4th Gen So, HeartGold, SoulSilver… whatcha getting?

[Dawn's Hat]

I'll check the exclusives before choosing (although I'll probably pick SS as I chose Gold the first time)

 

[poke-ranger]

I'm thinking of changing my mind to SoulSliver now... But i've always had the "first version" if that makes sense..

 

[xxChazxx]

I'm thinking of changing my mind to SoulSliver now... But i've always had the "first version" if that makes sense..

as have I.

Makes perfect sense.

I'm staying with HeartGold, however.

 

[Dasseo]

I had both Silver and Gold on GBC, so I might get both HeartGold and SoulSilver.
(:

 

[LordDarkrai]

I'm getting SoulSilver because when gold and silver came out in 2000 I have the Silver version and Luiga was one of my favorite pokemon in the game besides the starters.

 

[RockmanEXE]

Looks like Soul Silver is the popular one.

 

[Xashlei]

I want Heart Gold because it's the less popular, it seems. *shot* In all honesty though, it kind of became a trend for me or something. I got LeafGreen, Sapphire, and Pearl. Only now do I get the... "first" version. And I don't really care about using legendaries (both Lugia and Ho-Oh are cool). I just want their Dex data.

 

[TheNerdyPotato]

Im going to go with Silver, honestly i think it is more popular bcuz o flugia

 

[Katana3]

man silver was my first ever game and i wud love a remake not just playing shiny gold by zel,, awsome if they do make it

 

[Sakura Rain]

I'm getting SoulSilver for sure, since Silver was my favorite. Actually, Crystal was my favorite, but no remake for Crystal. :( I might end up getting both of them. Depends on how much money I have.

 

[FireTears]

I have not a single game a prefer to get, both are almost the same. Ho-oh and Lugia are obtainable in both games anyway.

But I am getting HeatGold because I would like to catch Kyogre ^^

 

[Cornelius]

I am getting HeartGold, since I was always more of a Ho-oh fan than I was to Lugia, although I like both birds.

 

[Samme!]

Im most definitely getting HeartGold :) it seems so awesome!!!! But if people are so obssesed with Lugia then why not get HeartGold and get the higher level one??

I just like Ho-oh and the box is cooler and i wanna get Kyogre and I wanna prove to my friend that HeartGold isn't just for girls and Its Purely Fantastic

 

[Nash Bandicoot]

i think heart gold is the one for me HO-OH is superior

 

[Karisthegucci]

I think I would have a heart attack from happiness if I got either but I think im going to get silver, based on the cover art. Lugia looks BA :D

My first pokemon game ever was crystal, so Im still hoping for a re-make of that :)

 

[GameplayerHGSS]

HeartGold all the way!!! And if there RREEAALLYYY Good then Soul Silver as well! (For a different starter and team,etc.) Besides I have All the games from Each Generation and love havin' them so i have to add both of these to my collection! FTW!!

 

[IcyArceusRider]

I'll have to get both.

But the main game I'll be playing will be SoulSilver, since I <3 LUGIA a lot better than Ho-Oh. And as a little kid, I played Silver more than Gold...

 

[Serazahr]

HeartGold because too few people appreciate Ho-Oh.

 

[polkop]

Simply, I will buy Soul Silver because I prefer Lugia.

 

[PokeBabe]

Soul Silver because of the awesome box art :]
And i just generally perfer Lugia over Ho-oh, even though you can get both in either of the games.
Ive also always perfered Ledian too.