• Ever thought it'd be cool to have your art, writing, or challenge runs featured on PokéCommunity? Click here for info - we'd love to spotlight your work!
  • Our weekly protagonist poll is now up! Vote for your favorite Trading Card Game 2 protagonist in the poll by clicking here.
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.

1st Gen Should I get Yellow from the eShop?

  • 27
    Posts
    8
    Years
    • Seen Jul 21, 2017
    I've never played the original, so I was wondering if I should buy it. I'm playing through Omega Ruby (and have yet to start on X.)

    Sometimes I want to get it, other times I decide against getting it, so I'm indecisive.

    Please help me decide. :)
     
    Last edited:
    On one hand, it is interesting to play through the games that started the entire series. You get a sense of how far the games have come since their early days, with all the features that have been added or changed.

    On the other hand, I won't lie to you. Red/Blue/Yellow are very rough games to get through if you are spoiled by the updated features of the later games. R/B/Y have glitches, weird bugs, and odd things that can frustrate a player. You'll find moves missing that should hit. You'll find that you can't carry as many items as you want, and your bag is going to become really disorganized. Even the box system is primitive, where you can't easily move your Pokemon around. And you always have to remember how many Pokemon are in a box before you go out and catch a new Pokemon; you can't catch a Pokemon if the box you're currently on is full.

    The game is still a lot of fun, though! But I'm saying that as someone who started with R/B/Y and is used to the old games. Since you never played the original, you should really decide if you want to see where the series got its start, and if that is a good enough reason to go primitive again.
     
    I got Yellow so I could have Pikachu follow me around and have Jessie and James battle me. If you haven't ever played FR/LG and have a device that can play GBA games, I'd suggest getting either of those instead.

    There's a glitch you can do in the VC Gen I games where you can catch Mew! It was in the originals, but nobody found out until around 2002-2003 I believe.

    It is very annoying to have to save whenever you switch PC Boxes. This was fixed in Ruby & Sapphire, and is hence no longer an issue in FR/LG. In FR/LG you can also play as a girl if you want to, whereas you can only play as Red (the male player) in RBY.

    You can only trade over local wifi in the VC re-releases, not via friend codes.
     
    Yeah I think it depends. Astinus and miragespot already mention the disadvantages of playing the old games. One other thing is you'll probably take longer to grind due to the EX Share feature being odd, although I didn't mind that much as I would either watch TV or Youtube when grinding in my 3DS version, lol. If you haven't experience Kanto and want to without headaches, perhaps FR/LG is better. If you don't mind, though, it's worth a shot.
     
    Old games are epic but that's why they are tough. You should see how did this legend started from bottom. Go for it!
    ...
    ...
    Btw.. that following pikachu is soooooooo cuuuuuteeeee :333
     
    (kinda late)
    If you didn't purchase it already, you should definitely! I personally really liked Yellow (even tho you have Pikachu on your team the whole time lol), but the gameplay is going to be a bit out of your comfort zone if you're used to the newer games I guess. But it's great to know the roots of the franchise you love :)
    Have fun playing it when you do !! ^^
     
    Back
    Top