Re-adjustments:You used a little too much of those eggs and where your ending the mountains, there is a grassy patch for that, I see no tile errors.
Comments:Other than what I said, this looks really good and I can't wait to play.

i know, them stones are there till i get round to putting a bush there
and what do u mean by 'ending the mountains?

 

[Tyrantrum]

To the top, left, and right.
Where the mountain edges are.

EDIT:
Map Name:Sweet Town

Hack Of:Ruby

Hack Name:Pokemon Soar!

Comments:This is the first town and I'm using Vincent ROMbase from PHCompany.

 

[Vulpid]

6/10 - Fair
Seems to small for a town don't cha think?
Not to mention theres nothing there but a few flowers and three houses. Its quite empty. Try adding something.

 

[Tyrantrum]

O.K., thanx for the rating.
The thing is that it was that size when I downloaded the ROMbase.
Plus it's bigger than the normal LITTLEROOT TOWN.
I will add more later.
Thanx again.

 

[MudMast]

UPDATE:

i fixed the things:

Map Name: Jubilife City

Game Name: Pokémon Alpha

Base Rom: Pokémon Ruby

Comments:
the large building is the Jubilife TV Station (JTV) - i recoloured sliph co. from fire red, edited a little bit (the roof) slightly.
the gym, well that is the new design for the Pokémon Trainer School.

its a bit big :D

it looks a bit glitchy, that was photobucket

EDIT: oops wrong one, i forgot some tiles, ill put newer one in
EDIT 2: heres newer one

 

[Tyrantrum]

Um...this looks exactly the same.
What are the things u fixed.

 

[MudMast]

i put bushes in, fixed the edge of the 'mountain'.

 

[destinedjagold]

EDIT:
Map Name:Sweet Town

Hack Of:Ruby

Hack Name:Pokemon Soar!

Comments:This is the first town and I'm using Vincent ROMbase from PHCompany.

RATINGS: 8/10
REASON: Lovely map and the graphics is very pleasing to my eyes. ;)
SUGGESTION: N/A

UPDATE:

i fixed the things:

Map Name: Jubilife City

Game Name: Pokémon Alpha

Base Rom: Pokémon Ruby

Comments:
the large building is the Jubilife TV Station (JTV) - i recoloured sliph co. from fire red, edited a little bit (the roof) slightly.
the gym, well that is the new design for the Pokémon Trainer School.
its a bit big :D

it looks a bit glitchy, that was photobucket

EDIT: oops wrong one, i forgot some tiles, ill put newer one in
EDIT 2: heres newer one

RATINGS: 4/10 never mind... 6/10
REASON: The tile errors and the excessive usage of stones irritated my eyes... Never mind... You just fixed them... Anyways, the map is lovely and big. Good job!
SUGGETION: Fix them up... Refrain from using same tiles in one area excessively...

 

[MudMast]

RATINGS: 4/10
REASON: The tile errors and the excessive usage of stones irritated my eyes...
SUGGETION: Fix them up...

what tile errors?
what stones?

are you looking at the one i just posted or the old one?

 

[Tyrantrum]

DJG:Thanx for rating it.
I'll put up the first route soon.

MudMast:The newer one looks much better.
Rating:...How about.....9.5/10
better?
Can't wait to play!

 

[CrazyLuigi]

Map Name: Kakariko City

Map Game: Fire Red

Comments: This is a rendition of Kakariko City from Ocarina of Time. I tried to model it best I could on the original Kakariko, while still keeping a "Pokemon" feel to it, if thing exists. I also had to make sacrifices to practicality, so this is obviously not a 100% accurate map. I'm still not totally satisfied with this map, if I had the ability I would have created a custom tileset to adequately recreate the city. I also have two problems that I was hoping criticism from this board could help clear up. You might notice two irregularly placed sign posts, these were placed simply because I could not find a way to connect the two mountain sides that didn't seem out of place. Currently, I think it might just be a problem with the tileset, but I could be wrong it has happened before. :P

Mapshot:

Map Name: Kokiri Village

Map Game: Fire Red

Comments: Most of my sentiments for this map were already stated above. I tried to re-create a Kokiri Village, but obviously had to make some simplifications and took some "artistic liberties."

Mapshot:

 

[magma_boi]

Map 1: 9/10
Reason: It's extreemly well done with few tile errors, and it is very comparable to Kakariko City. Occarina of time has to be the best game i have ever played.

Map 2: 8.5/10
Reason: I dont like it as much, but still it has no tile errors that i can see, and is comparble to Kokiri Village.

Great work.

Are these going to be in an actuall hack, or are they just maps you decided to create?


I added some more onto the map i posted a page back, just some stuff too fill up some space.
In the little place looking out to the sea theres gonna be a person standing there so it's not completley pointless.
Crits welcome.

 

[MudMast]

I added some more onto the map i posted a page back, just some stuff too fill up some space.
In the little place looking out to the sea theres gonna be a person standing there so it's not completley pointless.
Crits welcome.

i'm gonna give it a 6.5

noerrors that appear instantly but the two-floored building, the windows look strange and on the water, the top-right of the bottom-left water doesnt end.

 

[Tony the Awesome]

Umm...I made 2 new maps:

Route 1:

Spoiler:

Path of Kyota(Route 2):

Spoiler:

 

[CrazyLuigi]

Are these going to be in an actuall hack, or are they just maps you decided to create?

They are for a hack I work on when ever I have enough spare time. I doubt it will really get anywhere until the summer, assuming I don't start working full time then. =P

 

[adamb241]

Umm...I made 2 new maps:

Route 1:

Spoiler:

Path of Kyota(Route 2):

Spoiler:

1. 7.5/10- I think it has the basic ideas there but the ledges throw the map off, there are way to many unnatural ones. It is still very good though

2. 6/10- Very nice but the mountains are way to flat, make them look real. The grass looks like Game-Freak mapped it, make it look like something would want to live there.

 

[Binary]

Umm...I made 2 new maps:

Route 1:

Spoiler:

Path of Kyota(Route 2):

Spoiler:

First map:
Rate: 8/10
Reason: I like the use of the edges there, they look quite good. The pathways look good, nice work!
Suggestions: Theres too much use of grass in your map, you should not use too much grass. Try to add some more things in it like rivers, ponds etc. rather than those grass.

Second map
Rate:8.5/10
Reason: Nice map, I like the mountains and the ledges, but as the previous map you've used too much grass.
Suggestions: Look above xD

 

[Hyunbin]

map name: WINDING FOREST

hack of: POKéMON FIRERED

hack name: POKéMON DREAMSTAR

map:

Spoiler:

for a map explanation/overview click here:
Winding Forest EXPLAINED