Which would you choose?

[CrazyCarretta]

There are plenty of good choices. It's close between Eevee, Growlith, or Charmander

 

[Superjub]

Duh, Jirachi. :D
Then I could wish for an Torchic and an Eevee, among other things. ;)
Plus, Jirachi is like my second\third faourite Pokemon. :D

 

[Kasiren]

I say Magikarp. :D

After all of that long, hard, and very annoying training, it evolves into my all time favorite Pokemon. I am closer to nothing more than my Gyarados.

 

[mahamaniac3]

I would definately have either Miltank or Mantine.

 

[Ruphire]

I would choose Zubat.

It evolves into my favorite pokemon, Crobat.

 

[SonicThrust]

Shinx, it's just so cute ~.

It's also the only one of my favourites I think would actually make a decent starter...

 

[Dialga911]

although it's already a starter, I'd choose Cyndaquil. If you can look at my picture, then you'd know why.

Mew

I WILL NOT CHOOSE MEWTWO
MEWTWO IS WEAKER THEN MY GRANNY
HE IS SO COPYING MEW

Then why does Mewtwo have more power than Mew?Why are his stats better?Mew can learn almost every move, (I'm pretty sure it can't learn Blastburn, Frenzyplant, and Hydrocannon)but Mewtwo has better stats by far.Oh, and by the way, first post said don't choose a legendary.

 

[roacherman]

Lets see, if a legendary then Celebi (duh)

If not then Magikarp, after all IT DOES evolve to Gyrados right?

(plus I just like to see it splash XD phail)

 

[mickyching]

My favorite will always and forever be Charmander. He is so adorable, and he is one of the originals (I like the original pokemon better). Behind him, is Growlithe. He is an original, and a puppy, so I like him a lot.

 

[Nightstar]

I'd choose Ponyta so I wouldn't have to walk everywhere! :P
Besides, Ponyta would evolve into Rapidash, which is one of my favorite Pokemon!!

 

[Aberbecam]

Uhmmm..I should say torchic. because it evolves into combuskin and that combuskin evolves into one of my top 10 favorite pokemon blazekin.

 

[GlitchCity]

mine would be pidgey or dratini

 

[Esper]

I assume that I wouldn't get the pokemon custom ordered to my specifications so I'd just take the first well behaved pokemon that looked like it needed a good home. I'd rather have a good natured Bidoof than a foul-tempered Charmander.

 

[Dragon Song]

Well...
hard choice. X.X
Bidoof and Bibarel are so cute : )
Or maybe a Dratini, Dragonair is one of my favorites.
Cyndaquil is amazing...and I love Ponyta.
I like Starly, too, more than Pidgey.
But I think I might have to get a Tentacool or a Staryu.

Well, if I was in Sinnoh, I'd go with Chikorita. : )

 

[BoreanWolf]

Larvitar, Bulbasaur, Male Nidoran or Female Nidoran.

 

[RocketAdmin.]

Well if they ever make a Pre-Evo of Sneasel it would defo be that :D

 

[LiekingOfMudkipz]

O.o I never really thought of that. Mine would be a Stunky. Even if they smell I could use it to my advantage. Heh heh.

 

[RocketAdmin.]

Mew

I WILL NOT CHOOSE MEWTWO
MEWTWO IS WEAKER THEN MY GRANNY
HE IS SO COPYING MEW

Well that's the most stupid comment I've ever read....
Overall Mewtwo has the highest base stats (excl. Arceus duh)
Sooooooo you might wanna rephrase that.

:D

 

[The Apprentice™]

Hmm I would choose.....Growlithe. It's loyal and also it evolves into Arcanine. ^^