'H', please.
'S', please.
Not "Thief" for the third word. Not "Quiet" either. Leaves something like "Spiel", -ier, or -ied. Edit: Not "Spiel". Already guessed 'S'.
Probably "Quiets" for the fourth word. Maybe "Chaos" on the last word.
_________________
'O', please.
'U', please.
Crier for the third word, perhaps?
____________
'R', please.
Has a guess on the second word.
_____________
'C', please.
Is it "The Clumsy Crier Quiets the Chaos"?