2nd Gen What's your favorite starter?

[Darkness Assassin]

Ok guys. Totdile will always be my favorite. Water pokemon rule!!!! **** OTHER TYPE POKEMON!!!!!!!

 

[The Cynic]

Cyndaquil definately! Tis my favourite. Chikorita is quite bland and totodile just isn't my style.

For Gen I & II i picked the fire type as these are harder to find in the wild. By gen III I decided I would just pick the ones I liked rather that going for a set of pokemon that would have no type disadvantages overall.

Gen I & FR/LG : Charmander
Gen II & HG/SS: Cyndiquill
Gen III: Treecko
Gen IV: Turtwig

 

[white lancer]

When I was younger I would have picked Chikorita, but now it's Totodile without a doubt, although I'm not really a fan of its evolutions. My favorite one of them fully-evolved is Meganium.

 

[Tommmy]

I would always have chosen the fire one for some reason...

 

[Imperator161]

Totodile, as it's the starter I used in Gold (and Crystal). Cyndaquil is a close second, though. Chikorita's okay, but I don't like it as much as i like the other two.

 

[curiousnathan]

Well like majority, Cyndaquil.
I'm not sure why but I just think it looks cool and cute and when it evolves Typhlosion is really strong!

 

[Pokestick good times.]

Most say Cyndaquil's the best choice, and I like it alot.

If it matters, I guess I could just point out my four starter favs:
(the number means the generation)

1. Charmander
2. Cyndaquil
3. Mudkip
4. Turtwig

Wow, that was easier than I thought. I have no idea why I wrote all of them though.

 

[mondays suck]

Chikorita, Grass is one of the most fun types to play with, even though Chikorita doesn't get Leech Seed, at least not by level...

 

[SkyStar]

Chikorita Grass types are awesome

 

[Dhjona]

Cyndaquil, Fire types are awesome. ^^

 

[fsebastiao]

Cyndaquill , well, but thats because in every pokemon game i start with the fire starter, offtopic- started fire in D/P/P too and that was my biggest pokemon disappointment ever :(

 

[Reira]

I always choose Cyndaquil.

 

[SunStorm55]

Ah....

Come on! When I saw this forum I hoped you would include color games, because squirtle is my all time favorite starter! (Blastoise actually) Although if you are only doing II Generation, then it would be Cyndaquill.

 

[k.ks81]

my Favourite starter is cyndaquil

 

[RHCP]

To tell the truth, the earliest PKMN Game I've ever played is Ruby...
So I've never had to choose from the 2nd Gen starters! (Shocking, 'eh?)
But I will be choosing soon... (HG/SS)

 

[Demigod]

Totodile is win and funny

 

[branchi]

cyndaquil!!!!the awesome fire type!

 

[Maco]

Totodile. I've always chosen the water pokemon over every other, except in RBY (Charmander was too awesome)

 

[003]

I'd have to say Meganium. That thing DESTROYED in pkmn Silver for me. Can't wait to choose it again when the remakes come out.

 

[xJordan360]

Being a loyal fire fan, I'd have to go with Cyndaquil. I've never gone wrong with fire, and I always mono with it. :D Not to mention Typhlosion is complete and utter decimation contained in a red and white ball.