5th Gen Pokemon Competition

[mscat]

I kinda miss those. I guess they got replaced with the pokemon musical. Anyone else miss them?

 

[MegaKuriboh]

You mean the Pokeathon?
Heck yeah I miss that :( the Pokemon Musicial is stupid imo

 

[Pikachu-dance!]

I love the musicals !!:) they are one of my faviorate parts of the game !!:) if i wanna play super contests or pokeathlon i go back to my other games :)

 

[lamby101]

You mean the Pokeathon?
Heck yeah I miss that :( the Pokemon Musicial is stupid imo

I agree, there's no motivation to do it as you get no reward for taking part.

 

[Neiko Star]

I like getting new Props though.

 

[PlatinumDude]

I tried the Musical and it was pretty boring compared to the Contests and Pokeathlons. If one of them makes a comeback in the third version, I'll be happy.

 

[solarowl]

If you're talking about Pokeathlon, I'm with you. Musicals were much more boring this time. Contests were even better than this as well. Pokeathlon was the most entertaining. There were many events, and all of them were fun to play.

 

[Rionix]

I like the concept of Pokemon Musical. And I like to see my pokemon jiggling and bouncing. I'm not a gay though O.O

 

[vaporeon7]

I miss the Pokeathlon and Pokemon Contests (R/S/E not D/P/Pt). Those minigames were more fun and included more interactivity then the Musicals. I don't mind the concept of the Musicals I just don't like how it is more of a trimmed Super Contest. I wish there was more to it then just dressing up and pressing two buttons in the Musical. I think it'd be better if you could use all your props.

 

[Hyrulian_Hero]

they better bring it back in the 3rd revision of Black and White (Grey version I'm betting its gonna be called)

or at least the remakes of Ruby and Sapphire

 

[jessemac_7]

I hate how in the musicals like you really don't get to do anything but dress up your pokemon, its kinda boring. I'm wondering if they just added it in in hopes to appeal to female game players but IDK (not trying to be sexist, just speculating). Personally I enjoyed the contest in ruby, sapphire and emerald the most cuz I love the strategy.

 

[Alerek]

What I think they need to have is a game where they include pokemon contests(R/S/E), Pokeathlons, Musical. I mean why cant they just add all of them? It would add so much more time to the play time.

 

[AusGut]

Couldnt stand contests, found them so boring and dont even wanna try the musicals.

The Pokeatholon was fun though

 

[skyluigi2]

Compared to Contests and the Pokeathlon, Musicals are pretty rubbish. Really. There's no point...

-Totodile42

 

[Zhinc]

I hate how in the musicals like you really don't get to do anything but dress up your pokemon, its kinda boring. I'm wondering if they just added it in in hopes to appeal to female game players but IDK (not trying to be sexist, just speculating). Personally I enjoyed the contest in ruby, sapphire and emerald the most cuz I love the strategy.

That's not you being sexist: that's the game creators, if that's really the reason. ):

Yeah...I miss the old contest from R/S/E. I was really good at those! I had a Xatu for the smart contests and a Ninetales for Beauty...and a Regirock for either tough or cute, I can't remember...I was trying to get that one statue for the secret base you would get if you beat master level for all five areas.

Eh, Pokeathlon was okay. I just don't like games that require me to actually do things at that fast of a pace; they make me really nervous and sick. That's why I only play Pokemon games, I think...

 

[Giraffe]

The Pokeathlon was amazing... But the Musicals are cute; I love getting new props from 'fans'.

 

[Pikachu-dance!]

The Pokeathlon was amazing... But the Musicals are cute; I love getting new props from 'fans'.

i love my adoring fans :) but they dont give me anything any more because ive got all the accessories apart from the birthday cake and its my birthday in 6 days :D hello silver trainer card! :)

 

[PartiallyInsaneWhimsicott]

I thought, when I first heard about the games, and all the graphics being better than, say, Gen IV, I thought, "the Contests must be AWESOME!" Then when I found out they replaced them with--I can't even say it(which don't even give you ribbons or medals or anything)--it was like a slap in the face!

I miss my Contests...and my Pokeathlons!

 

[nate890]

While I do prefer the Pokeathlon and contest over the musical, the musical does have some interesting elements but they just need to be capitalized on. I wish the muscial had a bit more strategy to it!

 

[Nateon]

I loved the contests, i found them a fun challenge, i enjoyed the poketholon (cant spell) when it was introduced but i didn't even attempt the gen 5 ones, they just look awful =/