[What If] You could choose the first!

Gen II. It's style is more "charming" somehow, and I love the "traditional theme" of the game.
 
I'd have to say Gold/Silver/Crystal. Arguably still the best-designed one and a pretty awesome game all around.
 
I agree with the above answers, I think it would be neat to play through those and then go back to the Gen I games as a prequel later on.
 
If they weren't the first games to be released, Pokémon would be a lot more different than it is now, I imagine. Pokémon that were released in games such as Red and Blue set some sort of standard on how they should be, design-wise, so in terms of that, they would either resemble monsters more, or animals, all depending on whatever titles get made first other than these two (if that makes sense). Same could be applied to them stats-wise.

As for me--if it weren't Red, Blue, or Green, I'd personally prefer it to be Ruby, Sapphire, and Emerald. I'm kind of biased on this, as these are my most favorite games of all-time; though, they do have many things that would appeal among thousands of fans, with few being locations. Most of their towns, cities, and routes are pretty distinct from each other, and when exploring, you'd always be getting some new feel and experience.
 
I would have wanted R/S/E as the first then. I really enjoyed those games.
 
I agree with the Gold/Silver/Crystal option. To me it was simple enough to introduce all the core elements of the games (before all the extra things were added in the later gens I mean) and as it also presents Kanto to us, then FRLG still works as being released a generation afterwards.
 
I can definitely see an alternative path where GSC were released first, and then RBY were later released as "prequels" to the Johto games. Or, well I guess Yellow wouldn't have been released or it would be completely different (maybe even taking the place of Crystal?) because Ash's journeys in the anime would also be affected by the first game's change.

I'm not entirely sure how the the first games affected the franchise as a whole and I never really played them, but being the next oldest and having a great tie to the first ones, I think the GSC trio would work well.
 
Back
Top