• Ever thought it'd be cool to have your art, writing, or challenge runs featured on PokéCommunity? Click here for info - we'd love to spotlight your work!
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.

May vs. Dawn--Who's Better

Who's Better ?


  • Total voters
    126
Status
Not open for further replies.
Dude, most girls start getting their "assets" when they're about ~9 or 10 anyway, so I don't see what the big deal is about May's. As the show went on, they kind of decreased (wtf XD) anyway, so yeah - I never understood why people were so obsessed over them when they really weren't that big at all.

Same with Dawn's miniskirt. I do think it is a little bit too short (like the um...shot we got in DP039, that was a little too much if you ask me), but girls wear skirts, so why can't she? It shouldn't be a big deal, seriously - it's just a skirt. o_o But if that's the "main" reason why people like her, then I gotta wonder if anybody likes her for her personality at all. -_-

Yeah Dawn dresses up while May doesn't. Yeah, I agree with what Pocky said, you're just jealous, beacuse everyone says Dawn is much prettier than May. Well, THEY'RE TRUE !

So what if May doesn't dress up for Contests? I think that's a good thing - especially for (mostly younger) girls watching the show. May's confident enough to go out there and win with just her normal attire, while Dawn is showing that you must dress up and do your hair before you even get on stage. :/ Besides, Sinnoh Contests =/= Hoenn and Kanto Contests, so of course May isn't going to dress up (who knows about Johto Contests). As for Dawn being "prettier" than May, I don't see why that matters (it's your opinion, anyway) - because when it comes down to it, it's the personality of the character, not the looks, though that may be a bonus, especially if you're a guy. If that's the only reason you think Dawn is the better character, then...wow. :/ I don't even like Dawn, but she at least deserves to be liked for something other than her appearance. >>

As for their pokemon teams, May wins again for me. She had a variety of different pokemon, while Dawn doesn't (although I'll admit, the personalities of Dawn's pokemon are way better than May's). Like Haruka Chan already said, she has two water pokemon and four pokemon already in less than 44 episodes. May didn't have her whole Hoenn team, which was 6? pokemon, until the Hoenn GF.

And the thing about Dawn obsessing over her hair - it's not just her hair, it's her appearance in general. She always wants to look good, even for Contests, where it's not even mandatory, but optional to dress up. Examples are in DP009 (when she won't come out of the tent because she doesn't want anybody looking at her), DP019 (with Pachirisu, she kept brushing her hair after it messed it up), and DP029 (when the Sinnoh Now News Crew came, she told them to stop and she redid her hair, when it looked perfectly fine). DP011 and DP026 also show how she gets ready for Contests, and she was freaking out in DP011 when she couldn't get her ponytail right. DP026, she was showing off to Kengo before the Contest even started, because again, she knew that she looked "good." Though this all part of her character, sometimes I think she's a little over the top, especially for a 10-year-old. o_o;
 
i say dawn!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

i mean; may looks ugly;

and thsat dumb max..
 
I don't know why people care so much about how cartoon characters look o.O I think both May and Dawn look pretty

From what I've seen so far Dawn doesn't really seem over the top in girlyness, except from in the first ep where she tried bringing a whole suitcase full of clothes. In the one where she gets her hair messy and uses Piplup's Bubble to make it straght again and when she's worried about her ponytail in the contest...stuff like that seems normal to me. Or maybe she's just kind of acting more like a teenager over her looks. My friends are like that too...or maybe I've forgotten if Dawn really obsesses over that stuff too much. But I don't ever remember thinking that. If you're going onto a big stage you're going to care about how you look and if you're hair's just been frazzled you will too. I'm not saying she's not girly, but the way everyone was going on about her I was expecting her to pull out a mirror every episode.

You know, I was asking the same question. 0_o

Actually, that's the reason I don't like Dawn. Any girl who travels through a country on foot while wearing a miniskirt next to a pervert (Brock)

XD So true though, so true.
 
Well Jorah, that's what girly defines as. When girls always have to care about how they look, always have to obsess over their hair, wanting lots of clothes, ect. Dawn does that A LOT. Neither Misty or May were ever that bad. They cared about their looks, and liked shopping, yes. But most girls do.

Dawn is the most girly out of the girls, anybody can see that easily. Both her personality and attire is extremely girly. And it's like sometimes when she's on the show doing something like obsessing over her hair, or looking in the mirror..I want to smack her. Cause she's like too obsessed. (I can be like that too, but it's like COME ON. She's only 10.)It like makes you wonder how she's going to be when she's like my age (17) o_o
 
Well, I never really watched the Hoen saga. So I shouldn't really be talking. I've only seen like 2 episodes of DP. It seems like you guys know more about the characters than I do. From what I'm reading, May is the one I should like. I guess Dawn is more feminine than May. I do like May's outfit better than Dawns. A real 10 year old should not wear that. Atleast till she's 16. I guess I will have to change my answer to, May.

