2nd Gen The Real Which G/S/C Starter?

[BREAKINGBEN]

Cyndaquil was my first ever Pokemon. I was like 5 and I randomly chose it. It then became my only level 100 to date :).

Yes, I don't like to train after the Elite 4.

 

[zel 2.0]

I was thinking about this. Most of the time I have chosen Totodile, because I'm a water-type lover. But as time passed, I started to take a liking to Chikorita. I found that it has the skills I need. A decent attack power, good defense, and above all good defensive and healing skills.
Cyndaquil is a bit overused... :P

 

[yoshikiller995]

Totodile for me, he's the best imo.

 

[BeachBoy]

Well...I first picked Chikorita, and the memories I share with it are grand... :D So i Vote Totodile because it's water and dancing is too good! ;D agh...well it's between the two, *water bias kicks in*

Im going with totodile :D

 

[Philman]

I always liked Cyndaquil. I never think of these games in terms of strategy. Only what I feel is cool.

 

[Cactus Twist]

Cyndaquil is the best, though Totodile is also good, I've never really liked Chikorita

 

[Super Wario 64]

I chose Totodile on my Mono Water run on my crystal but most of the time, I choose Chikorita. Chiky's final evo is BL, better than its fire and water type companions

 

[*LuckyStarIsLucky*]

Totodile. helped me find shiny sentret at the beginning and is an aligatr.

 

[Mik]

Totodile, of course, it was on of my favourite pkmn in G/S **.
But i don't like Feraligatr movesets >.<

 

[Vaporeon7795]

dont kill me but...I really love Chickorita XD
"CHIKA" I SAY!! XD

 

[New Age Retro Hippie]

Cyndaquil, followed by Totodile. Never really liked little Chikorita...

 

[Thunder Beam]

I have always like Cyndaquil, I know that when I complete my Pokedex in Emerald, he is the one i'm going to get.

 

[Piplup-Trainer]

Totodile! I chose him in Pokemon Gold!