So I'm voting for Bulbasaur, but I have to be honest, though I know it's cliche, I would vote for Pikachu if it was an option, primarily because pokemon yellow was my first game, and I enjoyed using him so much in that game(yes, I am that old school, lol). Though I have wondered if I would have enjoyed him so much if I didn't have such easy access to the other three starters. That def made it more fun.