• Ever thought it'd be cool to have your art, writing, or challenge runs featured on PokéCommunity? Click here for info - we'd love to spotlight your work!
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.
    Register

5th Gen Where is Isshu? Confirmed - New York

Where is Isshu?

  • Total voters
    354
Status
Not open for further replies.
This is a theory I support, due to the bridges and layout. Shanghai it is for me.

[YouTube:8dLNZWejhqE]

(That's not me speaking - ahh!, I clicked the wrong one by mistake!)
 
MrCheeseQuack said:
This is a theory I support, due to the bridges and layout. Shanghai it is for me.

[YouTube:8dLNZWejhqE]

(That's not me speaking - ahh!, I clicked the wrong one by mistake!)
Click to expand...

:) yea i remember that one, its an old video. But we got even more landmarks now to connect to shanghai, and i predict some more when the games come out.
NYC itself cant be a region by its size, and the fact that its got no landmarks to connect it to isshu. At least not yet.
 
@ Coolnick not disputing your size of the region theory but maybe Isshu was meant to be a smaller region than all the others...not every nation in the world is the same size :P
 
Kizerzin said:
@ Coolnick not disputing your size of the region theory but maybe Isshu was meant to be a smaller region than all the others...not every nation in the world is the same size :P
Click to expand...

Maybe it was, but not the size of one city. Kanto and johto wee meant to be smaller regions. Isshu ofcourse has many towns, so I doubt theyd make it after one city.


rocky505 said:
how does liberty tower not connect to NYC?
Click to expand...

True, true. But still did you see the position of the lighthouse in isshu? If that is where liberty tower is, it woulndt make a connection to NYC being isshu, but it could still reference NY and its statue. But still it would be shanghai.
But idk. yet, we still need to see where liberty tower is, and if that "news" from pokemon pia meant that isshu is NYC(provided it isnt fake) then its official that it isnt shangha, but i highly doubt that outcome.
 
coolnick37 said:
Maybe it was, but not the size of one city. Kanto and johto wee meant to be smaller regions. Isshu ofcourse has many towns, so I doubt theyd make it after one city.




True, true. But still did you see the position of the lighthouse in isshu? If that is where liberty tower is, it woulndt make a connection to NYC being isshu, but it could still reference NY and its statue. But still it would be shanghai.
But idk. yet, we still need to see where liberty tower is, and if that "news" from pokemon pia meant that isshu is NYC(provided it isnt fake) then its official that it isnt shangha, but i highly doubt that outcome.
Click to expand...

Well that page looks like a cover, but it isn't, so I think it's a fake :P
 
pokewalker said:
Well that page looks like a cover, but it isn't, so I think it's a fake :P
Click to expand...

So do I. But we will just have to wait until it comes out, cause it might be like a second page or something. :S
 
Okay, I will say this for the last time.

It's. Not. A. Cover.

It's just a page inside. :|
 
Boarbeque said:
Why is this thread still up? What is there to discuss if it has already been confirmed as New York?
Click to expand...
wht,:S where? its not confirmed and it wont be confirmed ever.

@Surmonter the owner who posted this news said it was a cover, so thats why it is possible to assume it is fake, and btw we will see in 4 days so it doesnt matter much.
 
Even if it was confirmed; the thread would remain alive, to discuss how you think it's based on NY, etc (though when and if it gets confirmed, it won't stay alive for too long).
 
Well, if it is New York, the reason it may be based on only one city could now be that they are just gonna base more regions off a city from now on. If it's that you probably won't be able to travel to other regions much and they won't won't put them close together... but I see them doing other major cities in America and Europe (possibly Oceania area, though most likely as "sevii islands"). Paris would be epic! But I see no problem with it being based off of a smaller area. I mean, it's the area and land they're basing it off of, not using a city as-is for a country.
 
rocky505 said:
WPM himself says it is NYC and he said that magazine thing is real.
Click to expand...

o.o whos WPM? Lolz should have i already known who that is?

I just noticed on pokebeach that cover was beta so its probably real info, we will just have to w8 to see what it is about?
But I doubt it is talking about isshu.
Still tomorow we shall seeeeeeee :P
 
Last edited:
Isn't it possible that Isshu is based on nothing...? Just made up. I mean, it so inspirationless (is that a word?!). And if they would really base it on one of above mentioned cities/areas they would have made it more alike and easier to guess. I mean, the other regions were so recognizable. Almost all cities and important places were based on real stuff. And here? What, High Link being Central Park. Yeah right, and that desert is the parking place or what? I think GameFreak just broke another tradition here. Too bad really.
 
coolnick37 said:
o.o whos WPM? Lolz should have i already known who that is?

I just noticed on pokebeach that cover was beta so its probably real info, we will just have to w8 to see what it is about?
But I doubt it is talking about isshu.
Still tomorow we shall seeeeeeee :P
Click to expand...

If it's beta and wasn't published then there's obviously something wrong with it.

AKA they ran with a rumour/idea (like many people here) and Nintendo or whatever protested against it.

And no, I'm not pro-shanghai.
 
Jm20 said:
Isn't it possible that Isshu is based on nothing...? Just made up. I mean, it so inspirationless (is that a word?!). And if they would really base it on one of above mentioned cities/areas they would have made it more alike and easier to guess. I mean, the other regions were so recognizable. Almost all cities and important places were based on real stuff. And here? What, High Link being Central Park. Yeah right, and that desert is the parking place or what? I think GameFreak just broke another tradition here. Too bad really.
Click to expand...

Well i think it pretty much connects to shanghai like it did before with other regions. The city we know of the one below the lake is the same as shanghai area city(idk whats its called :P) and it is most probably its real-lie counterpart. As for shape, isshu is the same as shaghai are except for the central peninsula in shanghai which is a little bulky, but they changed parts of regions before too.
Id say its pretty much obvious that its shanghai....but we will see what pokemon pia has to say tomorow.
(at first i was thinking they based it nothing too, I voted for "somewhere else" :P but I changed my mind later)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top