4th Gen So, HeartGold, SoulSilver… whatcha getting?

[Skip Class]

I had gold last time so I take it this time too!

 

[Captain Arcane]

I'll be buying both. There is no point in buying only one, even if you prefer one over another. But as a ritual, I always buy both.

 

[Lycaeus]

I'm getting both. I'll probably use Gold as my main and Silver as my solo/side/challenges/whatever.

Plus Cyndaquil looks better in Gold ;D lol.

 

[msdmario]

I was thinking about getting both first with Soul Silver being my primary game since that was the first version I bought when the 2nd generation came out.

After Kyorge was announced to be a Heart Gold exclusive, it made up my mind that I will end up getting both games since I prefer Kyorge over Groudon. Soul Silver is still going to be my primary game though.

 

[Johto's Best]

Heart Gold, because I got Gold before I got Silver.

 

[JukainPwns]

Soulsilver all the way mainly,because i played silver as a kid

 

[Ineffable~]

Well, I had Pokémon Gold while my sister had Pokémon Silver, but that's not why I'm getting Heartgold. It's really Kyogre that finally decided it, though it was preceded by my revelation that Sacred Fire was a physical move. I thought, "Now it makes sense that Ho-oh has higher Attack! I thought it just sucked!" I also like how the Japanese logo looks.

However, it may be the first time I get both. It has always been a tradition that I get the first version of a set, then the third version (for example: Red and Yellow, Gold and Crystal, Diamond and Platinum). The only discrepancy is that I got Sapphire (and Emerald) instead of Ruby. Again, because of Kyogre.
However, they'll probably follow FRLG and not make DawnCrystal (lol, that's how I imagine the name). And I somehow ended up getting both Firered and Leafgreen, so who knows? It'll probably all depend on whether or not they come out before my birthday. Then I can ask for them. But then again, I could just ask for money for my birthday, and pre-order Heartgold and Soulsilver to get the Ho-oh, Lugia, and Arceus figurines. Ooooohhhhh, so excited!

 

[Slashx69]

I'll be getting Soul Silver, because you get Groundon on it.Not Kyoger.

 

[Dialga812]

I like heart gold better :cer_smile: .....

 

[Dirtyjerry]

I'll be getting both. I can't help but to buy every proper pokemon game that comes out.

 

[Foo Fighter]

Hmm. HG because I loved gligar in the original and Ill probably love him in this one too.

 

[Pokedra]

I was thinking of SoulSilver but I'm considering HeartGold now. The exclusive Pokemon seem better in HeartGold.

 

[P l a t i n u m]

Soul Silver's The Game For Me.

P l a t i n u m​

 

[Anxiety.]

SS
I prefer Lugia overall.

And, if we are talking about the metals, Silver wins there too.

 

[Britney's Circus]

I've been thinking about it and since i first got Gold as my first ever Pokemon game then it's going to be Heart Gold.

 

[Cherish]

I will be getting both games. I plan on importing SS from Japan and then buy HG in English.

 

[JoltIce]

Soul Silver Because Lugia pwns.

 

[PKMNgamer]

I'm gonna download a ROM of... possibly Heart gold. when it comes out in japan. and I'll be buying both when they come out in North America. I might just start with Soul Silver first though, get HG later on. But definatly getting both. :D I never played Gold and Silver (CRYSTAL FTW) so I don;t really have anything to base my buy on, I did OWN silver though... Just never played it o.o

 

[Kagura]

Definitely getting Heart Gold first, since it was my first 2nd Gen game, and I just like the color. I won't mind some exclusives, I can just buy a used copy of SS somewhere, if there are any.

 

[ShadowChikorita]

Both. XD

But I'll probably end up playing SoulSilver more often, 'cause Lugia is awesome.