May's pokemon ARE better than Dawn's from what I can see. Dawn's are too cute >_<
 
Both May's and Dawn's Pokemon are cute though. Except when Torchic evolved. Skitty, Beautifly, Munchlax, Bulbasaur, the baby Squirtle(HATE) and Eevee are all cute.

Well Jorah, that's what girly defines as. When girls always have to care about how they look, always have to obsess over their hair, wanting lots of clothes, ect. Dawn does that A LOT. Neither Misty or May were ever that bad. They cared about their looks, and liked shopping, yes. But most girls do.

Dawn is the most girly out of the girls, anybody can see that easily. Both her personality and attire is extremely girly. And it's like sometimes when she's on the show doing something like obsessing over her hair, or looking in the mirror..I want to smack her. Cause she's like too obsessed. (I can be like that too, but it's like COME ON. She's only 10.)It like makes you wonder how she's going to be when she's like my age (17) o_o

Yeah, she is definatly the girliest out of all of them. But she doesn't seem over the top to me...My sister is 11. She doesn't act as girly as Dawn but I think that's round about the age where you start caring a bit about how you look. But those 3 instances are the only times I can remember Dawn saying anything about how she looks/clothes and stuff...do I need to watch D/P again?
 
Well Jorah, that's what girly defines as. When girls always have to care about how they look, always have to obsess over their hair, wanting lots of clothes, ect. Dawn does that A LOT. Neither Misty or May were ever that bad. They cared about their looks, and liked shopping, yes. But most girls do.

Dawn is the most girly out of the girls, anybody can see that easily. Both her personality and attire is extremely girly. And it's like sometimes when she's on the show doing something like obsessing over her hair, or looking in the mirror..I want to smack her. Cause she's like too obsessed. (I can be like that too, but it's like COME ON. She's only 10.)It like makes you wonder how she's going to be when she's like my age (17) o_o

Once again, Haruka, you're just JEALOUS taht more people like Dawn ! LOOK AT THE POLL !

(Sorry lost my cool again)
 
Once again, Haruka, you're just JEALOUS taht more people like Dawn ! LOOK AT THE POLL !

Alright, whatever you say. Yes. I'm jealous because my favorite character is less liked. o_o; BTW. Dawn is only winning by 2.

I can say that both Dawn and May have fans that just like them for their body/outfit. Of course you're going to get that with those two. And by the comments in this thread, it seems like a lot of people (including you) like Dawn for her mini-skirt. D:

Shallow ? That's not shallow ! It's mostly the only thing that makes Dawn attractive to guys, IMO

LMAO. You pretty much just insulted Dawn, by saying the only good thing about her is her mini-skirt.
 
I'd just like to reiterate that I like Dawn because of her personality, and not the shortness of her skirt. x_x Though I don't mind her outfit either. Just, personally, during the Hoenn region, May would either irk me with how she acted, or just not do anything for me. And Dawn brought some life back into the show. At least, for me anyway.

If we have to compare appearances, I actually like both in different ways. One has a natural cuteness and sweet disposition, while the other shows a more dynamic and overall energetic look. If May didn't irk me in the certain episodes and movies she does, it would probably be a lot closer. But yea, this is a personal thing, as I know Dawn irks a number of you all instead. ^^;
 
"irk
–verb (used with object)
to irritate, annoy, or exasperate: It irked him to wait in line."

Straight from dictionary.com~ ^^; I didn't want to use "annoy" as much as "irk", for some reason. Maybe I see "annoy" as more negative...
 
Dawnfanboy, admit it. Your favorite character needs to lose the miniskirt, or at least put something more substantial then her panties underneath the thing. I'm starting to wonder if this argument is between "Who do more perverts like? The girl in the miniskirt or the girl who is very obviously blooming as we speak?"

Dangit, I'll admit that as a character Dawn is interesting. Funny thing? I liked May better. I dunno why, other then Dawn's less-then-modest choice of attire, but I do. And any character who needs a miniskirt to draw a fanbase is just not worth mentioning. That's all there is to it.
 
Shallow ? That's not shallow ! It's mostly the only thing that makes Dawn attractive to guys, IMO

IMO liking someone else better because of how they look is shallow.

Well this thread is getting kind of...interesting...but it could get locked if all people are arguing about is Dawn's skirt and May's body o.O
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top