The hard part is to make the thread-
How about we make this our judging system? We choose a number between 0 and 10 (either a 0 or a 5 at the end, such as 1.5 or 7, but you can't do 6.3 until you multiply/divide) for each category and multiply our numbers by the percentage given. Then, we get the score and we all give our scores together via PM (time to donate!) where we just average the whole thing out between us three, and that's the score. If two people like something and give it 10, but the third person gives a 1, averaging it out would give it a 7.
Either way, this is how each category is influenced
Graphics- 30% (nobody loves bad graphics)
Music- 20%
AI- 40% (how many bugs have I seen in games, fixed E.T.)
Personal Preference- 10%
For example, if I give the following scores-
Graphics- 8
Music- 10
AI- 9
PP- 10
Then it would only equal to this-
Graphics- 2.4
Music- 2
AI- 3.6
PP- 1
Total- 9.0
So, my score would be 9.0. Now, if you two were to give 8.6 and 7.2, then the final score would be 8.3.
This is how I thought up of the scoring system in 5 minutes.