2nd Gen Silver VS Gold...which is Better?

[Kitori_theTeamAquaSuicune]

Lets see...
I'm definitely going for silver because:
A) It's what got me into the Pokemon Fever
B) It was the first Pokemon Game I've ever received
C) Lugia and Vulpix plz

 

[joey7891]

silver cause thats the one i beat =D

 

[Zarluxan]

Silver. I loved the graphics better than golds and Aeroblast which you can only get from a silver Lugia is better than sacred fire from a gold Ho-oh.

 

[Mewtwo42]

Hmm....at first, people all started to say Gold was better. Now more people are saying Silver is better....wierd. Good....but wierd.

 

[Shortybt15]

i really couldnt care less... but i bought gold... so gold is better :)

 

[Mewtwo42]

Yeah, this topic is getting a little old.
I think most people would agree that Silver is better.
Well, according to the polls.

 

[Houndoom666]

Gold. I think Gold was cooler cuz I got gold first, and It was like the only think I did for like 6 months. And when I got Silver, I wasnt as impressed.

 

[Mewtwo42]

Gold is the more dominant of the two/three. I don't know why. Why weren't you impressed with Silver. There's nothing to not like about it.

 

[Arcknight316]

Silver's sprites are way cooler, but Ho-oh is cooler than Lugia, so my heart will always scream "GOLD!"

i always thought lugia was stronger than ho-oh.

its not.

it's actually not so great at attacking. i think gold's sprites are better. after all, crystal's sprites are mostly taken from gold

 

[bitter_doom]

pokemon silver all the way

i think silver is better because...well ts just that when i got my first pokemon game it was silver.. i was amazed cus i got it from a pawn broker and i had like 700 chicoratias ^_^ but then i didn't know what the hell that was...and then one day i brought it to school and a chinnese kid (no lie) gave me a celebi witch i was wraped cus i knew what that was... AND not to mention tyranitar haha but yeah so thats my vote :)

 

[spenceroone3]

I don't really have a favourite. I just always pick gold because more people seem to have it. :D

 

[sainsaw]

I liked gold more, because I always go for those colors (red, gold, ruby, pearl)

 

[-Jinx-]

Silver.
Even though when I acutally played the G/S/C generation games I only had Gold.​

 

[Oni Link]

Silver, because although Ho-Oh is ok, I love Lugia.
at the time I also preferred it because I wanted to be different, thinking that everyone would naturally prefer the more valued metal, Gold. :)

 

[EmpoleMew]

Silver Version because I like Lugia better. Ho-oh is good, but Fire/Flying does not look good when you're looking at Hydro Pump and the 4x Ancientpower. Plus, Aeroblast is pure pwnage over Sacred Fire.

 

[Improfane]

I'm apologising since I made a fatal error in my previous posts!

Mewtwo42, I'm sorry for misleading you. It turns out that EVs do not exist in RBY and vitamins actually increase a stat by one each time they are used.
source

In Generation I and Generation II games, vitamins increased a stat by a single point, with a maximum of ten of each vitamin which could be given to a Pokémon.

Sorry!

This is the topic and my post I realised my mistake.

 

[Shadowthinker]

Even though crystal is best i like Gold you can get Ho-oh.

 

[Chibi - Dalgia_X]

Silver all the Way for me

Sprites are way better than Gold and Lugia knows Aero Blast in Silver too

so GO SILVER

(Crystal kicks both their asses ^^)

 

[VEC]

Silver, I like Lugia better and Silver I got before Gold

 

[Shadow Byte]

I'd have to go with silver, partly because of Lugia, and partly because It was the first one I ever played/owned... Aeroblast rules