• Ever thought it'd be cool to have your art, writing, or challenge runs featured on PokéCommunity? Click here for info - we'd love to spotlight your work!
  • It's time to vote for your favorite Pokémon Battle Revolution protagonist in our new weekly protagonist poll! Click here to cast your vote and let us know which PBR protagonist you like most.
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.
    Register

5th Gen Where is Isshu? Confirmed - New York

Where is Isshu?

  • Total voters
    354
Status
Not open for further replies.
Gymnotide said:
Wait, you can't even say that, since your whole argument is based on dissimilarities with New York. Shanghai isn't even the right shape. It's a triangle. If you argue that New York's shape isn't right, then neither is Shanghai's and the only thing we can conclude is that it's NEITHER. That's right. Neither. Now, I'm fine with it being neither of them, but basing your argument on the fact that it could possibly be one of two things and that if it's not one, then it has to be the other is faulty. In addition, your argument greatly fails in and of itself.

And for your information, the East River is NOT the Long Island Sound. It's a strait that runs FROM the Long Island Sound into the Atlantic Ocean.
Click to expand...

Palantides is a few days too late, anyway. Liberty Ticket and the American Football player quietly confirms NYC as Isshu.

And his comparisons made Isshu look more like the NYC area than Shanghai does, lmao.

GFA said:
That was incredibly stupid. Tokyo has a subway, London has a subway, LA has a subway, Berlin (I think) has a subway.

-

Because American Football is just a name of a sport. Theirs an American Football League in freaking Italy They'd call it Football, if you know, it hadn't already been taken by a game that actually uses your feat ... What's it called ... Soccer?
Click to expand...

Isshu isn't in Italy, though. Yes, many major cities have Subways (Shanghai included, for that matter), but does Isshu look anything like Tokyo (already used), London, LA or Berlin?
 
No it definitely doesn't.
 
Then what is your point because I don't see it.
 
That it could be anywhere. Arguing it has a Subway doesnt make it NYC. Or Tokyo. Or Shanghai. Or anywhere for that matter. It just helps certain people's arguments
 
WarpstarX said:
Then what is your point because I don't see it.
Click to expand...
He's saying that you can't use the subway or football as proof that it's based on NY as other cities and countries have subways and they also have Football teams ;)
 
it's more popular in America. Hey at least there's other countries that find rugby lame.
 
Shanghai theory just got pwned by the new pokemon revealed:
1- a deer, an american deer, like BAMBIE
(1 for NYC)
&
2- a swan, a white swan, like the ones you see in upper new york
(2 for NYC)

:P whoot NYC FTW! lol
 
Volroc said:
Shanghai theory just got pwned by the new pokemon revealed:
1- a deer, an american deer, like BAMBIE
(1 for NYC)
&
2- a swan, a white swan, like the ones you see in upper new york
(2 for NYC)

:P whoot NYC FTW! lol
Click to expand...
Well we had a deer in Gen 2...I don't think deers are Native to Japan so that isn't much proof, I mean we saw Elephants in Gen 2 does that mean it's Africa now?
 
Magmaruby and Aquasapphire said:

Well we had a deer in Gen 2...I don't think deers are Native to Japan so that isn't much proof, I mean we saw Elephants in Gen 2 does that mean it's Africa now?
Click to expand...

have you seen it yet?

its bambie how more obvious can it get?

ive seen bambie, made by disney, its a copy& paste, if that doesnt give it away, nothing will

edit: stantler is a reindeer btw :P
 
Magmaruby and Aquasapphire said:

Well we had a deer in Gen 2...I don't think deers are Native to Japan so that isn't much proof, I mean we saw Elephants in Gen 2 does that mean it's Africa now?
Click to expand...

Their are deer native to Japan. Especially in Nara ...

Anywho, it'd be cool if it was base off of America. Japan started getting boring with Hoenn. Though Sinnoh was done pretty well.
 
GFA said:
Their are deer native to Japan. Especially in Nara ...

Anywho, it'd be cool if it was base off of America. Japan started getting boring with Hoenn. Though Sinnoh was done pretty well.
Click to expand...

see, i didnt even need to say it, i win :P
 
Volroc said:
Shanghai theory just got pwned by the new pokemon revealed:
1- a deer, an american deer, like BAMBIE
(1 for NYC)
&
2- a swan, a white swan, like the ones you see in upper new york
(2 for NYC)

:P whoot NYC FTW! lol
Click to expand...

IMO that's dumber than the subway and american football talk.
 
Oh I didn't know about the Deer in Japan, you learn something new everyday :).
Though the species of Pokemon doesn't prove anything really, they had the Swallow tail butterfly in Hoenn does that make it Oregon (the state butterfly)?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top