4th Gen So, HeartGold, SoulSilver… whatcha getting?

[Zelda]

I am going to get Heart Gold because I like the name more than Soul Silver for some reason. Also because of how I have played Gold in the past.

 

[Tulips And Clover]

I'm getting SoulSilver. Just prefer the colour tbh

 

[Luck]

I'm getting heartgold, because gold is better than silver.

 

[Artemis]

I'm getting heartgold, because gold is better than silver.

Aren't they the same except for exclusives? Anyway, I'm getting both on my side...

 

[Zelda]

I am getting Heart Gold and Soul Silver. Heart Gold for me, and Soul Silver for my brother.

 

[ckret2]

SoulSilver. I've got Gold and Crystal, so getting SoulSilver will round out my Gen II game trio, in a roundabout way. :D Plus, I now think silver is prettier than gold, and I adore that little Lugia soul-fire-ball logo.

... Hey, they're basically the same game, I can base my decision on logos if I want. XD

I may change my mind when the games are released in Japan and we find out which Pokémon are exclusives to which games, so I can pick the one that has whatever Pokémon I'd rather catch; barring that, though, definitely SoulSilver.

 

[angelsavoir]

I clicked both. I will be getting Heart Gold for sure, and I will proablay get my younger brother Soul Silver.

 

[Heart]

I'm so totally going to get soul silver, just like lynnx said.

 

[K-K-Slider]

I'm getting Gold. I already have access to lots of Lugia's, but it's freaking hard to find a legitimate Ho-oh...

 

[Wolfwhispers]

Heart Gold first, as Gold version was the first of the Johto games I got, followed by Silver. After Gold, if I love it so much, I'll get the remade Gold version so that I don't have to start over. :)

 

[giradialkia]

I posted here before i think but i've decided what i'm getting-
Heart Gold. For reasons i don't quite understand...:
Lugia > Ho-Oh, IMO.
I've played all in the past, but Silver most diligently.
Soul Silver sounds far less cheesy than Heart Gold. (I mean I'll be treated like a tool in GameStop when i go to get Heart Gold- when i got Pearl, the shopkeeper basically peed his pants, because it's all white and pink. I can only imagine what'll happen when i go for a game called ''HeartGold''.
But i'm still getting it anyways. Just... Because.

 

[Jeremy]

I'm getting them both sweeties. X3 In Japanese and English. XD

Yeah, I'm a big fan of the Metal Generation if you're not aware, sweeties.

 

[Poliwagged]

I'm getting them both sweeties. X3 In Japanese and English. XD

Yeah, I'm a big fan of the Metal Generation if you're not aware, sweeties.

This is true dedication, bros.



As for me, I'm undecided.

 

[bian]

Pokemon Gold was my favorite Pokemon game, so I'll choose Heart Gold.

 

[Andrew McKenzie]

Simple Answer. I've always gotten the "second" game in the series and where it applies, I also obtained the "Special" game.
So in order: Blue, Yellow, Silver, Crystal, Sapphire, Emerald, LeafGreen, Pearl, (Planning on getting Platinum) and finally, I plan to get SoulSilver.
Not sure why I always got the second ones, they always seemed more appealing to me for some unknown reason.
Granted, I suppose it was the names and/or colours that appealed to me more.
Silver being my fave colour.

 

[indyracer500]

Both but i'm playing Soulsilver first.

 

[white lancer]

Simple Answer. I've always gotten the "second" game in the series and where it applies, I also obtained the "Special" game.
So in order: Blue, Yellow, Silver, Crystal, Sapphire, Emerald, LeafGreen, Pearl, (Planning on getting Platinum) and finally, I plan to get SoulSilver.
Not sure why I always got the second ones, they always seemed more appealing to me for some unknown reason.
Granted, I suppose it was the names and/or colours that appealed to me more.
Silver being my fave colour.

Haha, I've done the same thing and pretty much for the same reason (except I don't have Pearl/Platinum because I don't have a DS...yet). It was mostly for the colors, and I usually tended to prefer the mascots of the "second" one, as well (although Charizard > Venasaur). I'll probably get SoulSilver because I had Silver version, and because I prefer Lugia.

 

[SparklingMistral]

HeartGold. I played the original Silver version, so I think it'd be nice to switch it up a bit and get HeartGold. :)

I may get SoulSilver though. If there's any major differences between the two games. (Which I doubt. =/ But you never know. xD)

 

[Teh Blue Charzerd]

when i first got my gameboy color in my birthday, i bought pokemon silver the next day, so i am going with soul silver. for me its kinda batter then gold/heart gold for some reason.

 

[Extric]

No idea yet. I'm going to wait to see what the differences will be between the versions.