Why is Pokemon considered childish?

Satoshi-Ash

Master Chris
    • 142
    Posts
    17
    Years
    Pokemon, which was one of the biggest hits in America, from when the manga arrived, to when Red and Blue were released. Now it is considered childish. Why is this? Was Pokemon(the manga) originally intended to target children? Or is it now considered childish because of the influence from the anime?

    What do you think?
     
    Satoshi-Ash said:
    Pokemon, which was one of the biggest hits in America, from when the manga arrived, to when Red and Blue were released. Now it is considered childish. Why is this? Was Pokemon(the manga) originally intended to target children? Or is it now considered childish because of the influence from the anime?

    What do you think?
    Click to expand...

    The Videogames came first :/

    Everything else is based around them, including the Manga. Now, I should also note there are about 20+ Different Pokemon Manga, More than one of which are still running.
     
    Satoshi-Ash said:
    Pokemon, which was one of the biggest hits in America, from when the manga arrived, to when Red and Blue were released. Now it is considered childish. Why is this? Was Pokemon(the manga) originally intended to target children? Or is it now considered childish because of the influence from the anime?

    What do you think?
    Click to expand...

    maybe because it was started when i was in kindergarden and targeted specifically to my age group so it is still considered childish
     
    The fact that the main character is about 10 years old... Now if the first game had a main character 20-years old. Where would this franchise be now?
     
    because Ash can never act mature for once and the fact that he is sometimes childish.
     
    Bamachi said:
    because Ash can never act mature for once and the fact that he is sometimes childish.
    Click to expand...

    good point he refuses to change his clothes to >.< and whenever something he loves is in danger he must shout out to them and then take a dramatic pause to turn his hat and also is ash retarded he LOVES that hat its like an obsession does he have OCD? ever notice he almost got killed jumping off a cliff trying to catch it in one of the episodes?
     
    If anything, the TV show influences most people's opinions on the franchise, as TV is the the favorite pastime of most developed countries. The TV Show is targeted at an audience younger than even the Videogames are, and as such, everyone, including fans, make genralizations about the franchise by what they see on the show (EX: Incorrectly calling Red Ash, and Green/Blue Gary, treating the Orange Islands like a real Region, ect.)

    Videogame Canon = The TRUE Canon, set by gamefreak.
     
    Some trainer classes in the first generation were depicted holding whips... I'm not sure what to think of that but it's evident from the pre-anime game generation that Pokemon was more of a teen than child thing. Shame it got buggered over, really.

    Ausaudriel said:
    They're really indepth RPGs and people recognize that.
    Click to expand...
    I never saw how Pokemon was in-depth at all.
     
    Ausaudriel said:
    Um, all of the different aspects involved in training Pokemon? O_o EV training, initial stats, breeding, TMs, and a billion other things.
    Click to expand...


    i think she meant the anime or some kind of lesson or moral
     
    Flex_S said:
    The fact that the main character is about 10 years old... Now if the first game had a main character 20-years old. Where would this franchise be now?
    Click to expand...
    XD down a drain? in a trash can?

    anyways, I don't know its probably cause 1 person said it was lame then everyone else copied him/her
     
    I personally think the games are targeted towards tweens, and young adults, in my opinion.
     
    Honestly, if you first look at Pokemon it does appear to be childish. Pikachu's appearance gives off the impression that it's a childs' series. Not to mention that the intention of creating monsters seems like it was intended towards the younger audience. Look at it from a neutral point of view though. It's basically fictional creatures (like animals) being trained by their master and sent to battle another one. It's quite childish if you look at it this way. In this case, the majority of the USA look at Pokemon this way. They can't talk, they can only say their names. But meh, not many people will be even willing to start their interest in Pokemon because of their strongly biased views on it, which is also highly influenced by what their friends think. Like Ausaudriel said, I too have a hard time taking the anime seriously nowadays.

    I mean, it's a cartoon. When kids age, they'll move apart from their cartoon TV shows and stuff. It's not a show that looks serious at all. The games are however more complex, but people usually wouldn't even want to try the games, and therefore will never know how complex the games really are.
     
    its childish because it is.
    The games involve single handedly destroying an evil organization as a kid.
    the anime is also childish, not to mention the people who make the dubs now ruin everything.
    Not to mention the cute monsters you catch in capsules.
    it seems really childish, and its supposed to be because its not aimed at the older audience.
    Of course, it does involve strategy and thinking(in the games), so it would seem childish at first glance.
    Tsk tsk tsk, if only nintendo made pokemon hard(er).
     
    Because it's meant for all ages which some how translates to child.
     
    It's a cartoon. Cartoons used to automatically be for children. Just about every animated movie till very recently was automatically given a G rating, regardless of content. These days you do see more PG and such animated movies, plus adult cartoons such as South Park. But Pokemon just fell into the "it's a cartoon so it's for kids" trap.
     
    An anime is different from a cartoon, so that's irrelevant. And I mean Pokemon in general.
     
    Satoshi-Ash said:
    An anime is different from a cartoon, so that's irrelevant. And I mean Pokemon in general.
    Click to expand...

    Anime = Cartoon made in another country (besides the US). So no, you fail.

    There is no real difference between an Anime and a cartoon other than cosmetic differences and the amount of violence that is allowed in it. If the tables were turned, would we be calling our own shows Anime? Nope.


    Pokemon is probably considered childish because alot of people don't look beyond the fact that there are cute animals in the show.
     
    Probably because of the 8+ rating on the games, people consider games cool when they're like MA 15+, but they haven't played the games.

    They're just putting it into a category because they judge the games by their cases, not the gameplay.
     
    You must log in or register to reply here.
    Back
    Top