Graphic Rating Thread

[Sylver]

Poor you... I know a tutorial that learns you how to do the same effect in ps in max 3 min, lol

 

[QuickDude]

someone rate my pimp sig and avatar

 

[DarkPegasus]

Looks cool to me ^_^

Anyway this is my first attemp at making sig in PS:

I know it's a bit dark, but it's ment to be that way(yes I know about the hue/saturation and duplicate layer and make it overlay).

 

[Composer of Requiems]

Looks cool to me ^_^

Anyway this is my first attemp at making sig in PS:

I know it's a bit dark, but it's ment to be that way(yes I know about the hue/saturation and duplicate layer and make it overlay).

Font in bottom right is a *bit* hard to read.

 

[Blitz~2005]

This one is abit big, So I made a smaller version for my sig

 

[Geometric-sama]

I've got some stuff for rating! My avatar, my sig, this icon and banner:

and this wallpaper I made: http://img219.imageshack.us/my.php?image=air39xz.jpg

All due to my Misuzu mode XD

 

[Blitz~2005]

The avatar is good, But it probibly needs some wrighting on it, 9.5/10

THe banner is great, Good compasition, Great use of patterns, 10/10

The wallpaper is good, But the pattern on that one kinda anoot's me, I give it 9/10

If i was to rate them all as one it would be a 9.5/10


Now rate mine, COz Mine didn't get rated :(

 

[Geometric-sama]

OK, I'll rate yours, then you have to rate the avatar and sig image I'm using (they're all part of the set :))

I don't know much about Naruto :) The banner is pretty cute though. The image you used is nice and cartoonish, nice font, but I don't like the way the circles blend into the background. 8/10

 

[Tommeh Smiff]

These were quick experiments with masking in PS, any good?

If you look closely, the line overlapping the "EH" in the first one shines slightly, as does Auron's Sword.​

 

[Sawyer]

peoplel shouldn't have to put text in their avatars. in fact, almost nobody does. Tommeh Smiff, your text and picture effects aren't too bad, but... the bg on the second one is really repetitive. and make the line and the sword's animation a little more noticeable.

 

[Blitz~2005]

OK, I'll rate yours, then you have to rate the avatar and sig image I'm using (they're all part of the set :))

I don't know much about Naruto :) The banner is pretty cute though. The image you used is nice and cartoonish, nice font, but I don't like the way the circles blend into the background. 8/10

Oh in that case, (i have rated the rest)

Your sig deserves a 9/10

and avatar a 10/10 :D

 

[Geometric-sama]

Thanks for your ratings XD. Was my rating of yours OK?

 

[Blitz~2005]

Yeah, Its your opinion not mine XD


Well keep up the good art :D

 

[Kurosaki]

Nice JA! Misuzu~ <3 9/10 - Something seems off about the banner, but I can't identify it.

I don't want my banner and avy rated, since I threw them togther in 5 minutes on PSP8, XD

 

[Geometric-sama]

I'd love to rate them anyway XD. SHUFFLE! is win, we showed some of it at our last club marathon.

 

[Mari]

JA, <3! It's Misuzu-chan~! <333 And it ish blue, too! :3 I wish I could read what was written though. :o Your avvy ish very nice too. I like how the piccies overlay. ;3

Davey-chan, yours ish awesome~! ;o

 

[Sawyer]

i can't rate it?! it's amazing, Yukito! perfect color scheme for grunginess, and brown and blue go well together x3

 

[Stevo-kun]

I would like someone to rate my current sig and avy, I made them XD *points to avy and sig* XD

 

[Geometric-sama]

They're OK, but a bit dark, and I have no idea what they say XD. The background in the sig is kind of boring.

 

[Stevo-kun]

Thanks for the comment ^^. Well I have an alternate version, plus I am kinda new to grunging XD

With coloured face

Blue face XD

There it is, tell me what ya think